By Captain Joseph Wilfred
As promised last Sunday, I have returned to consult The Sifu on which opposition party in Sabah to support in the coming 13th General Election and the following transpired.
2. On 16th September 2010, while ATAMA was performing for Malaysia Day at Padang Merdeka Kota Kinabalu, I attended a dinner reception hosted by PAKATAN RAKYAT at Putera Ballroom Bukit Padang together with The Sifu.
3. He was seated firmly in his chair from the beginning but mysteriously vanished when a SupreMoo, a Semenanjung MP, a Sabah MP, and a Sabah Assemblyman took over the microphone – in the process, abandoning even the food on the table which I personally know is one thing The Sifu will never do.
4. Today more than 9 months later, The Sifu told me why: He said,
5. “I am an objective person. For more than half a century as a human being, I tell you Captain, I can definitely recognize an idiot when I see and listen to one. I won’t sit around and hear crap.
6. You were there yourself on countless occasions when I told off people who had done wrong but in a very nice manner and these people (the brilliant ones, of course), despite feeling embarrassed, always put aside their shame and approached me for advice.
7. On the contrary, this SupreMoo (someone called him an old cow lately) portrays himself as a ‘I can do no wrong and you can do no right’ kind of politician. When I heard him speak (actually, he shouted all the way, to be precise), I find a person devoid of intellectual substance and etiquette. He doesn’t realize that his speeches are so hateful to hear so much so a convicted petty thief would rather choose amputation than to be put in a counseling room with this SupreMoo.
8. The Semenanjung MP, I heard, read Law from don’t know what university (I really don’t know). But that night on 16th September 2010, she portrayed herself as a “cheapskate Mandarin opera singer” who ignored the fact that 80% of the audience that night can only understand either English or Bahasa. To me, she is both a humiliation and an embarrassment.
9. As for the Sabah MP, I heard the people of Foh Sang Township ‘whispering’ that he thinks he is going to be the next Chief Minister of Sabah. For 3 times I have heard him spoke and I can have only one question to ask: ‘does this person really possesses a bona fide doctorate at all’?
10. You want to know what I think of the Sabah Assemblyman? This is one fellow who in spite of not having the ability to give a coherent and understandable description of anything at all in any language that he may try his tongue at (in short, everything he said that night was outright horrendous), has the audacity to parade his DUBIOUS NATIVE CERTIFICATE to all and sundry when everyone knows that his ancestors are 100% PURE CHINESE.
11. Oh…before I forget, do you still recall 25th July 2010 when a former PKR Leader launched his Pakatan Friends FaceBook Page in Yaho Hotel Sembulan? Remember the representative from Sepanggar who went up to the rostrum? His speech was a complete disaster and the audience, instead of laughing with him, was actually laughing at him. And the truth is, Captain, almost 90% of leaders and members from this Semenanjung Party are of this kind of quality.
12. By the way, Captain, it is wrong for you to address a veterinarian (meaning doktor binatang) as a doctor. You can only call him Vet So-And-So not Dr So-And-So. Under international standards, only genuine doctorate holders and medical practitioners treating human beings are entitled to be addressed as doctors.”
13. What about SAPP then, Sifu? Do you think the people of Sabah should support and vote for SAPP? What is your view? And His response was,
14. “If the opposition front in Sabah is only between PAKATAN RAKYAT (meaning PKR, DAP, PAS) and SAPP, then like what ATAMA had already suggested to SAPP Supreme Councilor Peter Marajin sometime in March this year, let PAKATAN RAKYAT take all the Parliamentary Seats while SAPP all the State Seats. All my reasons are already made known confidentially to SC Marajin by ATAMA.
15. Do not create multi-cornered fights and split the votes because only UMNO/BN will win. Whilst the local opposition party (meaning SAPP) support PAKATAN RAKYAT’s move to take over Putrajaya, PAKATAN RAKYAT must reciprocate and respect Sabah’s autonomy in every way.”
16. What if PAKATAN RAKYAT and SAPP refuse to come to a consensus? What then? The Sifu laughed,
17. “Of late, it has become obvious that PAKATAN RAKYAT (meaning PKR and particularly DAP) is bullying SAPP into a tight corner. You cannot really blame DAP members when they accuse SAPP of having a questionable leadership.
18. Interestingly, this Semenanjung Party also have corrupted leaders not to mention those with bogus doctorate, dubious native certificate, fake knighthood purportedly awarded by Queen Elizabeth II, and many others including a supreme loose cannon that fires blank rounds (check out youtube for parliament videos and you will know why UMNO MPs always ridicule and tell him to shut up).
19. Similarly, Captain, do you remember a sitting State Cabinet Minister from PBS who also claimed that his Datukship is equivalent to a British Knighthood not too long ago?
20. Now back to your question: If a black and white consensus cannot be reached, then PAKATAN RAKYAT and SAPP should jointly contest every Parliamentary plus State Seats against each other and lose all their deposits. This is one outcome that does not require a crystal ball to predict.” If they cannot agree and compromise, they should fight it out – fair and square and lose. There is no other way around the impasse.
21. If such a scenario happens, what is your advice to the people of Sabah? The Sifu (now serious),
22. “This is my message to all Sabahan brothers and sisters – vote for UMNO/BN if you are stupid; vote for PAKATAN RAKYAT if you are just as stupid; if you are not stupid, Vote only for SAPP but subject to the following terms and conditions:-
1. Do not vote for a candidate if he or she has any social, political, economical, family, or criminal baggage because such person’s integrity and credibility can be bought
2. Do not vote for any past or present incumbents because I have yet to see anything tangible that is worthy of praise being done by them, at least not by my standards
3. Do not vote for a candidate who has a speech and language problem because such person is usually stupid
4. Do not vote for a candidate who thinks he or she knows everything and yet only parrot what was heard
5. Vote for a candidate who is energetic and highly educated (preferably, but not limited or confined to, in English and with a degree in Economics) because only such candidates are able and willing to walk the extra mile for their constituents
23. If you could not find any or all of the above qualities in a SAPP candidate but on the other hand a PAKATAN RAKYAT candidate possesses those details, then, by all means, vote for the PAKATAN RAKYAT candidate instead.
24. If neither SAPP nor PAKATAN RAKYAT candidates have those qualities, I will stay home and not even bother to fly 17 hours back here to cast my vote.
(JW: Note to SAPP, in paragraph 22, The Sifu has insinuated to you what you should be contesting.)
25. Before I finish, I have to give due credit to Hiew King Chieu for highlighting the harassment on ATAMA in the mainstream media. This shows that Hiew King Chieu is a caring person. No human being is perfect but shortfalls can be rectified. Perhaps there is room for possible improvements, probably?
26. For helping ATAMA in my absence, I say a big THANK YOU.”
27. You people want to know what The Sifu said about Sabahans who are members of PAKATAN RAKYAT (particularly PKR and DAP) taking pot shots at SAPP, this is the analogy He gave:
28. “Throughout the real history of the Malacca Sultanate, Malay warriors are losers – they fought the Siamese and ended up paying ‘bunga emas’ every year as ‘ufti’ until ‘Hang Tuah’ and his friends came into the picture.
29. Who is ‘Hang Tuah’? He and the others are the personal bodyguards of a minor Chinese princess ‘Hang Li Po’ who came and married the Malacca sultan.
30. It is common in China those days that servants adopt the surnames of their masters and even courtiers who served the Imperial Court well were bestowed with the surname of the Emperor.
31. The entire ‘Hang Li Po’ clan was Chinese Muslims like Admiral Cheng Ho. To those of you Malay Muslims who do not know, Islam was practiced in India and China at least 600 years before any of your ancestors did.
32. Back to ‘Hang Tuah’, Malacca’s fortune changed instantly because of superior Chinese ‘kung fu’ and war strategy. After his death, every battle the Malay warriors fought was, again, lost e.g. against the Portuguese, English, Japanese, Communist, Indonesian Confrontation, and etc.
33. ‘Hang Tuah’ was epitomized as a Malay hero in history books until it was finally revealed by American scientists that the DNA from his remains was proven to be 100% Chinese.
34. All of a sudden, the name ‘Hang Tuah’ was stricken from all history books and you do know why, isn’t it? It is embarrassing to idolize a Chinese as a Malay Hero and worst, there was no other name that is as famous.
35. Remember his famous quote, ‘Takkan Melayu Hilang Di Dunia’? Malays in his era loved him very much for his loyalty even though history told us that the then Malacca sultan was a fickle minded asshole that did not deserved it.
36. He was so powerful yet so gentle; so Chinese yet so Malay. It took a Chinese warrior from China called ‘Hang Tuah’ who not only blended into local society, fought with them and for them, he even assured the local Malays that their race will not be wiped out from the face of this world…! By comparison, ‘Hang Tuah’ a Chinese is even more Malay than the Malays!
37. Coming back to Sabahan pretenders of Semenanjung Parties who insult and degrade the local opposition party who stood up against an Evil Monster, have you no shame when you mark them with infamy just because they are Sabah based and you are from a Semenanjung Party? Have you forgotten that you yourself also have Sabah blood flowing inside you? You are telling Sabahans that your half past six leaders are better to lord over Sabah?
