Behind a thousand miles
Amde Sidik
I sense there aren't going to be a lot of changes in the way our political leaders are behaving, unless they undergo an overnight heart cleansing or brain surgery in which by the time the nomination day is announced they are not yet fully recovered.
I mean if they are really wanted to topple BN government. (I've written about this subject many times)
By the way let me share my raw analysis why BN won handsomely in the recent Sarawak State General Election.
With fierce new political campaign's culture of Malaysian politics now, brought over crossed South China Sea; character assassination, abusive words and racist remarks. Outrageously immoral and unIslamic twenty years ago, now pasted with stickers, Halal sign on it, who are we to say?
It started by Mahathir during his era and the trend is getting worse by day.
Handsomely I mean, PBB fielded 35 candidates all won, SUPP won 6, and PRS won 8 and SPDP won 6. BN therefore won 55 out of 71 state seats. Not bad.
The result was nonetheless impressive for a man hated most by State's urbanites which result can be translated that nearly all in urban areas cleaned swift by DAPP.
The biggest puzzle, despite hatred at Sarawak's Chief, this urban paranoia didn't spread out to rural.
While no doubt the Chinese voters were focused, believing what they believed in but the belief didn't extent to rural areas because roads to kampong are filthy and unhygienic?
Sarawak BN position was intact, fully supported by the bumi's category including the Dayak group
It can be translated this way, Chinese were very much looking at bigger picture of Malaysia. They wanted a change in Malaysia politic, they were thinking about the whole system.
Likewise the Bumi let the Chinese believe of their view. Fear of DAP is exaggerated because DAP power has a ceiling. There is no way DAP can form a government; let them win because they can work like dog.
The Bumi believe a complete democratising Malaysia isn't good for them. They fear if the Chinese have free hand everywhere they could be sold out. That fear isn't come so much from Sarawak Chinese, but DAP Chinese from Malaya having learnt DAP's history. (Watch DAP proposal for merger with SNAP)
With electrifying onslaught from opposition, another Malayan's opposition political party namely PKR, where many onlookers had the impression PKR could topple BN. Inspired by the fogy image, PKR leaders became bigheaded, refused to budge even an inch. Knowingly, very unnecessary to field up more than 20seats,let alone talking about all state seats, they offered SNAP only 3 seats? It must be with the idea to kill SNAP; the result backfired, like curiosity kills the cat. Wonder if they dare to try again in Sabah?
I was in the coastal areas of Sarawak-Limbang to Bintulu throughout the campaign period. Lot wanted to vote for SNAP but SNAP was not seen to make any headway, had no infrastructure readied, some candidates fielded were dead wood-kayu mati they called.
Sarawak Bumi discreetly talked about Sabah being colonised by UMNO. Sabah people can't do much, everything else is referred to KL, may be one day even to look for a wife need approval from Putrajaya.
They were incidents that Sabahans asked to go to Putrajaya to collect their uncollected mykads, isn't that not frightening George said.
Sarawak local wouldn't want this to happen in Sarawak. Those tried bringing UMNO to Sarawak were insane, Latiff said, an opposition supporter from Benkenu but would vote BN on the issue of local Sarawak interest.
Vote PKR Sarawak, this is exactly a copycat of Sabah has UMNO and Sarawak has PKR?
Their choice was no choice but come back to square one. No matter how bad Taib Mahmud is but people of Sarawak choose Taib Mahmud not by PM of Malaysia.
Sarawak BN didn't do the campaign as fierce as opposition did, what they had in many kampongs were karaoke singing and kenduris of course, pulus la!.
Which means, Sarawak is for Sarawakians.
"You're not politician but more of a writer, are you?" asked by an elderly person in Miri. My reply was yes and no
Amdee Sidik is a Citizen Journalist and Deputy President of SAPP
Showing posts with label Sarawak Election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sarawak Election. Show all posts
Sunday, May 15, 2011
Wednesday, April 27, 2011
Betulkah semua Cina Sarawak benci BN?
KUALA LUMPUR: Walaupun sudah seminggu berlalu, keputusan pilihan raya negeri (PRN) Sarawak masih menjadi topik perbincangan khususnya mengenai gelombang pengundi Cina yang dilihat telah menolak Barisan Nasional (BN) di negeri itu.
Perkembangan ini menimbulkan kebimbangan tentang kemungkinan wujudnya trend polarisasi seperti yang dipamerkan oleh pengundi Cina di Semenanjung Malaysia.
Bagaimanapun, analisis menunjukkan bahawa pengundi Cina di Sarawak tidak menolak BN sepenuhnya.
Pada PRN Sarawak ke-10 baru-baru ini, pengundi Cina di kawasan bandar dikatakan mengundi DAP untuk mempamerkan kebosanan dan rasa tidak puas hati mereka yang begitu mendalam terhadap Parti Rakyat Bersatu Sarawak (SUPP) yang mereka lihat gagal memperjuangkan kepentingan mereka.
Ramai ahli politik, pemimpin masyarakat dan individu Cina di negeri itu berkata mereka tidak faham kenapa ada ahli politik tertentu cuba membuat tafsiran tentang keputusan pilihan raya negeri itu berdasarkan kaum.
Kaum Cina di Sarawak berkata kebanyakan orang luar membuat andaian silap mengenai keputusan pilihan raya berkenaan kerana mereka tidak memahami gaya politik tempatan.
Mereka berkata kebanyakan orang Cina mengundi pembangkang, terutama DAP, untuk memberi isyarat jelas bahawa mereka sudah bosan dengan perkara tertentu, termasuk faktor yang melibatkan Ketua Menteri Tan Sri Abdul Taib Mahmud dan timbalannya Tan Sri Dr George Chan.
“Pertama ialah untuk memprotes kedudukan Taib yang didakwa menguasai begitu banyak kepentingan perniagaan dan kedua, untuk menunjukkan protes mereka terhadap SUPP di bawah pimpinan Chan yang tidak memainkan peranannya untuk menolong rakyat yang diwakilinya,” kata seorang pemimpin masyarakat dari Sibu.
Beliau berkata sekiranya benar semua orang Cina benci BN, sudah tentu mereka bertindak secara habis-habisan untuk memastikan BN tidak mendapat majoriti dua pertiga, memandangkan ramai juga pengundi Bumiputera menolak BN di sesetengah kawasan.
“Ia lebih merupakan protes mengenai isu tempatan, bukan terhadap BN secara menyeluruh. Jika tidak, tentulah tidak terdapat lebih 20 peratus undi kaum Cina yang berpihak kepada BN,” katanya.
Isu terkini mengenai Taib, yang mungkin merupakan antara ahli politik paling berpengalaman di Malaysia, ialah berkaitan begitu banyak kepentingan perniagaan yang dikuasai oleh keluarganya dan perkara ini menjadi perhatian utama pengundi, khususnya dari kawasan bandar dan pinggir bandar.
Satu lagi perkara yang dijadikan isu besar oleh pembangkang pada pilihan raya baru-baru ini ialah tempoh Taib menerajui negeri itu yang telah begitu lama dan wujudnya gesaan secara senyap dalam kalangan pelbagai pihak agar beliau berundur. Malah, selepas pilihan raya itu, isu berkenaan masih hangat.
Seorang lagi pemimpin masyarakat Cina berkata kebanyakan pengundi Cina tidak menentang BN secara sepenuhnya, dan menurut beliau: “Apa yang kami mahu ialah agar beberapa ketidakadilan dan keadaan yang merugikan kami, diperbetulkan. Kami hanya orang biasa yang bersungut tentang perkara yang dianggap wajar.”
Di sebalik semua itu, kata beliau, Taib tetap berjaya menerajui BN untuk mengekalkan majoriti dua pertiga dalam Dewan Undangan Negeri dengan agak mudah.
Malah, parti pimpinan beliau, Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu, menang kesemua 35 kerusi yang ditandinginya dengan memperoleh 68.3 peratus undi popular.
Pengundi Cina juga, kata pemimpin masyarakat itu, mengharapkan agar kebimbangan mereka, apabila melihat anak mereka terpaksa meninggalkan Sarawak untuk mencari rezeki di tempat lain dan penyelesaian dicari kepada iklim perniagaan yang tidak memberangsangkan.
“Dalam hal ini, SUPP dilihat gagal menyalurkan kebimbangan sebenar dan sungutan pengundi yang tinggal di kawasan tradisinya,” katanya.
Pemimpin Cina Sibu, Temenggong Vincent Lau, membuat kesimpulan menarik mengenai anggapan masyarakat Cina di Sarawak terhadap SUPP dengan berkata: “Setiap kali mereka (SUPP) membuat keputusan, ia sama ada silap atau tidak mempunyai arah tuju politik. Itulah sebabnya orang hilang keyakinan terhadap parti itu.”
Lau berkata para pemimpin SUPP perlu melakukan muhasabah diri dan berhenti daripada bercakaran sesama mereka kerana perbuatan itu telah menjerumuskan parti berkenaan ke dalam satu demi satu krisis dan akhirnya menyebabkan ia mencatat pencapaian buruk pada pilihan raya negeri kali ini.
“Sekiranya mereka terus bergaduh sesama sendiri, maka parti itu mungkin terpaksa tutup kedai. Jika ini terjadi, ia memalukan masyarakat Cina di negeri ini dan sudah tentulah, perkara sebegitu tidak ingin dilihat oleh rakyat,” katanya.
Lau berkata berdasarkan pengamatannya, para pemimpin, pekerja parti dan anggota peringkat akar umbi dalam SUPP, telah gagal bekerja sebagai suatu pasukan sejak beberapa tahun lepas dan inilah yang menyebabkan parti itu menjadi tidak berkesan dan dilihat sebagai “menipu rakyat.”
Oleh itu, katanya, tidak hairanlah semakin ramai yang bosan dengan SUPP dan kegagalan parti itu menunaikan janjinya telah menyebabkan mereka berpaling tadah serta memberi undi kepada DAP.
Mungkinkah kewujudan sebuah parti baru berasaskan kaum Cina boleh menjadi jawapannya?
- Bernama
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Pundit: Sarawak losses fatal if PKR doesn’t buck up
Sheridan Mahavera
PKR was over-dependent on Anwar during the Sarawak campaign, said Aeria.
PKR’s dismal performance in the Sarawak election is a disturbing omen of how the party will fare in the next general election unless it institutes painful changes, a political analyst said last night.
Political scientist Dr Andrew Aeria said the party organised a respectable pre-election training programme but it ultimately foundered in making use of those preparations during the campaigning period.
“The campaign itself was too Anwar-centric,” said Aeria, referring to PKR de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim who criss-crossed Sarawak to campaign for PKR.
“And they did not offer an alternative to the policies the Barisan Nasional was offering. If it was change, then change to what? That’s what people want to know,” Aeria told a forum here last night on the election results and its implications.
He added that if the party hopes to do well, the PKR also needed to replace its “re-recycled leaders” with new ones and have stronger grassroots machinery.
This, however, did not mean that BN could automatically defeat PKR and wrest back lost seats and Selangor, a state where the former is the dominant party in the Pakatan Rakyat government.
Aeria, of Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, said BN must also put through meaningful reforms if it wants to recapture the trust of a public weary of sloganeering.
The PKR fielded 49 candidates in the Sarawak election — the most out all PR and BN parties — but only managed to win three seats: Ba Kelalan, Krian and Batu Lintang.
Its PR partner, DAP, on the other hand, won 12 of the 15 seats it contested. Islamist party PAS won none of the five seats it contested.
BN was able to retain the two-thirds majority in the Sarawak state assembly when it won 55 seats. However, it only secured 54.5 per cent of the popular vote.
Aeria described PKR’s Sarawak campaign as “paradoxical” as it was organised and, at the same time, dysfunctional.
The PKR held pre-election training programmes for polling and counting agents, and for potential candidates.
It also had the support of local non-governmental organisations to tap into widespread anger among Dayaks over ancestral land disputes.
Yet when it came time to the actual campaign, the party was torn by factionalism and infighting between local influential figures over who gets to be a candidate, he said.
“Some candidates were even residing in Kuala Lumpur and flew back to stand in their area. In some places, there was not even a grassroots machinery to help them campaign.
At an earlier press conference, PKR strategy director Rafizi Ramli admitted the party was stretched thinly across the 49 seats. However, it was forced to do so because it did not want to give BN walkover victories in 24 seats.
Initially, PKR had only wanted to contest in 25 seats where it had established a presence and was confident of gaining support.
But it was forced to contest in these 24 other seats because neither of its partners wanted to step up and “share the burden” of standing against the BN, Rafizi said.
PKR’s final decision to stand in these “unwinnable” areas crimped the party’s ability to pool its resources and focus on the 25 seats which it stood an even chance of winning.
Aeria noted that a weakness in the PR campaign was that each party’s grassroots machinery did not work each other.
“There was a lot of co-operation between the leaders of each party in how they staged ceramah together. But there was no cooperation at the grassroots level”.
“Moving forward, all parties, whether in BN or PR need to reform and renew. The electorate is more interested in substantive issues but the parties seem stuck in the past,” Aeria said.
PKR was over-dependent on Anwar during the Sarawak campaign, said Aeria.
PKR’s dismal performance in the Sarawak election is a disturbing omen of how the party will fare in the next general election unless it institutes painful changes, a political analyst said last night.
Political scientist Dr Andrew Aeria said the party organised a respectable pre-election training programme but it ultimately foundered in making use of those preparations during the campaigning period.
“The campaign itself was too Anwar-centric,” said Aeria, referring to PKR de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim who criss-crossed Sarawak to campaign for PKR.
“And they did not offer an alternative to the policies the Barisan Nasional was offering. If it was change, then change to what? That’s what people want to know,” Aeria told a forum here last night on the election results and its implications.
He added that if the party hopes to do well, the PKR also needed to replace its “re-recycled leaders” with new ones and have stronger grassroots machinery.
This, however, did not mean that BN could automatically defeat PKR and wrest back lost seats and Selangor, a state where the former is the dominant party in the Pakatan Rakyat government.
Aeria, of Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, said BN must also put through meaningful reforms if it wants to recapture the trust of a public weary of sloganeering.
The PKR fielded 49 candidates in the Sarawak election — the most out all PR and BN parties — but only managed to win three seats: Ba Kelalan, Krian and Batu Lintang.
Its PR partner, DAP, on the other hand, won 12 of the 15 seats it contested. Islamist party PAS won none of the five seats it contested.
BN was able to retain the two-thirds majority in the Sarawak state assembly when it won 55 seats. However, it only secured 54.5 per cent of the popular vote.
Aeria described PKR’s Sarawak campaign as “paradoxical” as it was organised and, at the same time, dysfunctional.
The PKR held pre-election training programmes for polling and counting agents, and for potential candidates.