37. If your leaders are so invincible like you say they are, why don’t they become like ‘Hang Tuah’s of modern Malaysia instead of arrogant assholes…?
38. I only have one label for these Sabahan pretenders and that is they are traitors to Sabah of the highest order…!
With that The Sifu ended all political talk and jump started into dessert mode. It was unfortunate that I could not ask The Sifu one more thing before he whacked his Ais Kacang; did any one of you reading this, notice that The Sifu did not mention anything negative about PAS? Maybe next time...
p.s.1. If you read between the lines, you will realize that a lot of unnamed ambitious politicians were literally ‘slaughtered’ by The Sifu whose motto is to spare no one that is incompetent. And to those of you who know that you are targeted, The Sifu has time and again reminded the two of us to tell you to your face if and when we have the opportunity one day “that there is absolutely no dignity at all for you to continue asking the ‘RAKYAT’ to keep voting for you when you are already a laughing stock as a result of your being thoroughly dishonest and your character utterly despicable.
p.s.2. We will try to produce a translated version of this conversation for the benefit of ‘BAHASA’-speaking readers but that will have to wait for a while.
p.s.3. Like what you are reading? Anyone of you guys and gals who want more from The Sifu will have to ‘bodek’ me and ATAMA ;-)
Showing posts with label Pakatan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pakatan. Show all posts
Tuesday, June 28, 2011
Monday, June 13, 2011
Formula "PR Plus SAPP" baik dan sesuai
FORMULA PENYATUAN gagasan pembangkang bernaung dalam satu bumbung apa yang dipanggil “ PR plus SAPP” sememangnya suatu langkah yang sesuai malah kemunculannya telah dinanti nantikan oleh penyokong masing masing kerana selagi pembangkan tidak sekata dalam apa juga strateginya untuk menumbangkan BN pada PRU13 tidak akan kesampaian.
Malahan pembangkang akan terus menjadi bahan ketawa baik dipihak BN mahupun rakyat disekeliling yang sudah tentu akan menambahkan lagi kemudaratan dari segi moral dan pengaruh parti parti masing masing dalam pembangkang kerana rakyat akan melihat isu ketidak sepakatan itu sebagai kayu ukur kepada kematangan pemimpin pembangkang dalam menyelesaikan kekalutan itu.
Perang mulut dikalangan pemimpin yang disibukkan oleh media setiap masa merupakan perkara biasa dalam percaturan politik, tetapi signifikannya pemimpin harus bijak mencari formula yang terbaik bagaimana menjatuhkan parti lawan seperti BN yang dilihat sebagai gagah perkasa.
Jikalau gagasan pembangkang terus menerus bermusuhan sambil mendewa dewakan ideology dan kekuatan politik masing masing sambil mengaku pernah melakar sejarah kegemilangan politik itu dan ini tetapi musuh didepan mata kelihatan gagah perkasa, mampukah ia ditumbangkan dalam keadaan pembangkang bergelut sesama sendiri?
Ada juga orang berkata…” Kalau inilah kelibat pembangkang..jangankan menumbang BN…menggoncangnya pun belum tentu dapat dilakukannya”. Begitu sekali kata kata masyarakat sekeliling yang mungkin sudah bosan dan muak melihat perangai pemimpin pemimpin pembangkang yang sering tidak sehaluan.
Bersyukur apabila kenyataan Presiden SAPP Datuk Seri Panglima Yong Teck Lee baru baru ini dimana beliau sudah memberi isyarat positif kepada formula baru penyatuan gagasan pembangkang yang dipanggil “PR plus SAPP” sekaligus membuka ruang untuk penyatuan kerjasama dalam pembangkang untuk menentang BN pada PRU13 akan datang ini.
Sekiranya formula ini berjaya dimaterialisasikan pihak pembangkang tidak mustahil menghadapi laluan sukar untuk menumbangkan BN pada PRU13, sebaliknya BN dan UMNO akan melihat kebangkitan pembangkang menerusi formula baru disifatkannya sebagai kedudukkan tidak selamat bagi BN diSabah.
Spekulasi negatif semakin menular dikalangan masyarakat sekeliling yang merasa sangsi keupayaan “ PR plus SAPP” mengageh agehkan kawasan DUN dan Parlimen calun parti masing masing ketika PRU13, ianya memang satu satunya persoalan hangat namun gagasan itu perlu membentuk satu urusetia yang lengkap bagi menyelaras segala keperluan dalam merumuskan permasalahan yang timbul pada ketika itu.
Seperti kata orang sekeliling…” Kalau BN mampu menyelaraskan 14 buah parti parti dalam komponen BN menjadi satu otak, satu kepala dan satu hati dalam satu tujuan…mengapa pula gagasan pembangkang tidak boleh melakukannya sedangkan ia hanya merangkumi 4 parti didalamnya,”. Dalam ertikata yang lain bahawa ianya mampu dilakukan sekiranya pemimpin pemimpin pembangkang mempunyai kesungguhan untuk melakukannya berteraskan ketelusan, kejujuran, keikhlasan, tidak tamak, bertoleransi selain menfokuskan cita cita “Masa untuk perubahan” akan tercapai.
Ingatlah kata kata ini…” Kalau ada kemahuan, disitu ada jalan dan kalau ada keseriusan disitu pasti ada kejayaannya….kita ibaratkan perjuangan itu jikalau sebatang lidi sudah pasti ianya mudah dipatahkan sebaliknya jika ia mengandungi serumpun/seikat lidi tentunya sukar untuk dipatahkan.”.
Malahan pembangkang akan terus menjadi bahan ketawa baik dipihak BN mahupun rakyat disekeliling yang sudah tentu akan menambahkan lagi kemudaratan dari segi moral dan pengaruh parti parti masing masing dalam pembangkang kerana rakyat akan melihat isu ketidak sepakatan itu sebagai kayu ukur kepada kematangan pemimpin pembangkang dalam menyelesaikan kekalutan itu.
Perang mulut dikalangan pemimpin yang disibukkan oleh media setiap masa merupakan perkara biasa dalam percaturan politik, tetapi signifikannya pemimpin harus bijak mencari formula yang terbaik bagaimana menjatuhkan parti lawan seperti BN yang dilihat sebagai gagah perkasa.
Jikalau gagasan pembangkang terus menerus bermusuhan sambil mendewa dewakan ideology dan kekuatan politik masing masing sambil mengaku pernah melakar sejarah kegemilangan politik itu dan ini tetapi musuh didepan mata kelihatan gagah perkasa, mampukah ia ditumbangkan dalam keadaan pembangkang bergelut sesama sendiri?
Ada juga orang berkata…” Kalau inilah kelibat pembangkang..jangankan menumbang BN…menggoncangnya pun belum tentu dapat dilakukannya”. Begitu sekali kata kata masyarakat sekeliling yang mungkin sudah bosan dan muak melihat perangai pemimpin pemimpin pembangkang yang sering tidak sehaluan.
Bersyukur apabila kenyataan Presiden SAPP Datuk Seri Panglima Yong Teck Lee baru baru ini dimana beliau sudah memberi isyarat positif kepada formula baru penyatuan gagasan pembangkang yang dipanggil “PR plus SAPP” sekaligus membuka ruang untuk penyatuan kerjasama dalam pembangkang untuk menentang BN pada PRU13 akan datang ini.
Sekiranya formula ini berjaya dimaterialisasikan pihak pembangkang tidak mustahil menghadapi laluan sukar untuk menumbangkan BN pada PRU13, sebaliknya BN dan UMNO akan melihat kebangkitan pembangkang menerusi formula baru disifatkannya sebagai kedudukkan tidak selamat bagi BN diSabah.
Spekulasi negatif semakin menular dikalangan masyarakat sekeliling yang merasa sangsi keupayaan “ PR plus SAPP” mengageh agehkan kawasan DUN dan Parlimen calun parti masing masing ketika PRU13, ianya memang satu satunya persoalan hangat namun gagasan itu perlu membentuk satu urusetia yang lengkap bagi menyelaras segala keperluan dalam merumuskan permasalahan yang timbul pada ketika itu.
Seperti kata orang sekeliling…” Kalau BN mampu menyelaraskan 14 buah parti parti dalam komponen BN menjadi satu otak, satu kepala dan satu hati dalam satu tujuan…mengapa pula gagasan pembangkang tidak boleh melakukannya sedangkan ia hanya merangkumi 4 parti didalamnya,”. Dalam ertikata yang lain bahawa ianya mampu dilakukan sekiranya pemimpin pemimpin pembangkang mempunyai kesungguhan untuk melakukannya berteraskan ketelusan, kejujuran, keikhlasan, tidak tamak, bertoleransi selain menfokuskan cita cita “Masa untuk perubahan” akan tercapai.
Ingatlah kata kata ini…” Kalau ada kemahuan, disitu ada jalan dan kalau ada keseriusan disitu pasti ada kejayaannya….kita ibaratkan perjuangan itu jikalau sebatang lidi sudah pasti ianya mudah dipatahkan sebaliknya jika ia mengandungi serumpun/seikat lidi tentunya sukar untuk dipatahkan.”.
Oleh: Wartawan Jendelasabah.com
(Ambrose Mail Matthew)
SAPP prefers "Pakatan Plus Formula"
By Dullie Marie
SAPP prefers the Pakatan-Plus formula announced by DAP's Lim Kit Siang in 2008.
We acknowledge the common political enemy of the oppositions is the Barisan Nasional and we are always prepared to work together with the Pakatan Rakyat to seek the solutions to achieve one-to-one contest against the BN in the coming general election.
We appreciate the invitation of PR's Sabah Secretariat inviting SAPP to join Pakatan Rakyat after their first meeting chaired by YB Fuziah Salleh, vice president of Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) and also Member of Parliament for Kuantan.
SAPP withdrew from BN on 17th September, 2008 shortly after the BN formed the government. SAPP made a 8-points declaration as the basis of our struggle for Sabah including to correct the imbalances in the economic and social structure of the country affecting Sabah, that Sabah shall have political autonomy whereby the government shall be formed and run by the people of Sabah, that Sabah shall be given fair and just participation in the federal administration.
On greater interests of Sabah SAPP prefers the cooperation formula as announced publicly by YB Lim Kit Siang at the DAP gathering held on 16 September 2008 at Kian Kok High School where Lim Kit Siang called SAPP as Pakatan-Plus.
Our committee will continue to discuss with the Pakatan Rakyat parties to achieve what the public aspire for.
DULLIE HJ MARIE is Vice President of SAPP and Head of SAPP Negotiating Team
DULLIE HJ MARIE is Vice President of SAPP and Head of SAPP Negotiating Team
Tuesday, June 7, 2011
PKR eyes Pakatan-SAPP alliance in Sabah
Clara Chooi
Pakatan Rakyat supporters during nomination day during the Batu Sapi by-election last year which BN won in a three-way fight involving both PKR for Pakatan and SAPP. — Picture by Jack Ooi
PR believes a pact with the active SAPP (Sabah Progressive Party), helmed by former chief minister Datuk Yong Teck Lee, will be crucial to boost the opposition’s chances against BN when elections are called.
The Malaysian Insider understands that Sabah PKR, under the leadership of party president Datin Seri Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail, has formed a “negotiation team” to lead the merger discussions with SAPP.
It is believed the members include Libaran PKR division chief Ahmad Thamrin Jaini, Papar PKR chief Datuk James Ghani, Tenom PKR chief Datuk Halik Zaman, Kota Kinabalu PKR chief Christina Liew, Tawau PKR division chief Datuk Kong Hong Ming, Sabah PKR Youth chief Jafery Jomion and PKR deputy secretary-general and Penampang division chief Darell Leiking, all of whom currently sits on the special presidential council which leads PKR’s Sabah chapter.
Other members on the team are ex-BN man and former federal deputy minister Datuk Kalakau Untol and PKR supreme council member Datuk Roland Chia.
A party insider confirmed with The Malaysian Insider that the committee members will meet today to appoint a chairman before discussions are initiated with PR’s Sabah parties about the merger.
Once an agreement is reached in Sabah PR, the insider added, negotiations with SAPP will start.
But if the Sarawak polls were any indication, such political cooperation could turn tricky, largely due to a likely clash in views between the peninsular-based PR pact and SAPP, whose struggles centre on promoting autonomy for Sabahans.
SAPP’s Yong has already grown testy over the proposal following a small fallout with DAP adviser Lim Kit Siang last week when the latter purportedly issued an ultimatum to the party, saying it must form a formal pact and not merely a political friendship.
When contacted yesterday, Sabah DAP chief Jimmy Wong stood by Lim’s ultimatum, saying it was issued with no malice intended.
SAPP, said Wong, must become a PR “blood brother” and not merely a friend or relative to the pact.
“We are openly inviting them to join us but you cannot just forge cooperation without joining us as a formal partner, a blood brother. If you merely become a friend or relative, you can abandon us when we are down.
Win or lose, sink or swim, we must stay together as a pact. And we must do it now,” he said.
Despite the tiff however, DAP and PKR have both openly indicated their intentions and the urgency to push for such an alliance while SAPP has stayed non-committal thus far.
But when contacted over the weekend, SAPP information chief Chong Pitt Fah also confirmed with The Malaysian Insider that the party has also formed a negotiation committee to discuss the merger proposal.
“But there has been silence on their part so far. We have formed our committees but we have not held any discussions,” he said.
He expressed confidence that a PKR-DAP-PAS-SAPP alliance will not go the way of Sarawak when negotiations between PR and Sarawak’s opposition SNAP failed to bear fruit, resulting in multicornered fights in 26 constituencies during the state polls on April 16.
“SAPP is a very active party. We have our support and we have two MPs and two assemblymen,” he said.
Thursday, June 2, 2011
Implications of Sarawak election on Sabah
In view of the super confidence of DAP that only they can bring change to Sabah, we wish to share with the public our party analysis of the DAP performance in the April Sarawak state elections and its implications on the coming general elections. SAPP had sent five teams to lend moral support to Pakatan and to learn about the Sarawak elections.
Sarawak DAP conducted a superb campaign, tapping into the widespread unhappiness among the urban Chinese whose discontent with the Taib Mahmud government has been simmering ever since 2006 over the urban land leases renewal issue. Other than national issues, the community generally found it difficult to do business due to monopolistic policies.
The anger is directed at the Chief Minister who has served for thirty years. It is as if the Chief Minister of Sabah today is still Datuk Harris Mohd. Salleh of 1981. The Chinese had at one time overwhelmingly supported Taib and BN ever since the 1987 Ming Court incident. That support has now being withdrawn.
DAP sent their entire party machinery from KL, Penang, Selangor, Perak and other states to Sarawak.
Money and time was not a constraint. Sarawak DAP was also smart enough to quickly settle the seat sharing formula with Sarawak National Party (SNAP) and PAS. The tension with PKR over two Chinese urban seats was resolved when the power to select candidates (by issuing the Authority to Use Party Symbol) was taken away from the Sarawak DAP chief by the DAP HQ in Kuala Lumpur. That way, PKR and DAP leaders in KL were able to settle the seats sharing whatever the wishes of the local leaders. This KL top down method is the same as the BN, which SAPP is uncomfortable with because it is against the principle of autonomy.
Out of the 15 seats contested by DAP, DAP did very well in the big towns (winning 10 seats with big majorities). In mixed seats, DAP won another two (Dudong and Batu Kawah with majorities of 317 and 543 votes respectively). DAP lost in two mixed seats (Bawang Assan and Simanggang by 1808 and 2447 votes). In Limbang's Bukit Kota mixed seat, where the entire Sabah DAP was encamped to help, DAP lost by a whopping 5001 votes (BN 6835 to DAP 1774).
It is safe to assume that DAP would have won also Batu Lintang in Kuching (won by PKR) and Senadin in Miri (PKR lost by 58 votes) if DAP had contested in these two seats. This makes a maximum potential of 14 DAP state seats. But this is Sarawak DAP's maximum because in parliamentary elections, DAP resources will be stretched nationwide. The fact that, after the Sarawak elections, DAP supremo Lim Kit Siang openly called for a DAP-SNAP merger shows that the DAP leadership knew that DAP has reached its peak in Sarawak.
The outcome in Sarawak is that the Chinese represented by DAP is now in the opposition and the bumiputras, represented by other parties, remain in government. This is the "two parties system" championed by DAP, with the Chinese in the opposition and the Bumiputras in government. This is the DAP "416" promise of change of toppling Taib Mahmud on April 16. Instead, "416" turned out to be Taib's victory because Taib was sworn in on the evening of "416".
This is why SAPP had called on DAP green horns in Sabah not to be over elated by their so-called success in Sarawak. Sarawak "416" is neither a success for the opposition nor for Sarawak nor for the Chinese community.
Implications for the parliamentary elections
Translating the state results into parliamentary seats, when counted with neighbouring BN strongholds, the DAP and PKR combined strength is only 3 to 5 parliamentary seats. For instance, Bakelalan (PKR majority 473) would be outnumbered by Bukit Sari (BN majority 5063) when counted as one parliamentary seat (Lawas). This means BN could keep 26 to 28 of the 31 MPs in Sarawak. This is no secret because every party head quarters, be it BN, UMNO, DAP, PKR, PAS or SAPP has done their own analysis.
Therefore, to achieve Pakatan's target of 15 MPs from Sabah and Sarawak, the combined Sabah opposition (Pakatan plus SAPP) has to garner 10 to 12 MP seats out of the 25 MP seats in Sabah. To achieve this target, SAPP respects the wish of the people that the opposition works together. SAPP has been playing our part; our leaders have met with PKR and DAP leaders at various levels from top to bottom, attending Pakatan functions and building mutual confidence.
But we do not agree with the Lim Kit Siang's view that "to change Sabah, we must have change in Malaysia". In fact, to change Malaysia, we must have change in Sabah. This is because, if the national opposition cannot win in Sabah and Sarawak, then there is no change in Malaysia. SAPP aims to restore autonomy to Sabah by having a change of government in Sabah and in Putrajaya. It is not sufficient to have a mere changing of urban YBs like what happened in the recent Sarawak elections.