It also had the support of local non-governmental organisations to tap into widespread anger among Dayaks over ancestral land disputes.
Yet when it came time to the actual campaign, the party was torn by factionalism and infighting between local influential figures over who gets to be a candidate, he said.
“Some candidates were even residing in Kuala Lumpur and flew back to stand in their area. In some places, there was not even a grassroots machinery to help them campaign.
At an earlier press conference, PKR strategy director Rafizi Ramli admitted the party was stretched thinly across the 49 seats. However, it was forced to do so because it did not want to give BN walkover victories in 24 seats.
Initially, PKR had only wanted to contest in 25 seats where it had established a presence and was confident of gaining support.
But it was forced to contest in these 24 other seats because neither of its partners wanted to step up and “share the burden” of standing against the BN, Rafizi said.
PKR’s final decision to stand in these “unwinnable” areas crimped the party’s ability to pool its resources and focus on the 25 seats which it stood an even chance of winning.
Aeria noted that a weakness in the PR campaign was that each party’s grassroots machinery did not work each other.
“There was a lot of co-operation between the leaders of each party in how they staged ceramah together. But there was no cooperation at the grassroots level”.
“Moving forward, all parties, whether in BN or PR need to reform and renew. The electorate is more interested in substantive issues but the parties seem stuck in the past,” Aeria said.
Pakatan may falter with early Taib exit, analysts say
Clara Chooi
PETALING JAYA, April 27 — Political analysts have warned that Pakatan Rakyat (PR) could lose its momentum in Sarawak should Chief Minister Tan Sri Abdul Taib Mahmud resign before the next general election.
In their analysis of the just-concluded state polls, the scholars pointed out last night without the “anti-Taib” rallying cry to unite opposition supporters, Barisan Nasional (BN) may regain its lost votes — particularly from the rural communities.
As such, they said all PR parties — including DAP — needed to quickly formulate a new strategy that would bring their campaign beyond the anti-Taib sentiment and penetrate deeper into the interiors of the hornbill state where BN’s vote bank lies.
Political scientist Wong Chin Huat said DAP could not afford to rest on its laurels and expect its victories to repeat in the coming polls without working hard to keep its message alive among its supporters.
“PR will go forward but can it continue to maintain its dominance in urban Sarawak?
“Taib is now seen as a ‘rural CM’. Will he go before the federal elections? If he does, the opposition cannot campaign against him [any] longer because you cannot find a leader more hated than him.
“But can they survive without Taib?” he said during a Merdeka Center forum on the April 16 Sarawak state polls held at the Hilton Hotel here last night.
Wong pointed out that failure to perform well in Sarawak during the general election would mirror PR’s failure to wrest control of Putrajaya.
This, he said, was because by remaining in the opposition, PR parties would find it hard to prove to voters that they could do better than the ruling government.
“Like in Sarawak... can DAP do better than SUPP in government? They need to be remembered... they need to show that although they are in the opposition, they are really driving the state forward,” he said.
Wong said PR needed to offer “something” tangible to Sarawak voters to keep their support from
dissipating, stressing on an often-raised point that the political expectations of east Malaysians vastly differed from those of the peninsula voters.
“PR does not have a policy for Sarawak. Its urban centre is stuck now as there is a stagnation in development so PR needs to offer something.
“(Penang Chief Minister) Lim Guan Eng came in to speak about offering free WiFi to Sarawakians but that is a West Malaysian thing; it’s different in Sarawak,” he pointed out.
Universiti Malaysia Sarawak (Unimas) Associate Professor Dr Andrew Aeria agreed, noting PR’s message to voters was to “change” but that the pact had failed to explain the alternatives.
“You tell them to change but change for what? Do not forget, BN has an economic policy in place and whether we like to admit it or not, people have benefitted.
“PR has not come up with an economic programme for Sarawak... so if you want to dislodge their programme, you need to come up with something better,” he warned.
He agreed with a comment from the audience that while many voters were unhappy with Taib’s 30-year rule, they still voted him into power as it was better to vote for “the devil they know”.
“True, it is always better to be safe than sorry and voters are very rational that way. Until and unless you can provide them with a better alternative, they would not want to risk it.
“This sentiment may not be shared by the urban communities but for those in the rural areas, losing BN is seen as very risky,” he explained.
Universiti Malaysia Sarawak (Unimas) lecturer Dr Faisal Syam Hazis concurred with his fellow academicians, adding that all three PR parties needed to pool their resources and begin working the ground immediately to prepare for the general election.
He said DAP needed to move beyond its representation of the urban Chinese communities while all PR parties should share in the burden of taking on seats in BN strongholds.
“In the polls, DAP was obviously very well-equipped but the other PR parties were struggling with their campaigns.
“There is a need for PR to formulate strategies together,” he said.
Aeria agreed that the Sarawak state polls had seen a divided campaign among DAP, PKR and PAS, resulting in imbalanced victories between the parties.
On April 16, DAP emerged the biggest winners by securing 12 of the 15 state seats it had contested. PKR trailed behind, winning three of its 49 seats, while PAS failed to win a single seat.
Aeria said PKR’s biggest failure was its ill-preparedness for the polls, pointing out that the party was still arguing over its manifesto even after nomination day.
“There was also no sharing of campaign machineries. It did not happen. Every party went out on their own.
“It is true that the leaders came together — Lim Kit Siang, Guan Eng, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Datuk Nik Aziz Nik Mat — but the machinery at the lower ground level... that was another story,” he said.
Faisal agreed that PR needed to stop depending heavily on the anti-Taib vote in the coming polls, particularly to prepare for the possibility that the chief minister stepped down before it is called.
The 13th general election must be called by April 2013. During the Sarawak state polls, Taib had promised to leave in “two or three years’” time, bowing to public pressure and the growing disenchantment among even BN leaders against his lengthy leadership.
The opposition had centred most of its campaign messages on calling for Taib’s early resignation, capitalising on the numerous allegations of corruption and abuse of power made against the country’s longest-serving chief minister.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak also spent six days in Sarawak urging voters to believe Taib’s resignation plan, an unprecedented move that PR had described as a desperate attempt by the ruling pact to cling on to its fixed deposit state.
“So if Taib goes, what’s next? The challenge is for PR to penetrate the rural seats. Overcome the struggle between the opposition factions,” said Faisal
However, the analysts also agreed that with Taib’s thumping victory on April 16, it was unlikely that the chief minister would relinquish his post before the national poll.
“Why should he? Taib won in 35 out of the 35 seats that his party contested,” Aeria pointed out.
BN managed to triumph in 55 seats during the state polls, retaining its two-thirds majority in the state and safely recapturing government.
Of the 55, Taib’s PBB topped the charts by winning in all 35 state seats that it contested while PRS won eight of its nine seats, SPDP in six of its eight seats and SUPP in six of 19 seats contested.
The ruling pact’s popular vote, however, dipped considerably — from 63 per cent in 2006 to 55.5 per cent this year.
Taib was the crux of PR’s campaign during the Sarawak state poll.
PETALING JAYA, April 27 — Political analysts have warned that Pakatan Rakyat (PR) could lose its momentum in Sarawak should Chief Minister Tan Sri Abdul Taib Mahmud resign before the next general election.
In their analysis of the just-concluded state polls, the scholars pointed out last night without the “anti-Taib” rallying cry to unite opposition supporters, Barisan Nasional (BN) may regain its lost votes — particularly from the rural communities.
As such, they said all PR parties — including DAP — needed to quickly formulate a new strategy that would bring their campaign beyond the anti-Taib sentiment and penetrate deeper into the interiors of the hornbill state where BN’s vote bank lies.