Datuk Richard Yong We Kong is Secretary General, SAPP
Datuk Richard Yong We Kong is Secretary General, SAPP
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
A New Alliance
By Zaid Ibrahim
Like many Malaysians today, I think our country’s politics is on the verge of breakdown. The Pakatan Rakyat has not managed to play a meaningful political role as a federal Opposition. The checks and balances they are supposed to provide have given way to so much hostility that they will shoot down everything the Barisan Nasional proposes, even good ideas.
This behaviour automatically triggers equally vicious reactions from the BN and there is so much mutual hatred even in Parliament that we wonder whether good laws are being made. How can there be? There is so little real debate. There is almost no engagement between the two sides.
Leaders in the BN and Pakatan seem interested only in annihilating each other. One side can “gain” only if the other side “loses”, but the reality is that no one wins in this kind of system. It is unhealthy and it is certainly not democratic. This endless acrimony brings no benefit to the Rakyat. They are disappointed by all the broken promises, the absent leadership, and the blind pursuit of power that puts party politics above all else.
Many openly say the BN is no longer a working coalition. Some of the major component parties nolonger enjoy the support of their constituents and they cannot come to the table as equal partners as they once did. Only UMNO continues to wield its traditional influence—but without the strength of its partners to bring balance, UMNO too has changed. It has become autocratic and fixed in its ways. It is unaware, or afraid, of the need to change. It has become deaf to the needs of others.
Even now there is a movement within UMNO that wants more seats at the next General Election at the expense of the component parties. If this happens, the BN will cease to be a coalition even in name. It will no longer represent Malaysians. It will represent only its own interests and I fear for my country and my fellow citizens should that day ever come.
What about the Pakatan? Not only has it failed to provide a real and constructive Opposition to the Government, it has positioned Anwar as beyond question and reproach. He can do no wrong and his “coalition” follows him blindly out of politically expedience.
Anwar is a convenient figurehead, and he is the only person holding the Pakatan together. PAS and the DAP are still utterly divided on the issue of the Islamic state. They have merely postponed their differences—not resolved them—for the sake of achieving political power. In situations like this, basic questions of right and wrong get lost in the mud of ambition. Why should a coalition depend exclusively on the cult-status of one man alone?
How can we expect the Pakatan to provide responsible leadership if it simply ignores its own internal differences? Have we even seen any evidence that the Pakatan is a real coalition and not a marriage of convenience?
No, we haven’t, and because they are locked in the endless death-struggle with the BN, we can’texpect anything more of them either.
So, what about the rest of us who are sick of this endless political feuding? There are many of us who adhere closely to the founding principles of our nation regardless of the political leadership of the day. We put national unity first, and we work tirelessly to ensure, as Tunku Abdul Rahman wanted, a place in the sun for everyone.
We yearn for real debate on policies that affect us because we know that this is the process through which we make good laws. We want to engage all sides because we recognise that good ideas exist everywhere, regardless of creed, colour or political affiliation. We never dismiss an argument simply because we don’t like the person who says it—we evaluate proposals on their own merit for the benefit of all Malaysians, not just a particular party, ideology or interest.
Why don’t these Malaysians have a voice in our national political debate? Is it true that to take part in these discussions, we have to be either BN or Pakatan? Of course not. But we need to provide a new space so that individuals—and parties—that have been marginalised by the BN-Pakatan divide may come together.
We need a new alliance made up of Malaysians sincerely committed to a civil society, policy and the public interest.
But unlike the BN and Pakatan, this alliance agrees only on the fundamental principle that each of us has a right to express our views on policy and public issues, and to be heard. Our entitlement is to mutual respect. Our privilege is the responsibility we bear to ensure that each and every one of us gets a fair hearing.
This is how we can rebuild constructive engagement in our political landscape. And yes, we have to rebuild it brick by brick because it has been destroyed—this is an admission we must be honest and courageous enough to make. If the BN and Pakatan cannot recognise the good in each other on matters of national importance, then a new alliance must bridge the divide by being a “Loyal Opposition” devoted to Malaysia and the interests of its diverse peoples.
Such an alliance will provide valuable constructive criticism - or support - to the government of the day, whether at the state or federal level, and it is only through this process that we can reshape our political landscape and return to it the principles of parliamentary democracy that we cherish so much.
Like many Malaysians today, I think our country’s politics is on the verge of breakdown. The Pakatan Rakyat has not managed to play a meaningful political role as a federal Opposition. The checks and balances they are supposed to provide have given way to so much hostility that they will shoot down everything the Barisan Nasional proposes, even good ideas.
This behaviour automatically triggers equally vicious reactions from the BN and there is so much mutual hatred even in Parliament that we wonder whether good laws are being made. How can there be? There is so little real debate. There is almost no engagement between the two sides.
Leaders in the BN and Pakatan seem interested only in annihilating each other. One side can “gain” only if the other side “loses”, but the reality is that no one wins in this kind of system. It is unhealthy and it is certainly not democratic. This endless acrimony brings no benefit to the Rakyat. They are disappointed by all the broken promises, the absent leadership, and the blind pursuit of power that puts party politics above all else.
Many openly say the BN is no longer a working coalition. Some of the major component parties nolonger enjoy the support of their constituents and they cannot come to the table as equal partners as they once did. Only UMNO continues to wield its traditional influence—but without the strength of its partners to bring balance, UMNO too has changed. It has become autocratic and fixed in its ways. It is unaware, or afraid, of the need to change. It has become deaf to the needs of others.
Even now there is a movement within UMNO that wants more seats at the next General Election at the expense of the component parties. If this happens, the BN will cease to be a coalition even in name. It will no longer represent Malaysians. It will represent only its own interests and I fear for my country and my fellow citizens should that day ever come.
What about the Pakatan? Not only has it failed to provide a real and constructive Opposition to the Government, it has positioned Anwar as beyond question and reproach. He can do no wrong and his “coalition” follows him blindly out of politically expedience.
Anwar is a convenient figurehead, and he is the only person holding the Pakatan together. PAS and the DAP are still utterly divided on the issue of the Islamic state. They have merely postponed their differences—not resolved them—for the sake of achieving political power. In situations like this, basic questions of right and wrong get lost in the mud of ambition. Why should a coalition depend exclusively on the cult-status of one man alone?
How can we expect the Pakatan to provide responsible leadership if it simply ignores its own internal differences? Have we even seen any evidence that the Pakatan is a real coalition and not a marriage of convenience?
No, we haven’t, and because they are locked in the endless death-struggle with the BN, we can’texpect anything more of them either.
So, what about the rest of us who are sick of this endless political feuding? There are many of us who adhere closely to the founding principles of our nation regardless of the political leadership of the day. We put national unity first, and we work tirelessly to ensure, as Tunku Abdul Rahman wanted, a place in the sun for everyone.
We yearn for real debate on policies that affect us because we know that this is the process through which we make good laws. We want to engage all sides because we recognise that good ideas exist everywhere, regardless of creed, colour or political affiliation. We never dismiss an argument simply because we don’t like the person who says it—we evaluate proposals on their own merit for the benefit of all Malaysians, not just a particular party, ideology or interest.
Why don’t these Malaysians have a voice in our national political debate? Is it true that to take part in these discussions, we have to be either BN or Pakatan? Of course not. But we need to provide a new space so that individuals—and parties—that have been marginalised by the BN-Pakatan divide may come together.
We need a new alliance made up of Malaysians sincerely committed to a civil society, policy and the public interest.
But unlike the BN and Pakatan, this alliance agrees only on the fundamental principle that each of us has a right to express our views on policy and public issues, and to be heard. Our entitlement is to mutual respect. Our privilege is the responsibility we bear to ensure that each and every one of us gets a fair hearing.
This is how we can rebuild constructive engagement in our political landscape. And yes, we have to rebuild it brick by brick because it has been destroyed—this is an admission we must be honest and courageous enough to make. If the BN and Pakatan cannot recognise the good in each other on matters of national importance, then a new alliance must bridge the divide by being a “Loyal Opposition” devoted to Malaysia and the interests of its diverse peoples.
Such an alliance will provide valuable constructive criticism - or support - to the government of the day, whether at the state or federal level, and it is only through this process that we can reshape our political landscape and return to it the principles of parliamentary democracy that we cherish so much.
Sunday, May 29, 2011
"No ultimatum only harsh realities – “Time and tide waits for no man”
By Jeffrey
I respectfully disagree with PR’s position that defines national political change as being based on (1) a titanic struggle between BN vs PR (2) that those opposed to BN must “unite & join” under a single banner to give PR the additional 30+ seats in Sarawak & Sabah.
The strategy is not for PR win another 30 seats from East Malaysia but to deny BN that 30 seats. For that to happen Semenanjung PR’s leaders must recognize that foremost in Sarawkian & Sabah’s aspirations is regional political autonomy. This is their main grouse against UMNO/BN. PR therefore has nothing better to offer and bring to the table to advance this central East Malaysian aspiration if it requires East Malaysian political parties & parties (like Sabah’s SAPP & Sarawak’s SNAP) to unite under PR banner, follow its strict dictation on seat allocation that will be perceived there as serving more of PKR’s and DAP’s interest to expand their presence/control at expense of local parties. They don’t want to dislodge one neo colonialist semananjung mster (BN) for another (PR)!
The Opposition just can’t go there (East Malaysia), highlight local issues, stir regional sentiments there against Federal Control by BN and then when it comes to matters of next General election inconsistently dictate to locals there (Jeffrey kitingan or Yong Teck Ling) how to contest under PR’s banner and what to do. For that will be simply exciting aspirations that you you do not and cannot satisfy – that will only unleash a backlash!
I reiterate: the immediate step is not PR winning BN but BN losing in terms of seats to PR plus combination of local East Malaysian parties contesting under their own banners. You then all come together only after winning GE in this sense (otherwise its academic) but not before GE upon terms that East malaysians must contest under PR’s banner in an epic struggle defined narrowly as consisting only 2 players (ie BN & PR).
30 seats more for PR don’t help. Its a hung parliament! Neither can rule with a simple majority of a 2 or 3 parliamentarians more! If you have more, the other side will buy cross overs; if you have less, the other side couldn’t rule with such a small majority and will do even more drastic things to consolidate power than what was donme in 308! Either way the country will plunge to rough times. You’ve got to think big, bold, drastic and strategic, as what is needed is a paradigm shift in power equation – not a simple majority of 30! Its now or never to do so. Sorry thats the harsh reality.
I respectfully disagree with PR’s position that defines national political change as being based on (1) a titanic struggle between BN vs PR (2) that those opposed to BN must “unite & join” under a single banner to give PR the additional 30+ seats in Sarawak & Sabah.
The strategy is not for PR win another 30 seats from East Malaysia but to deny BN that 30 seats. For that to happen Semenanjung PR’s leaders must recognize that foremost in Sarawkian & Sabah’s aspirations is regional political autonomy. This is their main grouse against UMNO/BN. PR therefore has nothing better to offer and bring to the table to advance this central East Malaysian aspiration if it requires East Malaysian political parties & parties (like Sabah’s SAPP & Sarawak’s SNAP) to unite under PR banner, follow its strict dictation on seat allocation that will be perceived there as serving more of PKR’s and DAP’s interest to expand their presence/control at expense of local parties. They don’t want to dislodge one neo colonialist semananjung mster (BN) for another (PR)!
The Opposition just can’t go there (East Malaysia), highlight local issues, stir regional sentiments there against Federal Control by BN and then when it comes to matters of next General election inconsistently dictate to locals there (Jeffrey kitingan or Yong Teck Ling) how to contest under PR’s banner and what to do. For that will be simply exciting aspirations that you you do not and cannot satisfy – that will only unleash a backlash!
I reiterate: the immediate step is not PR winning BN but BN losing in terms of seats to PR plus combination of local East Malaysian parties contesting under their own banners. You then all come together only after winning GE in this sense (otherwise its academic) but not before GE upon terms that East malaysians must contest under PR’s banner in an epic struggle defined narrowly as consisting only 2 players (ie BN & PR).
30 seats more for PR don’t help. Its a hung parliament! Neither can rule with a simple majority of a 2 or 3 parliamentarians more! If you have more, the other side will buy cross overs; if you have less, the other side couldn’t rule with such a small majority and will do even more drastic things to consolidate power than what was donme in 308! Either way the country will plunge to rough times. You’ve got to think big, bold, drastic and strategic, as what is needed is a paradigm shift in power equation – not a simple majority of 30! Its now or never to do so. Sorry thats the harsh reality.
Pakatan wants to kill SAPP?
Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) Vice President Dullie Marie felt very disappointed and in delusion on what was uttered by DAP’s advisor, Lim Kit Siang during the dinner in conjunction with Harvest festival hosted by DAP.
"I was appointed by the Supreme Council to head a committee on any negotiation with DAP. The main objective to negotiate in good faith to have an understanding with DAP on one to one basis to face Barisan National in this coming election. This is also the aspiration expressed by of most the Sabahans.
Dullie, who is also SAPP Putatan CLC Chief said it was supposed to be an occasion to celebrate the real meaning of Harvest Festival as it originally intended; to celebrate on the spirit of cordial relationship among the people of Sabah but unfortunately it turned out to be political talks dominated by DAP leaders from Peninsular and of course some PR leaders in Sabah.
"Lim Kit Siang made a blatant speech by telling Sabahans that only through PR changes are possible. He blindly ignored without any regard on the existence of local party/parties. Not even a bit. Lim Kit Siang speech did not reflect at all on cooperation with local party like SAPP.
"He put it in ultimatum SAPP must be in PR, which we can assume and conclude it will be another episode like SNAP in Sarawak. It seems he simply ignored and insensitive to the feeling of most Sabahan. He was so passionate with excitement that makes him to forget PR was unregistered coalition.
"Besides, he totally disregarded the wishes of PR leaders in Sabah who know better the realities. The negotiation committee set up by SAPP was prompted due to the request made by DAP and PKR leaders in Sabah and Peninsular respectively.
"His attitude is a mere reflection of divide and rule imposed on Sabahans. This also tell us they are always in the upper hand and for us to survive we have to be subservient to their terms. We can safely conclude that PR leaders especially those from Peninsular will make decisions for their leaders in Sabah. They have no choices but to toe along the line.
"Generally the main objective is to kill local party like SAPP even before negotiations. By displaying such attitudes to reach mutual understanding will be rough and tough.
"Lim Kit Siang is very arrogant and insensitive in his speech. He managed to camouflage the audience who are mainly of the Chinese community. By sensationalizing on issues Lim forget to ask himself on actual number of Chinese seats in Sabah; he felt so great he is not even bothered to know on seats held by Bumiputras, Muslims and non-Muslims. Sabah is a multi-racial and religious society. Its issues differ so much from the West which usually bases along race and religious lines.
"The promise of making Sabah into a prosperous State within 100 days is nothing new. The same slogan we have had heard when UMNO began to spread its wings into Sabah in 1990s. But what had happened since then. Hence, he forgot to address the experience learnt by Sabahans from being ‘colonized’ for the last 48 years. He also quoted the speech made by Tan Sri Simon Sipaun on 7th March 2011. This is another superficial trick display; that by putting him in the limelight he (Lim) hoped psychologically able to hoodwink and lure the support from KDM community.
"I guess he displayed such arrogant attitude due to his party's success in Sarawak. Being a veteran politician he should have good answers on what happened on Chinese’s voting trends in Sarawak. Lim should also open his eyes on the voting trends on the natives of Sarawak. Why they are still rallied and gave their votes to BN despite on various exposures made by the opposition. The Sarawakians want to protect their own autonomy.
"Therefore, for PR to achieve its dreams to Putrajaya, he should stop this arrogance; stop the ego of being more superior than us here in Sabah. He has to remember this is the 21st century. We agreed on change and will cooperate but will not join any pact at this particular instance of time.
"SAPP would like to make total change based on the Malaysian Agreement 1963 on the basis of 20 Points and that Sabah is a partner in the formation of Malaysian Nation. Lim should remember without Sabah and Sarawak there won’t be a Malaysia today.
"I just like to remind Lim Kit Siang and other leaders from Peninsular that they should be more sensitive on what they say.
"We are loyal Malaysians and that we have grown with time. We believed the change must be made by Sabahans itself. Sabahans should be given the wisdoms on the real meaning of Independence. PR leaders should refrain from imposing colonist mentality to the Sabahans.
Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Shadow cabinet: Who is power hungry?
PKR vs DAP: More than just a spat, a crossroad for Pakatan and New Politics
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
KUCHING - The DAP and Parti Keadilan Rakyat are at loggerheads over the shadow cabinet line-up announced on Sunday. Sarawak DAP chairman Wong Ho Leng in his blog yesterday accused "someone" in the PKR Political Bureau of being "power hungry"' for objecting to being given "junior" portfolios. The DAP-PKR tussle over posts in the Sarawak shadow Cabinet escalated into a full-fledged war today - Malaysian Insider
If one reads the above with care, what does it all say?
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
Apparently still gloating on their Sarawak win, they have become vain and insensitive to their coalition partners in PKR Sarawak. Preferring to admonish their partners in public, without regard for sensitivities and close cooperation, will only lead to more misunderstanding. At the rate DAP is conducting themselves in the Pakatan Rakyat, it won’t be long before this attitude will cause the disintegration of the Opposition Coalition.
Manipulative politics not part of New Politics
It is really senseless how internal squabbles can come out so openly in the mainstream media. One really wonders if third-parties have been prodding such a blow-up. Surely, DAP has enough sense to sit down and work it out with their coalition partners? Already PAS is wondering what the hell is going on. The MSM had a field day reporting this exclusive and splashed it all over national television. BN leaders are also laughing their heads off.
DAP really needs to shake off such a mentality if it intends to stay in the coalition. The SNAP-DAP merger fiasco is hardly over, and yet DAP Sarawak has already started another one. Such bullying tactics in the past led a meek PKR into conceding most of the choice urban seats to DAP. Insisting on safe seat allocations in the urban areas at the expense of PKR, DAP went on to garner a historic win. Offering little help to PKR during the Sarawak election, who were seriously shorthanded while contesting on all fronts, had also impaired PKR’s chances to win more seats than anticipated.