Political scientist Wong Chin Huat said DAP could not afford to rest on its laurels and expect its victories to repeat in the coming polls without working hard to keep its message alive among its supporters.
“PR will go forward but can it continue to maintain its dominance in urban Sarawak?
“Taib is now seen as a ‘rural CM’. Will he go before the federal elections? If he does, the opposition cannot campaign against him [any] longer because you cannot find a leader more hated than him.
“But can they survive without Taib?” he said during a Merdeka Center forum on the April 16 Sarawak state polls held at the Hilton Hotel here last night.
Wong pointed out that failure to perform well in Sarawak during the general election would mirror PR’s failure to wrest control of Putrajaya.
This, he said, was because by remaining in the opposition, PR parties would find it hard to prove to voters that they could do better than the ruling government.
“Like in Sarawak... can DAP do better than SUPP in government? They need to be remembered... they need to show that although they are in the opposition, they are really driving the state forward,” he said.
Wong said PR needed to offer “something” tangible to Sarawak voters to keep their support from
dissipating, stressing on an often-raised point that the political expectations of east Malaysians vastly differed from those of the peninsula voters.
“PR does not have a policy for Sarawak. Its urban centre is stuck now as there is a stagnation in development so PR needs to offer something.
“(Penang Chief Minister) Lim Guan Eng came in to speak about offering free WiFi to Sarawakians but that is a West Malaysian thing; it’s different in Sarawak,” he pointed out.
Universiti Malaysia Sarawak (Unimas) Associate Professor Dr Andrew Aeria agreed, noting PR’s message to voters was to “change” but that the pact had failed to explain the alternatives.
“You tell them to change but change for what? Do not forget, BN has an economic policy in place and whether we like to admit it or not, people have benefitted.
“PR has not come up with an economic programme for Sarawak... so if you want to dislodge their programme, you need to come up with something better,” he warned.
He agreed with a comment from the audience that while many voters were unhappy with Taib’s 30-year rule, they still voted him into power as it was better to vote for “the devil they know”.
“True, it is always better to be safe than sorry and voters are very rational that way. Until and unless you can provide them with a better alternative, they would not want to risk it.
“This sentiment may not be shared by the urban communities but for those in the rural areas, losing BN is seen as very risky,” he explained.
Universiti Malaysia Sarawak (Unimas) lecturer Dr Faisal Syam Hazis concurred with his fellow academicians, adding that all three PR parties needed to pool their resources and begin working the ground immediately to prepare for the general election.
He said DAP needed to move beyond its representation of the urban Chinese communities while all PR parties should share in the burden of taking on seats in BN strongholds.
“In the polls, DAP was obviously very well-equipped but the other PR parties were struggling with their campaigns.
“There is a need for PR to formulate strategies together,” he said.
Aeria agreed that the Sarawak state polls had seen a divided campaign among DAP, PKR and PAS, resulting in imbalanced victories between the parties.
On April 16, DAP emerged the biggest winners by securing 12 of the 15 state seats it had contested. PKR trailed behind, winning three of its 49 seats, while PAS failed to win a single seat.
Aeria said PKR’s biggest failure was its ill-preparedness for the polls, pointing out that the party was still arguing over its manifesto even after nomination day.
“There was also no sharing of campaign machineries. It did not happen. Every party went out on their own.
“It is true that the leaders came together — Lim Kit Siang, Guan Eng, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Datuk Nik Aziz Nik Mat — but the machinery at the lower ground level... that was another story,” he said.
Faisal agreed that PR needed to stop depending heavily on the anti-Taib vote in the coming polls, particularly to prepare for the possibility that the chief minister stepped down before it is called.
The 13th general election must be called by April 2013. During the Sarawak state polls, Taib had promised to leave in “two or three years’” time, bowing to public pressure and the growing disenchantment among even BN leaders against his lengthy leadership.
The opposition had centred most of its campaign messages on calling for Taib’s early resignation, capitalising on the numerous allegations of corruption and abuse of power made against the country’s longest-serving chief minister.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak also spent six days in Sarawak urging voters to believe Taib’s resignation plan, an unprecedented move that PR had described as a desperate attempt by the ruling pact to cling on to its fixed deposit state.
“So if Taib goes, what’s next? The challenge is for PR to penetrate the rural seats. Overcome the struggle between the opposition factions,” said Faisal
However, the analysts also agreed that with Taib’s thumping victory on April 16, it was unlikely that the chief minister would relinquish his post before the national poll.
“Why should he? Taib won in 35 out of the 35 seats that his party contested,” Aeria pointed out.
BN managed to triumph in 55 seats during the state polls, retaining its two-thirds majority in the state and safely recapturing government.
Of the 55, Taib’s PBB topped the charts by winning in all 35 state seats that it contested while PRS won eight of its nine seats, SPDP in six of its eight seats and SUPP in six of 19 seats contested.
The ruling pact’s popular vote, however, dipped considerably — from 63 per cent in 2006 to 55.5 per cent this year.
Friday, April 22, 2011
Butt out! SPDP tells MCA
Sarawak Barisan Nasional’s (BN) parties are now locked in a quarrel over Tan Sri Abdul Taib Mahmud’s extended stay in government with the chief minister’s loyalists telling MCA to stop meddling in the hornbill state.
Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP) vice-president Sylvester Entri Muran chided his political equivalent in MCA Gan Ping Siew today for demanding Taib take responsibility for the loss of Chinese votes in the state election and resign immediately.
The statement, said Entri, shows Gan’s “blatant ignorance” of Sarawak’s political landscape.
Writing in an emailed statement to national news agency Bernama today, the Marudi assemblyman pointed out that it was Taib who had secured BN’s victory during the polls when the ruling pact successfully retained its two-thirds majority in the state assembly.
BN won 55 seats in the 71-seat Sarawak assembly on Saturday but lost 16 seats — 12 to DAP, three to PKR and one to independent — the ruling pact’s worst electoral performance in Sarawak since 1987.
Its losses to DAP were largely Chinese-majority urban seats, triggering Gan’s statement yesterday that Taib should step down immediately.
The Chinese community make up the largest segment of the 979,796-strong Sarawak electorate.
“MCA are using their sharpest spear to attack their own toughest shield. This is a clear-cut smear campaign by the MCA to undermine the state leadership,” Bernama quoted Entri as saying.
Entri also stressed that Sarawak voters had indicated their support to retain Taib as Chief Minister and their wishes should be respected.
He pointed out that Taib already has a succession plan in mind; one which would ensure political stability and economic prosperity.
Entri also reportedly noted that it was merely SUPP (Sarawak United People’s Party) that had performed badly in the state election whereas BN’s other Sarawak partners like SPDP, Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS) and Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) won.
SUPP, which claims to represent the interests of the Chinese community, suffered its worst ever electoral defeat when it only secured six of the 19 state seats it contested.
Its dismal showing mirrored that of MCA’s performance in Elections 2008 when its parliamentary representation was reduced by more than half from 31 seats to 15.
PBB, of which Taib is president, succeeded in recapturing all the 35 seats it had contested while PRS won in eight seats and SPDP won in six.
As such, Entri said that Gan should focus on revitalising MCA instead of meddling in Sarawak politics so that it could become a good platform for the Chinese community in the peninsula.
“I suggest that the MCA should not toe the line of (the) opposition in order to be popular within the (Chinese) community.
“The party should just sit down and analyse what has happened so that it can prepare for the next general election,” Bernama quoted Entri as saying.