Sarawak PKR chief Baru Bian has in the past given in to DAP’s demands as an equal coalition partner, but DAP still continues to take advantage of his friendly gesture. It is Wrong to think you are smart and he is naive. This is not what new politics is about. This is even worse than old politics. How is it different from manipluating and bullying? Shame on you, Wong Ho Leng and DAP.
Just as we call on Malaysians to reject the corrupt and despicablle Umno elite and BN, we must call on Malaysians to reject this sort of 'cheating' politics - of getting unfair advantage by taking undue advantange, and later on having the cheek to laugh at your opponent for being naive and falling to your 'skilled' hand. Do we admire this type of he-man, cave-man tactics? Which leads to the question of what type of culture do we want for ourselves and our children?
Do we want to be smart, sharp, alert, capable, caring and protecting of those who are less gifted? Or do we simply want to be cunning, calculative and win at all costs? Malaysians, think carefully. Don't blindly support for the sake of supporting. All leaders, regardless of party Or coalition, must Deserve our respect especially as far as such basics are concerned.
Bumi and Dayak interest
Making a mockery of Baru Bian’s suggestion to include a more equal Bumi and Dayak participation in the Shadow Cabinet, DAP's Wong Ho Leng had also gone on to belittle his counterpart in PKR. He rubbed salt into Baru by describing the portfolio alloted to him as 'junior'. Is this sheer spite or gross insensitivity? Whichever disgusting reason, Wong Ho Leng should go back to school and learn some manners before he walks out the door as a Member of our Malaysian Parliament!
The question is, why is Wong making it so personal? Is he trying to chop down Baru Bian's persona and credibility so that he can be the indisputable 'Chief Minister' of Sarawak. So much ambition with just 12 seats! It is incredible and if this is a reflection of how other DAP leaders are, especially at national level, then PKR and PAS must wake up instantly and dump DAP. They may look foolish for a while, but better they realize that they have been nurturing a viper in their bosom before they become like MCA - raped, abused and ditched by an uncaring spouse!
Wong has sunk to a personal low by questioning the Sarawak PKR chief’s powers. Why can’t he try to listen to Baru Bian's views instead of railroading the Shadow Cabinet proposal through at press conference and later on with juicy statement aimed at tarnishing his own coalition mate? If I were PKR and PAS, I would demand disciplinary action against him. Is there any difference between him and Zulkifli Noordin or Zahrain Hashim. Even Wee Choo Keong has a bit more class, and that to me, is really digging the bottom of the barrel.
Wong cannot hide the fact that Bumi and Malay interest were sidelined in DAP's Shadow Cabinet proposal. Yes, DAP federal level - please do take note of this. It is DAP's proposed Shadow Cabinet lineup and not Wong's. This is how the people in Sarawak will judge the lineup - a DAP proposal. And the people of Sarawak are more than just Chinese. Nearly 70 per cent of Sarawakians are non-Chinese, in fact.
Winnability and Winning the Only Thing
I fail to understand why Guan Eng and Kit Siang continue to close an eye and let Sarawak run wild when they should withdraw their franchise if Wong and co. really have full automation. Why let a loose cannon tar the good name of the DAP?
If winnability and the number of seats are all that matters, then every single Single one of the Sarawakian people should vote BN and dump Pakatan. If it is all a numbers game and winning is all that counts, let's stick with the BN. Why take a chance this motley group of Churchmouses calling themselves DAP, PKR and PAS!
Many Malaysians often say silly things like, Winning is not the Only thing, it is Everything! Then let's keep Taib Mahmud. Who can beat him at the numbers and winnability game? At 75, he cleans up 35 seats each time for the PBB for the past 30 years. Enough humbers for you? Seeing stars yet?
Wong can stubbornly cling onto his face, but as far as national and state politics are concerned, he is nearly finished! So instead of swaggering and thinking of how to teach these orang peninsula a lesson, he should realize he is already yesterday's news in Sarawak itself. How many Iban, Dayak, Bidayuh, Orang Ulu, Malay and Melanau in Sarawak would wish to go near him after his Crass reaction on the Shadow Cabinet lineup that marginalizes their representation?
The arrogant should always repent. Humility is the core essence of humanity. Those who are guilty may have used their cunning to take advantage and bully their colleagues. And Malaysians, DAP and Pakatan supporters may have been blinded because of the recent election success. They forgot the very promises that Pakatan made - Reform, New Politics, Civil Culture.
So do not try to grandstand in public or deflect attention from this fact. Never ever try to deal like this again. Stop the hot gas, start working by repairing ties with humility. Maybe that way, you can gain the forgiveness of your colleagues and the Sarawak people. It is actually a very Serious crime what DAP has done. It is little different from what Pakatan keeps accusing Umno of doing - bamboozling people and being hypocritical. No amount of water can wash you guys clean.
Summary and implications for DAP, PAS and PKR
A stern-faced Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim had dismissed the shadow Cabinet line-up as a mere proposal from DAP, claiming the final list had yet to be determined by other PR parties. He has also just called on the Pakatan to close ranks.
Really, it is simply incredible that the setup of a Shadow cabinet at the state level can erupt into a full scale mudslinging contest. Seriously, DAP should investigate if there 'external' forces that encouraged Wong Ho Leng into his horrible actions.
It is also unacceptable of Wong Ho Leng to go public with his grievances. In the aftermath of the Kedah DAP fiasco in 2009, wasn't the Pakatan secretariat set up for a purpose? Doesn't the DAP, or for that matter PKR and PAS, respect their own secretariat. If not, then this is another lie the DAP and Pakatan has told the nation. Please don't rush to make a public announcement. Clarify among yourselves first, then only only tell. And make sure, you tell the truth now.
Sarawak DAP must come to terms that PKR and PAS are part and parcel of the Opposition Coalition. Due respect and a smooth cooperation should be the order of the day amongst coalition partners. DAP cannot continue to make their own calls, without due consultation with the Coalition Partners.
Finally, this fiasco is a stab in the back for Sarawak PKR and its chief Baru Bian. It is very unethical and totally uncalled for and Baru should be extended an apology for such a low blow. Truly, memories of PKR's Zulkifli Noordin and PAS' Khalid Samad come back to me.
If DAP at federal level cannot get its Sarawak leaders to resolve this matter amicably, we are pretty sure that this coalition will not last.
PAS would be better off in the arms of UMNO, before this coalition collapses and it loses more Malay votes. Being an Islamic party in a Muslim-predominant country, it will always have its own core and can only be rocked by external turbulence for a limited period of time.
PKR has always lived on principles and ideals - it takes only 24 hours to collapse this party because it is just a baby party. But being a baby party - it takes just 24 hours for it to grow back again. But as long it always stays true to its ideals, it will bounce back bigger and stronger. The day it stops doing that will truly be "the day the music died".
And DAP - the lone-ranger Chinese party. Unable to get along with anyone after all these years. Because it is too boastful and too bullying. It will have to continue to compete with the MCA and another pseudo-multiracial party, Gerakan.
Is that what you guys want people to think. Then the whole bunch of you - DAP, PAS and PKR - had better get your act together because I for one am starting to think of voting for Umno!
- Malaysia Chronicle
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
KUCHING - The DAP and Parti Keadilan Rakyat are at loggerheads over the shadow cabinet line-up announced on Sunday. Sarawak DAP chairman Wong Ho Leng in his blog yesterday accused "someone" in the PKR Political Bureau of being "power hungry"' for objecting to being given "junior" portfolios. The DAP-PKR tussle over posts in the Sarawak shadow Cabinet escalated into a full-fledged war today - Malaysian Insider
If one reads the above with care, what does it all say?
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
Apparently still gloating on their Sarawak win, they have become vain and insensitive to their coalition partners in PKR Sarawak. Preferring to admonish their partners in public, without regard for sensitivities and close cooperation, will only lead to more misunderstanding. At the rate DAP is conducting themselves in the Pakatan Rakyat, it won’t be long before this attitude will cause the disintegration of the Opposition Coalition.
Manipulative politics not part of New Politics
It is really senseless how internal squabbles can come out so openly in the mainstream media. One really wonders if third-parties have been prodding such a blow-up. Surely, DAP has enough sense to sit down and work it out with their coalition partners? Already PAS is wondering what the hell is going on. The MSM had a field day reporting this exclusive and splashed it all over national television. BN leaders are also laughing their heads off.
DAP really needs to shake off such a mentality if it intends to stay in the coalition. The SNAP-DAP merger fiasco is hardly over, and yet DAP Sarawak has already started another one. Such bullying tactics in the past led a meek PKR into conceding most of the choice urban seats to DAP. Insisting on safe seat allocations in the urban areas at the expense of PKR, DAP went on to garner a historic win. Offering little help to PKR during the Sarawak election, who were seriously shorthanded while contesting on all fronts, had also impaired PKR’s chances to win more seats than anticipated.
Sarawak PKR chief Baru Bian has in the past given in to DAP’s demands as an equal coalition partner, but DAP still continues to take advantage of his friendly gesture. It is Wrong to think you are smart and he is naive. This is not what new politics is about. This is even worse than old politics. How is it different from manipluating and bullying? Shame on you, Wong Ho Leng and DAP.
Just as we call on Malaysians to reject the corrupt and despicablle Umno elite and BN, we must call on Malaysians to reject this sort of 'cheating' politics - of getting unfair advantage by taking undue advantange, and later on having the cheek to laugh at your opponent for being naive and falling to your 'skilled' hand. Do we admire this type of he-man, cave-man tactics? Which leads to the question of what type of culture do we want for ourselves and our children?
Do we want to be smart, sharp, alert, capable, caring and protecting of those who are less gifted? Or do we simply want to be cunning, calculative and win at all costs? Malaysians, think carefully. Don't blindly support for the sake of supporting. All leaders, regardless of party Or coalition, must Deserve our respect especially as far as such basics are concerned.
Bumi and Dayak interest
Making a mockery of Baru Bian’s suggestion to include a more equal Bumi and Dayak participation in the Shadow Cabinet, DAP's Wong Ho Leng had also gone on to belittle his counterpart in PKR. He rubbed salt into Baru by describing the portfolio alloted to him as 'junior'. Is this sheer spite or gross insensitivity? Whichever disgusting reason, Wong Ho Leng should go back to school and learn some manners before he walks out the door as a Member of our Malaysian Parliament!
The question is, why is Wong making it so personal? Is he trying to chop down Baru Bian's persona and credibility so that he can be the indisputable 'Chief Minister' of Sarawak. So much ambition with just 12 seats! It is incredible and if this is a reflection of how other DAP leaders are, especially at national level, then PKR and PAS must wake up instantly and dump DAP. They may look foolish for a while, but better they realize that they have been nurturing a viper in their bosom before they become like MCA - raped, abused and ditched by an uncaring spouse!
Wong has sunk to a personal low by questioning the Sarawak PKR chief’s powers. Why can’t he try to listen to Baru Bian's views instead of railroading the Shadow Cabinet proposal through at press conference and later on with juicy statement aimed at tarnishing his own coalition mate? If I were PKR and PAS, I would demand disciplinary action against him. Is there any difference between him and Zulkifli Noordin or Zahrain Hashim. Even Wee Choo Keong has a bit more class, and that to me, is really digging the bottom of the barrel.
Wong cannot hide the fact that Bumi and Malay interest were sidelined in DAP's Shadow Cabinet proposal. Yes, DAP federal level - please do take note of this. It is DAP's proposed Shadow Cabinet lineup and not Wong's. This is how the people in Sarawak will judge the lineup - a DAP proposal. And the people of Sarawak are more than just Chinese. Nearly 70 per cent of Sarawakians are non-Chinese, in fact.
Winnability and Winning the Only Thing
I fail to understand why Guan Eng and Kit Siang continue to close an eye and let Sarawak run wild when they should withdraw their franchise if Wong and co. really have full automation. Why let a loose cannon tar the good name of the DAP?
If winnability and the number of seats are all that matters, then every single Single one of the Sarawakian people should vote BN and dump Pakatan. If it is all a numbers game and winning is all that counts, let's stick with the BN. Why take a chance this motley group of Churchmouses calling themselves DAP, PKR and PAS!
Many Malaysians often say silly things like, Winning is not the Only thing, it is Everything! Then let's keep Taib Mahmud. Who can beat him at the numbers and winnability game? At 75, he cleans up 35 seats each time for the PBB for the past 30 years. Enough humbers for you? Seeing stars yet?
Wong can stubbornly cling onto his face, but as far as national and state politics are concerned, he is nearly finished! So instead of swaggering and thinking of how to teach these orang peninsula a lesson, he should realize he is already yesterday's news in Sarawak itself. How many Iban, Dayak, Bidayuh, Orang Ulu, Malay and Melanau in Sarawak would wish to go near him after his Crass reaction on the Shadow Cabinet lineup that marginalizes their representation?
The arrogant should always repent. Humility is the core essence of humanity. Those who are guilty may have used their cunning to take advantage and bully their colleagues. And Malaysians, DAP and Pakatan supporters may have been blinded because of the recent election success. They forgot the very promises that Pakatan made - Reform, New Politics, Civil Culture.
So do not try to grandstand in public or deflect attention from this fact. Never ever try to deal like this again. Stop the hot gas, start working by repairing ties with humility. Maybe that way, you can gain the forgiveness of your colleagues and the Sarawak people. It is actually a very Serious crime what DAP has done. It is little different from what Pakatan keeps accusing Umno of doing - bamboozling people and being hypocritical. No amount of water can wash you guys clean.
Summary and implications for DAP, PAS and PKR
A stern-faced Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim had dismissed the shadow Cabinet line-up as a mere proposal from DAP, claiming the final list had yet to be determined by other PR parties. He has also just called on the Pakatan to close ranks.
Really, it is simply incredible that the setup of a Shadow cabinet at the state level can erupt into a full scale mudslinging contest. Seriously, DAP should investigate if there 'external' forces that encouraged Wong Ho Leng into his horrible actions.
It is also unacceptable of Wong Ho Leng to go public with his grievances. In the aftermath of the Kedah DAP fiasco in 2009, wasn't the Pakatan secretariat set up for a purpose? Doesn't the DAP, or for that matter PKR and PAS, respect their own secretariat. If not, then this is another lie the DAP and Pakatan has told the nation. Please don't rush to make a public announcement. Clarify among yourselves first, then only only tell. And make sure, you tell the truth now.
Sarawak DAP must come to terms that PKR and PAS are part and parcel of the Opposition Coalition. Due respect and a smooth cooperation should be the order of the day amongst coalition partners. DAP cannot continue to make their own calls, without due consultation with the Coalition Partners.
Finally, this fiasco is a stab in the back for Sarawak PKR and its chief Baru Bian. It is very unethical and totally uncalled for and Baru should be extended an apology for such a low blow. Truly, memories of PKR's Zulkifli Noordin and PAS' Khalid Samad come back to me.
If DAP at federal level cannot get its Sarawak leaders to resolve this matter amicably, we are pretty sure that this coalition will not last.
PAS would be better off in the arms of UMNO, before this coalition collapses and it loses more Malay votes. Being an Islamic party in a Muslim-predominant country, it will always have its own core and can only be rocked by external turbulence for a limited period of time.
PKR has always lived on principles and ideals - it takes only 24 hours to collapse this party because it is just a baby party. But being a baby party - it takes just 24 hours for it to grow back again. But as long it always stays true to its ideals, it will bounce back bigger and stronger. The day it stops doing that will truly be "the day the music died".
And DAP - the lone-ranger Chinese party. Unable to get along with anyone after all these years. Because it is too boastful and too bullying. It will have to continue to compete with the MCA and another pseudo-multiracial party, Gerakan.
Is that what you guys want people to think. Then the whole bunch of you - DAP, PAS and PKR - had better get your act together because I for one am starting to think of voting for Umno!
- Malaysia Chronicle
Thursday, May 5, 2011
80% in PolI says PKR an Umno Clone
Everyone of us, supporters or members of Pakatan Rakyat are looking forward and fighting very hard to see a change in Federal government comes this 13th general election.
As the days go by, the road to PutraJaya seems to be getting further and further away. What has happen? Everything seems to be breaking apart other then once in a while screaming from leaders that the coalition is still strong, working together and they are going to capture PutraJaya.
How is that to be when PKR leaders cannot provide truthful answers to all their follies. MPs and Aduns jumped ship, party members leaving, existing members not happy with what is going on and supporters dwindling.
There is no room for decent or vocal, all must abide according to what the leader said or instructed. Sound familiar and akin to Umno?
Within the three parties in the coalition, PKR wants to be the master and only what its leader says or instructs are valid. DAP suggest a merger with SNAP and without giving it a second thought was immediately rejected by PKR, the master. My tweet to PKR Anwar Ibrahim, "Explain why DAP can work with PAS despite history of differences, why PR cannot work with SNAP" and of course receive no reply.
The Sarawak shadow cabinet list can have so many controversies, mind you, its just a shadow cabinet and PKR wants to be in control.
Malaysia for all
As the days go by, the road to PutraJaya seems to be getting further and further away. What has happen? Everything seems to be breaking apart other then once in a while screaming from leaders that the coalition is still strong, working together and they are going to capture PutraJaya.
How is that to be when PKR leaders cannot provide truthful answers to all their follies. MPs and Aduns jumped ship, party members leaving, existing members not happy with what is going on and supporters dwindling.
There is no room for decent or vocal, all must abide according to what the leader said or instructed. Sound familiar and akin to Umno?
Within the three parties in the coalition, PKR wants to be the master and only what its leader says or instructs are valid. DAP suggest a merger with SNAP and without giving it a second thought was immediately rejected by PKR, the master. My tweet to PKR Anwar Ibrahim, "Explain why DAP can work with PAS despite history of differences, why PR cannot work with SNAP" and of course receive no reply.
The Sarawak shadow cabinet list can have so many controversies, mind you, its just a shadow cabinet and PKR wants to be in control.
Malaysia for all
Thursday, April 14, 2011
‘Two Pakatan leaders will ditch Anwar’
Kita officials claim a DAP and PAS chief will make the announcement after the Sarawak election.