By Clara Chooi
Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP) vice-president Sylvester Entri Muran chided his political equivalent in MCA Gan Ping Siew today for demanding Taib take responsibility for the loss of Chinese votes in the state election and resign immediately.
The statement, said Entri, shows Gan’s “blatant ignorance” of Sarawak’s political landscape.
Writing in an emailed statement to national news agency Bernama today, the Marudi assemblyman pointed out that it was Taib who had secured BN’s victory during the polls when the ruling pact successfully retained its two-thirds majority in the state assembly.
BN won 55 seats in the 71-seat Sarawak assembly on Saturday but lost 16 seats — 12 to DAP, three to PKR and one to independent — the ruling pact’s worst electoral performance in Sarawak since 1987.
Its losses to DAP were largely Chinese-majority urban seats, triggering Gan’s statement yesterday that Taib should step down immediately.
The Chinese community make up the largest segment of the 979,796-strong Sarawak electorate.
“MCA are using their sharpest spear to attack their own toughest shield. This is a clear-cut smear campaign by the MCA to undermine the state leadership,” Bernama quoted Entri as saying.
Entri also stressed that Sarawak voters had indicated their support to retain Taib as Chief Minister and their wishes should be respected.
He pointed out that Taib already has a succession plan in mind; one which would ensure political stability and economic prosperity.
Entri also reportedly noted that it was merely SUPP (Sarawak United People’s Party) that had performed badly in the state election whereas BN’s other Sarawak partners like SPDP, Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS) and Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) won.
SUPP, which claims to represent the interests of the Chinese community, suffered its worst ever electoral defeat when it only secured six of the 19 state seats it contested.
Its dismal showing mirrored that of MCA’s performance in Elections 2008 when its parliamentary representation was reduced by more than half from 31 seats to 15.
PBB, of which Taib is president, succeeded in recapturing all the 35 seats it had contested while PRS won in eight seats and SPDP won in six.
As such, Entri said that Gan should focus on revitalising MCA instead of meddling in Sarawak politics so that it could become a good platform for the Chinese community in the peninsula.
“I suggest that the MCA should not toe the line of (the) opposition in order to be popular within the (Chinese) community.
“The party should just sit down and analyse what has happened so that it can prepare for the next general election,” Bernama quoted Entri as saying.
By Clara Chooi
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
A letter from Kuching
A Kuching-based political observer sent me this letter which I am sharing with you. See what you make of it.
What PR and PKR in particular failed to understand is how the BN has worked in rural areas (Malay, Melanau, Iban, Bidayuh and some Orang Ulu). These communities rely heavily on the BN for paltry sums of donations and grants. Come elections the penghulus (appointed by BN) may be told to ensure all the longhouses under their care vote for BN and prevent any opposition politicians from entering their longhouses.
The penghulus are afraid because they receive a monthly allowance from the government and there is no way they are going to allow anyone to make them lose their allowances.
On top of that some penghulu may be given a sum of money to be distributed to the longhouse folks through the longhouse chiefs. Along the way the amount smeant for each longhouse dweller may be ‘taxed’ by the penghulus and longhouse chiefs. Of course besides money there are things like beers, pigs for BBQ, rice packets, etc that may be distributed.
Now, we must remember many of the folks are poor and they see election time as ‘durian runtuh’. To us in the towns and cities we think it is so cheap to buy their votes but to them it is either that or nothing at all. We forget them all after the elections as no opposition parties are seen after that returning to see how they are doing. The BN rep will return be it for Christmas or Gawai or Hari Raya and dish out some money for their places of worship like chapels, etc.
The church on the other hand is another issue. The leaders especially in the rural areas are only humans. They want to be seen as ‘powerful’ and to be met and to be shaking hands with the YBs. It makes them feel important. So again these leaders will not tell them the real issues facing society at large. To the educated ones they say the church remains neutral and this allows them the justification of not standing up against abuses.
PR will have to start early and right away if they want to win GE 13. They shouldn’t wait until the date is announced. They should start by identifying and choosing several potential candidates to stand for GE 13. Once the candidates are known they will have to start work on the ground. In one constituency, you could have say three or four potential candidates. As the date draws nearer, the party leadership should choose the most hard working, dedicated and promising candidates as its final choice. All the others who are not chosen then will have to just support the candidate chosen.
Sarawak is a vast area and larger than West Malaysia. It takes time and money to be able to reach out to the rural masses. In this state election, all the PR big guns campaigned heavily in the urban areas. The results showed it worked. PR leaders should go to the rural areas now to start off the GE 13 campaign. When they wait till the date is announced, they themselves will be busy with their own individual areas. Internet is only accessible in urban areas. Even if they can get it in rural areas they would not be able to afford it. PR can start their campaign by getting several doctors/medical personnel to visit the rural areas and conduct health checks free of charge. In this way you get to know the villagers and they get to know you too. You can also provide reading material or simple toys for the children. Provide sewing machines and teach the people to sew and make a small living. Instead of giving cash, pigs, beers, etc, these suggestions would be more useful and could help change their hard lives in the interior.
At the end of the day, as things stand, it all boils down to money and who has the most of it to dish out. Now you understand why BN is ever so powerful in Sarawak and is referred to as its fixed deposit. In a way, PR failed to understand the people. They rely on their advisers who are mainly educated and sitting behind the desk in an air-conditioned office. They listen to political scientist/analyst/observers and armchair ‘experts’.
One point of interest in this state election, is that lawyers like Baru Bian, See Chee How, etc got voted in but they kicked out doctors including George Chan, Chris Kiyui, Michael Teo….. Perhaps when there is a shortage of doctors in the state, the people prefer them to remain as doctors – not as politicians – and help patients instead.
The key to change in Sarawak now is with a change of government in the federal level. Not the other way round. And the key to Putrajaya will be the rural areas of Sabah and Sarawak.
What PR and PKR in particular failed to understand is how the BN has worked in rural areas (Malay, Melanau, Iban, Bidayuh and some Orang Ulu). These communities rely heavily on the BN for paltry sums of donations and grants. Come elections the penghulus (appointed by BN) may be told to ensure all the longhouses under their care vote for BN and prevent any opposition politicians from entering their longhouses.
The penghulus are afraid because they receive a monthly allowance from the government and there is no way they are going to allow anyone to make them lose their allowances.
On top of that some penghulu may be given a sum of money to be distributed to the longhouse folks through the longhouse chiefs. Along the way the amount smeant for each longhouse dweller may be ‘taxed’ by the penghulus and longhouse chiefs. Of course besides money there are things like beers, pigs for BBQ, rice packets, etc that may be distributed.
Now, we must remember many of the folks are poor and they see election time as ‘durian runtuh’. To us in the towns and cities we think it is so cheap to buy their votes but to them it is either that or nothing at all. We forget them all after the elections as no opposition parties are seen after that returning to see how they are doing. The BN rep will return be it for Christmas or Gawai or Hari Raya and dish out some money for their places of worship like chapels, etc.
The church on the other hand is another issue. The leaders especially in the rural areas are only humans. They want to be seen as ‘powerful’ and to be met and to be shaking hands with the YBs. It makes them feel important. So again these leaders will not tell them the real issues facing society at large. To the educated ones they say the church remains neutral and this allows them the justification of not standing up against abuses.