PETALING JAYA: Two Kita officials have predicted that Anwar Ibrahim will lose the support of two senior Pakatan Rakyat leaders—one from DAP and the other from PAS—after the Sarawak state election.
The Kita men—central committee member Muhammad Firdaus Christopher and Selangor election committee chief Abdul Malek Shamsuddin—said the two Pakatan leaders would ask Anwar to give up his position as opposition leader because they believed he was indeed the man shown to be having sex with a prostitute in the controversial video screened for journalists last month.
They did not name the two leaders, but said their reason for waiting until after the Sarawak election was that Pakatan needed Anwar as a vote puller.
“But if Pakatan loses, they will blame Anwar,” Firdaus said.
Both Firdaus and Abdul Malek are former members of PKR, the party Anwar leads. They called on all leaders and members of Pakatan parties to stop defending the opposition leader in the face of what they said was clear evidence of his loose morals.
“By defending him, are they condoning his act,” Firdaus said.
The two also called on Anwar to give up politics “for the sake of the nation”.
“The nation has to progress,” Firdaus said. “He should be talking about how he is going to help the Indian poor, the Sabahans and Sarawakians instead of about his case.”
The main promoters of the sex video are tape, former Malacca chief minister Abdul Rahim Thamby Chik, Kedah businessman Shazryl Eskay Abdullah, and former senator Shuib Lazim.
Anwar has denied that he is the individual in the video. His family is also standing by him.
Inspector General of Police Ismail Omar last Thursday announced that the police had enough evidence to identify man the man in the video.
Kita was formed by Zaid Ibrahim after he had quit PKR following some disagreement with the party’s leadership.
By K Pragalath
PETALING JAYA: Two Kita officials have predicted that Anwar Ibrahim will lose the support of two senior Pakatan Rakyat leaders—one from DAP and the other from PAS—after the Sarawak state election.
The Kita men—central committee member Muhammad Firdaus Christopher and Selangor election committee chief Abdul Malek Shamsuddin—said the two Pakatan leaders would ask Anwar to give up his position as opposition leader because they believed he was indeed the man shown to be having sex with a prostitute in the controversial video screened for journalists last month.
They did not name the two leaders, but said their reason for waiting until after the Sarawak election was that Pakatan needed Anwar as a vote puller.
“But if Pakatan loses, they will blame Anwar,” Firdaus said.
Both Firdaus and Abdul Malek are former members of PKR, the party Anwar leads. They called on all leaders and members of Pakatan parties to stop defending the opposition leader in the face of what they said was clear evidence of his loose morals.
“By defending him, are they condoning his act,” Firdaus said.
The two also called on Anwar to give up politics “for the sake of the nation”.
“The nation has to progress,” Firdaus said. “He should be talking about how he is going to help the Indian poor, the Sabahans and Sarawakians instead of about his case.”
The main promoters of the sex video are tape, former Malacca chief minister Abdul Rahim Thamby Chik, Kedah businessman Shazryl Eskay Abdullah, and former senator Shuib Lazim.
Anwar has denied that he is the individual in the video. His family is also standing by him.
Inspector General of Police Ismail Omar last Thursday announced that the police had enough evidence to identify man the man in the video.
Kita was formed by Zaid Ibrahim after he had quit PKR following some disagreement with the party’s leadership.
By K Pragalath
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
SNAP is still Pakatan-friendly
Snap's priority is re-acquainting itself to the people, says party advisor Daniel Tajem.
KUCHING: Former diplomat and ex-deputy chief minister Daniel Tajem is quietly confident that Sarawak Nasional Party’s (Snap) primary objective will be achieved in the 10th Sarawak state election this Saturday even if it fails to make an impression on the election front.
Going into the election as underdogs, Snap, Tajem said, would have re-introduced itself to the grassroots voters.
Snap has had to suffer humiliation in the hands of its more manipulative brothers in the Pakatan Rakyat coalition in recent weeks.
Having said this, Snap’s advisor Tajem reiterated the party’s position as being Pakatan-friendly.
“I go back to the basic objective. Snap’s revival started only three months ago. At that time there were no plans or talk of taking part in the election.
“The aim was to reacquaint people to Snap. Then the election was called. It interfered with our plans and ended up with Snap being forced into participating,” he told FMT recently.
Tajem, who is considered an icon among the Dayaks, has distanced himself from the conflicts within Snap and the party’s collision with PKR.
Peninsular-based PKR, many here opined, has bulldozed its way into contesting in 48 seats. This has only ‘buried’ Snap’s aspiration of making a significant impact in the state polls on April 16.
“Snap is made up of many Dayaks. Our aim is to reach the many more out there. We believe Snap should be representing Dayak majority areas. Snap is a local party,” said Tajem.
“But there are two wings in Pakatan. One wing is trying to dominate the politics here and has made Snap a victim,” he added.
Beware of vote-buying
Although he declined to speculate on the election, Tajem did however say that “all the thinking Dayaks are not in Sarawak”.
“The 20 percent rural Dayaks who are educated are not in Sarawak anymore. They can’t get jobs here, so they are now working in peninsular, Singapore, the Middle East and even in as far as Norway and Mexico.
“They are not here. What you have left is the old Dayak who will be happy with the pittance thrown to them (by the BN),” he said on a bitter note.
In the 2006 polls, Tajem was a candidate in Bukit Begunan and was poised to win until hours before the election when BN stepped in with its “fear, bribe and threaten” campaign.
Tajem was up against BN candidate Mong Dagang. Dagang eventually won the seat by 1,007 votes.
“Its the rural voters’ characteristic….in the end, those who are leftovers in the longhouses will vote for them (BN) for the (RM)25 pittance.
“It’s the characteristic … it’s how they are,” he said, declining to to delve further.
Snap is contesting in 27 seats in the election. Intelligence sources say the party “could win two seats”.
In the run-up to the nominations, Snap was in a bitter tussle over overlapping seats with PKR which refused to budge on its decision to contest 48 seats. As a result of the disagreement, PKR and Snap will be battling it out with BN in 24 seats.
Along the way Snap was also alleged to be part of a covert BN operation to split voter support for PKR.
The Umno support
A reliable Umno source said the party was receiving its funds from an individual aligned to Umno.
The same source said that “in the event (Chief Minister) Taib (Mahmud) fails, BN wants to co-opt Snap.”
“There is a feeling that things are not good for BN that’s why they are making a deal with Snap.
“There also some here (in Umno) who feel it is time an Iban heads the state. It will also mean that BN is heeding the call of Sarawakians,” said the source.
By Pushparani Thilaganathan
KUCHING: Former diplomat and ex-deputy chief minister Daniel Tajem is quietly confident that Sarawak Nasional Party’s (Snap) primary objective will be achieved in the 10th Sarawak state election this Saturday even if it fails to make an impression on the election front.
Going into the election as underdogs, Snap, Tajem said, would have re-introduced itself to the grassroots voters.
Snap has had to suffer humiliation in the hands of its more manipulative brothers in the Pakatan Rakyat coalition in recent weeks.
Having said this, Snap’s advisor Tajem reiterated the party’s position as being Pakatan-friendly.
“I go back to the basic objective. Snap’s revival started only three months ago. At that time there were no plans or talk of taking part in the election.
“The aim was to reacquaint people to Snap. Then the election was called. It interfered with our plans and ended up with Snap being forced into participating,” he told FMT recently.
Tajem, who is considered an icon among the Dayaks, has distanced himself from the conflicts within Snap and the party’s collision with PKR.
Peninsular-based PKR, many here opined, has bulldozed its way into contesting in 48 seats. This has only ‘buried’ Snap’s aspiration of making a significant impact in the state polls on April 16.
“Snap is made up of many Dayaks. Our aim is to reach the many more out there. We believe Snap should be representing Dayak majority areas. Snap is a local party,” said Tajem.
“But there are two wings in Pakatan. One wing is trying to dominate the politics here and has made Snap a victim,” he added.
Beware of vote-buying
Although he declined to speculate on the election, Tajem did however say that “all the thinking Dayaks are not in Sarawak”.
“The 20 percent rural Dayaks who are educated are not in Sarawak anymore. They can’t get jobs here, so they are now working in peninsular, Singapore, the Middle East and even in as far as Norway and Mexico.
“They are not here. What you have left is the old Dayak who will be happy with the pittance thrown to them (by the BN),” he said on a bitter note.
In the 2006 polls, Tajem was a candidate in Bukit Begunan and was poised to win until hours before the election when BN stepped in with its “fear, bribe and threaten” campaign.
Tajem was up against BN candidate Mong Dagang. Dagang eventually won the seat by 1,007 votes.
“Its the rural voters’ characteristic….in the end, those who are leftovers in the longhouses will vote for them (BN) for the (RM)25 pittance.
“It’s the characteristic … it’s how they are,” he said, declining to to delve further.
Snap is contesting in 27 seats in the election. Intelligence sources say the party “could win two seats”.
In the run-up to the nominations, Snap was in a bitter tussle over overlapping seats with PKR which refused to budge on its decision to contest 48 seats. As a result of the disagreement, PKR and