PR will have to start early and right away if they want to win GE 13. They shouldn’t wait until the date is announced. They should start by identifying and choosing several potential candidates to stand for GE 13. Once the candidates are known they will have to start work on the ground. In one constituency, you could have say three or four potential candidates. As the date draws nearer, the party leadership should choose the most hard working, dedicated and promising candidates as its final choice. All the others who are not chosen then will have to just support the candidate chosen.
Sarawak is a vast area and larger than West Malaysia. It takes time and money to be able to reach out to the rural masses. In this state election, all the PR big guns campaigned heavily in the urban areas. The results showed it worked. PR leaders should go to the rural areas now to start off the GE 13 campaign. When they wait till the date is announced, they themselves will be busy with their own individual areas. Internet is only accessible in urban areas. Even if they can get it in rural areas they would not be able to afford it. PR can start their campaign by getting several doctors/medical personnel to visit the rural areas and conduct health checks free of charge. In this way you get to know the villagers and they get to know you too. You can also provide reading material or simple toys for the children. Provide sewing machines and teach the people to sew and make a small living. Instead of giving cash, pigs, beers, etc, these suggestions would be more useful and could help change their hard lives in the interior.
At the end of the day, as things stand, it all boils down to money and who has the most of it to dish out. Now you understand why BN is ever so powerful in Sarawak and is referred to as its fixed deposit. In a way, PR failed to understand the people. They rely on their advisers who are mainly educated and sitting behind the desk in an air-conditioned office. They listen to political scientist/analyst/observers and armchair ‘experts’.
One point of interest in this state election, is that lawyers like Baru Bian, See Chee How, etc got voted in but they kicked out doctors including George Chan, Chris Kiyui, Michael Teo….. Perhaps when there is a shortage of doctors in the state, the people prefer them to remain as doctors – not as politicians – and help patients instead.
The key to change in Sarawak now is with a change of government in the federal level. Not the other way round. And the key to Putrajaya will be the rural areas of Sabah and Sarawak.
Monday, April 18, 2011
We Need Fair Election Rules

Dear Editor,
I AM a Malaysian student in a U.S. university and would like to comment on something I found outrageous about the Sarawak state election.
How is it that Chinese people make up the majority in Sarawak (something the mainstream media is not keen on mentioning often), yet Chinese candidates were left to fight for around 20 or so seats out of 71 in the state assembly?
While I’m not a fan of political parties chasing votes from specific communities (PBB vs. PKR for Malays/Melanaus, SUPP vs. DAP for Chinese), how is it that the battle between DAP and SUPP to win the Chinese vote became a sideshow while PBB and Taib retained their political dominance while representing a minority of Sarawak’s population?
Of course, those questions are rhetorical. We all know the reasons behind them and no one dares ask why. For a Chinese person to question his or her lack of political representation is the worst form of political incorrectness in Malaysia.
Yet, this isn’t an issue about one race versus another (like a zero sum game). It’s a question of fairness, and whether or not to allow those in power (with questionable legitimacy) to do whatever they wish, to subordinate whomever they want in their quest for more power and wealth at the expense of those who are subordinated.
This issue paints a relevant picture of the unfair rules that opposition parties have to play by during elections. Again, I would like to emphasize how it sickens me that racial politics dominate our elections, but it does and here’s my take on it: Chinese people are the majority of Sarawak’s population. They are more likely to not vote in favor of Barisan Nasional, hence the electoral boundaries are gerrymandered in a way that:
(1) in most of the constituencies, their power as a voting bloc becomes irrelevant (especially in rural seats, where the racial breakdowns are a far cry from mirroring the state’s demographics as a whole) – the DAP did not even bother contesting these seats; and
(2) even in urban seats where they are undeniably the majority, the constituency boundaries keep their proportion as low as possible, forcing opposition Chinese politicians to appeal more to other races (which is a great thing, except that BN creates double standards by exempting themselves from this requirement).
For rural seats with non-Chinese majorities, BN knows that they can bribe constituents who have had their livelihoods squeezed so badly by the state government’s policies that they would do anything (like vote BN) just to receive a one-off cash payment to make ends meet.
With these rules in place, even if the DAP won every Chinese vote, other opposition parties will gain nothing and Sarawak would still be in the hands of Taib and PBB. This begs the question for the opposition parties:
How can you win if even the rules you agree to abide by to are designed to keep you from winning?
Forget about ballot stuffing, ballot dumping, phantom voters, postal votes and other documented dirty tricks in the bag. The opposition parties are screwed by the system long before the game has even began. And there’s nothing they can do about it unless ordinary voters become cognizant of this fact.
They can’t push for an independent Election Commission (to ask for independent institutions in Malaysia is like wishing to see donkeys fly), but greater awareness among ordinary folk can lead to solid action, such as popular support for election monitoring by respected international observers.
While there are lots of undesirable aspects of Malaysian politics – personality attacks, race, pandering to religious ignorance, sex – let’s at least establish some fair ground rules when it comes to elections. And while personality attacks, race, pandering to religious ignorance and sex in public debate are the darker sides of democracy that we have to accept, unfree and unfair elections are not.
If elections are set up in a way that the outcome that matters most – the ruling party retaining power – will occur however the electorate votes, then why even bother voting anyway. If Malaysians think that BN’s majority in parliament will be chipped away election by election, and that somewhere down the line, the opposition will actually stand a chance of winning power, they are gravely mistaken. But they are not powerless to prevent it.
If people in the Middle East can bring down oppressive dictators through intelligent use of social media in a globally connected world, surely Malaysians can demand free and fair elections. (This is NOT a revolutionary message. It simply seeks fair rules under the system, not to overthrow the system.)
In the Ivory Coast, election monitors certified Alassane Ouattara as the winner of the 2010 presidential election, and the international community backed him persistently even as the incumbent Laurent Gbagbo rigged the official results and refused to leave office.
Their patience paid off as Gbagbo was finally deposed in 2011. This demonstrates how if you put yourself in the court of the respected international election observers, you will never be able to run from the truth. This is why I believe free and fair elections should be a cause that every Malaysian citizen should take up and every opposition party should champion.
Thank you for your time.
LIM YIN KUIN
Opposition must re-strategise, East wind blowing but not yet strong enough
By Datuk Yong Teck Lee
The reality is that a change of federal government is possible only if the Borneo states of Sabah and Sarawak shift away from the BN to the opposition. The Sarawak state elections results, if translated into parliamentary seats, means that the opposition can capture only 4 to 5 seats in the main towns out of the 31 in Sarawak. Hence, the opposition must urgently and sincerely re-strategise for the general elections.
The lesson from Sarawak for the Sabah opposition is that the key to changing the government lies in the combined strengths of both the rural and urban areas that cut across demographic lines. As an elaboration, a rally of 35,000 people in Penang was sufficient to change the state government in 2008. But in Kuching, a rally of 35,000 cannot even change the city mayor. This means that just relying on urban or on rural areas alone is not sufficient.
We must win in both the rural and urban areas. In the rural areas, local issues, party organization, personal strengths of candidates and the smart use of resources are crucial factors in beating the BN’s vastly superior machinery. In Sarawak, PKR, especially, should have concentrated their resources in marginal areas instead of over spreading themselves too thinly all over the vast state. As a result, all 13 marginal seats were lost to BN. BN also managed to turn around “black areas” like Bawang Assan and Senadin, both defended by a demoralised SUPP. If the opposition had concentrated resources in these 15 areas, then the opposition could have won a formidable 28 or more, thus denying BN its two-third majority. PKR also wasted much precious time and resources fighting fellow Pakatan partner SNAP. The end results show that PKR has beaten not only SNAP but also itself. This is a self-inflicted damage that could have been avoided.
Previously, I had reminded PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim that we should not underestimate BN’s political will to remain in power. BN leaders have too much to lose and will fight tooth and nail to remain in government. Of all people, Anwar, a former UMNO acting Prime Minister, should know what I mean. Not everyone is like SAPP who walked out of the incumbent BN government and chose to fight from outside. It takes time and efforts to build a strong team based on consensus. The days of top down coercion from KL to Sabah and Sarawak are over. KL-based parties must accept this fact in order to strengthen the opposition in Sabah and Sarawak. Hence, it is not too early to re-strategise a common opposition campaign in facing the BN in the coming general elections.
The reality is that a change of federal government is possible only if the Borneo states of Sabah and Sarawak shift away from the BN to the opposition. The Sarawak state elections results, if translated into parliamentary seats, means that the opposition can capture only 4 to 5 seats in the main towns out of the 31 in Sarawak. Hence, the opposition must urgently and sincerely re-strategise for the general elections.
The lesson from Sarawak for the Sabah opposition is that the key to changing the government lies in the combined strengths of both the rural and urban areas that cut across demographic lines. As an elaboration, a rally of 35,000 people in Penang was sufficient to change the state government in 2008. But in Kuching, a rally of 35,000 cannot even change the city mayor. This means that just relying on urban or on rural areas alone is not sufficient.
We must win in both the rural and urban areas. In the rural areas, local issues, party organization, personal strengths of candidates and the smart use of resources are crucial factors in beating the BN’s vastly superior machinery. In Sarawak, PKR, especially, should have concentrated their resources in marginal areas instead of over spreading themselves too thinly all over the vast state. As a result, all 13 marginal seats were lost to BN. BN also managed to turn around “black areas” like Bawang Assan and Senadin, both defended by a demoralised SUPP. If the opposition had concentrated resources in these 15 areas, then the opposition could have won a formidable 28 or more, thus denying BN its two-third majority. PKR also wasted much precious time and resources fighting fellow Pakatan partner SNAP. The end results show that PKR has beaten not only SNAP but also itself. This is a self-inflicted damage that could have been avoided.
Previously, I had reminded PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim that we should not underestimate BN’s political will to remain in power. BN leaders have too much to lose and will fight tooth and nail to remain in government. Of all people, Anwar, a former UMNO acting Prime Minister, should know what I mean. Not everyone is like SAPP who walked out of the incumbent BN government and chose to fight from outside. It takes time and efforts to build a strong team based on consensus. The days of top down coercion from KL to Sabah and Sarawak are over. KL-based parties must accept this fact in order to strengthen the opposition in Sabah and Sarawak. Hence, it is not too early to re-strategise a common opposition campaign in facing the BN in the coming general elections.
Sunday, April 17, 2011
‘Excited Najib not a fool’
Even though Sarawak came through for BN, the voter breakdown would have been 'sobering' for Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak and his people.
The most important headline to me said: ‘Najib is excited, but will consider all aspects.’
I presumed that’s spoken in the context of responding to urgings that we hold general election soon.
The urgings came mainly from people who believed in self-hype and those still green in politics.
They are taking on the PM who said that the elections in Sarawak will factor into a decision to have nationwide elections.
With over 30 years practical experience in politics, Najib is not going to rush in where fools do so amidst exuberant and jubilant whoops of joy.
Even though victorious, he and his people must have gone through the election results with sobering attitude.
They are looking more at signals not trumpeted by the mainstream media and the chorus singers.
But first things first. Congratulations are in order for Taib Mahmud and his gang for winning all the 35 seats PBB contested.
Its partner political parties, SUPP, PRS and SPDP – all under BN – won a further 20 seats.
The Pakatan Rakyat people won 15 seats and an independent won one seat.
Mocks and sarcasms
How did PBB succeed in retaining all the 35 seats? We can advance all sorts of reasons.
We can if we want to justify our position taken if were prompted to win an argument for argument’s sake.
If we do, then having seen our analyses proven wrong, we are likely to be fazed.
But clearly, if the position and stand we have taken were prompted by basic beliefs, then the mocking and sarcasms expected to be raised by gleeful asinine commentators at my previous article, will leave me dismayed.
Fortunately, they will not because as I explained, I was moved not by a desire to win arguments for augments sake, but more moved by basic beliefs.
I will expand more on that in my own blog sakmongkol.blogspot.com.
So why is Najib excited but not enough I think to decide on a general election?
At first instance, this reaction is to be expected.
Anyone wishing to vanquish his opponent doesn’t expose his strategic thinking and forfeits the element of surprise.
Look closer at the results. BN managed to get 372,379 votes (54.5%) in total while the opposition raked in 300,288 votes (45.5%), with the DAP getting 142,847 votes of those.
At the 2006 state election, BN obtained 63 seats, DAP won six, SNAP and PKR one each.
More loses
This time around, BN lost an additional eight seats to the opposition compared to the 2006 polls.
BN lost 16 seats, DAP notched a 100% increase in the number of its seats, PKR improved three-fold by taking in three seats.
SNAP which was hastily resurrected before the elections got nothing. PAS won nothing.
BN won some seats by courtesy of postal votes. The postal votes went against PKR contestants.
Popular votes for BN were reduced by 8% from 63% to 55%. The popular votes for Pakatan rose to 45%.
Looking at the results will not cause one to rush in prematurely. Najib and his cabinet literally made Sarawak their 2nd home for more than a week. Putrajaya moved to Kuching during that time.
Najib must have also realized that Umno has almost taken over the election operations.
He must have also revived feedbacks, that Umno’s involvement at ground level was not well revived by Taib’s own ground forces.
In a general election setting, the fact that state elections had to be won by sending in the cavalry from Peninsula is not that encouraging.
The Sarawak state election must be seen as by elections of 71 state seats undertaken simultaneously.
You can concentrate resources and forces at one place but that cannot be done in nationwide general elections.
Perhaps these are the reasons that excite Najib but not sufficient for him to abandon pragmatism.
Mohd Ariff Sabri Aziz
Lesson To Be Learnt
By Amdee Sidik
Sure we learnt a few things judging from the results of Sarawak General Election, last night 16 April 2011.
For those visited the ground and observed what were said and did and perhaps later try to synchronize in logical sense from the result; mind boggling it is, but it’s Sarawak’s style!
In the end it Borneo’s matter prevails.
Yes, I do agree we’ve more than 1Malaysia as proven by DAP. But that doesn’t mean we, from both divides, one is less patriotic to the country while the other is more.
Here is about ability to convey the message. The message about which way is the best way to save the country, in this case, very particular, which way is the best way to save the State of Sarawak, that must be in the mind of majority in Sarawakians.
There are many ways of saying as well as doing this. In Sarawak’s rural, no sophisticated techniques required, a mere whisper would do, because if they do openly it would backfire, see the results obtained by PKR which fielded 49 seats won only 3.
The DAP is different even though both are in Pakatan. DAP voters are from 2Malaysians. This group is fighting for the ‘Pan Malaysial’, while the other I could say is fighting for local, yet happily merged –unspoken or written agreement in as far as politics is concerned. It’s all about fighting injustices.
Injustices about treatment of State like Sarawak by the federal, was there a need to take swearing in hastily manner for Taib Mahmud? This wouldn’t happen in Sabah where everything else must come from Prime Minister and from KL.
To a point, it isn’t just Sarawakians, many Sabahan would agree no matter how disagree they’re with Taib Mahmud.
SNAP was squeezed, badly strategized, too late to rescue once becomes mash potatoes.
Here the danger, the non-local parties are here to stay in Borneo.
The history of DAP’s survival tells us, it isn’t intended to be superior but just to presence via innovations and the change of mindset, makes DAP different. A sheer hard work, slowly and surely becomes worth pursuing.
At the same token if local parties aren’t careful all would face the same fate as SNAP.
This would be the line of thought (…) leave to continue
Sure we learnt a few things judging from the results of Sarawak General Election, last night 16 April 2011.
For those visited the ground and observed what were said and did and perhaps later try to synchronize in logical sense from the result; mind boggling it is, but it’s Sarawak’s style!
In the end it Borneo’s matter prevails.
Yes, I do agree we’ve more than 1Malaysia as proven by DAP. But that doesn’t mean we, from both divides, one is less patriotic to the country while the other is more.
Here is about ability to convey the message. The message about which way is the best way to save the country, in this case, very particular, which way is the best way to save the State of Sarawak, that must be in the mind of majority in Sarawakians.
There are many ways of saying as well as doing this. In Sarawak’s rural, no sophisticated techniques required, a mere whisper would do, because if they do openly it would backfire, see the results obtained by PKR which fielded 49 seats won only 3.
The DAP is different even though both are in Pakatan. DAP voters are from 2Malaysians. This group is fighting for the ‘Pan Malaysial’, while the other I could say is fighting for local, yet happily merged –unspoken or written agreement in as far as politics is concerned. It’s all about fighting injustices.
Injustices about treatment of State like Sarawak by the federal, was there a need to take swearing in hastily manner for Taib Mahmud? This wouldn’t happen in Sabah where everything else must come from Prime Minister and from KL.
To a point, it isn’t just Sarawakians, many Sabahan would agree no matter how disagree they’re with Taib Mahmud.
SNAP was squeezed, badly strategized, too late to rescue once becomes mash potatoes.
Here the danger, the non-local parties are here to stay in Borneo.
The history of DAP’s survival tells us, it isn’t intended to be superior but just to presence via innovations and the change of mindset, makes DAP different. A sheer hard work, slowly and surely becomes worth pursuing.
At the same token if local parties aren’t careful all would face the same fate as SNAP.
This would be the line of thought (…) leave to continue
Saturday, April 16, 2011
Sarawak State Elections 2011 Results
BN Sarawak won 55 seats (Two-thirds majority), DAP - 12, PKR -3, Independent - 1 ...See Full Results...
Sarawak State Election Results
No: | Constituency | Incumbent | WON | DETAILS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
N1 | Opar | SUPP | SUPP | |
N2 | Tasik Biru | SPDP | SPDP | |
N3 | Tanjong Datu | PBB | PBB | |
N4 | Pantai Damai | PBB | PBB | |
N5 | Demak Laut | PBB | PBB | |
N6 | Tupong | PBB | PBB | |
N7 | Samariang | PBB | PBB | |
N8 | Satok | PBB | PBB | |
N9 | Padungan | PKR | DAP | Click here |
N10 | Pending | DAP | DAP | Click here |
N11 | Batu Lintang | DAP | PKR | Click here |
N12 | Kota Sentosa | DAP | DAP | Click here |
N13 | Batu Kawah | SUPP | DAP | Click here |
N14 | Asajaya | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N15 | Muara Tuang | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N16 | Bengoh | SUPP | SUPP | Click here |
N17 | Tarat | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N18 | Tebedu | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N19 | Kedup | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N20 | Sadong Jaya | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N21 | Simunjan | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N22 | Sebuyau | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N23 | Lingga | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N24 | Beting Maro | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N25 | Balai Ringin | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N26 | Bukit Begunan | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N27 | Simanggang | SUPP | SUPP | Click here |
N28 | Engkilili | SNAP | SUPP | Click here |
N29 | Batang Ai | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N30 | Saribas | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N31 | Layar | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N32 | Bukit Saban | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N33 | Kalaka | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N34 | Krian | SPDP | PKR | Click here |
N35 | Belawai | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N36 | Semop | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N37 | Daro | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N38 | Jemoreng | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N39 | Repok | SUPP | DAP | Click here |
N40 | Meradong | DAP | DAP | Click here |
N41 | Pakan | SPDP | SPDP | Click here |
N42 | Meluan | SPDP | SPDP | Click here |
N43 | Ngemah | SNAP | PRS | Click here |
N44 | Machan | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N45 | Bukit Assek | DAP | DAP | Click here |
N46 | Dudong | SUPP | DAP | Click here |
N47 | Bawang Assan | SUPP | SUPP | Click here |
N48 | Pelawan | SUPP | DAP | Click here |
N49 | Nangka | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N50 | Dalat | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N51 | Balingian | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N52 | Tamin | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N53 | Kakus | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N54 | Pelagus | PRS | IND | Click here |
N55 | Katibas | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N56 | Baleh | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N57 | Belaga | PRS | PRS | Click here |
N58 | Jepak | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N59 | Kidurong | DAP | DAP | Click here |
N60 | Kemena | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N61 | Bekenu | SPDP | SPDP | Click here |
N62 | Lambir | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N63 | Piasau | SUPP | DAP | Click here |
N64 | Pujut | SUPP | DAP | Click here |
N65 | Senadin | SUPP | SUPP | Click here |
N66 | Marudi | SPDP | SPDP | Click here |
N67 | Telang Usan | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N68 | Bukit Kota (Limbang) | PBB | PBB | Click here |
N69 | Batu Danau | SPDP | SPDP | Click here |
N70 | Ba'kelalan | SPDP | PKR | Click here |
N71 | Bukit Sari (Lawas) | PBB | PBB | Click here |
In this 10th state legislative assembly elections, there are a total of 213 candidates vying for 71 seats.
Although numerous minor opposition parties and Independents are in the fray, the main gladitorial combat is between the ruling BN and Pakatan Rakyat.
The campaign saw long-serving Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud, who has been in power for three decades, turning into Pakatan's main target while BN went for its tried-and-tested 'development' card.
Political observers are expecting, barring any widespread vote-rigging, Pakatan to make significant inroads this time round based on the anti-Taib factor alone.
The results of this elections would have far-reaching consequences - it will decide how long Taib will continue his rule, when the general elections will be held and whether Sarawak will see the beginning of a robust two-party system.
Taib Mahmud, who is battling for his seventh term, will lead the BN in the fight for all 71 seats.
Taib's PBB is contesting 35 seats, while BN component party SUPP is gunning 19 the other partners, PRS is going for 9 and SPDP 8.
Meanwhile, PKR is contesting in 49 seats, Snap (26), DAP (15), PCM (6), PAS (5). A total of 41 candidates are contesting as Independents.
There will be straight fights in 27 constituencies, three-cornered fights in 23 constituencies, 17 (four-cornered), two (five-cornered) while two constituencies will face six-cornered fights.
All eyes will be on 28 hot seats identified by Malaysiakini. Pakatan is set on denying BN its two-thirds majority by winning at least 24 seats.
The constituency with the largest number of voters is Pending (29,498 voters) while the least number of voters are in Ba'Kelalan (6,958).
Polling opens at 8am to close at 5.30pm. Unofficial results should begin trickling in at about 6pm. According to the Election Commission, the final results should be in by 8pm.
However, some polling stations in a number of rural constituencies will close as early as 11.30am because of the small number of voters. Unofficial results from these areas will be known much earlier. Helicopters are being for 15 voting centres.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




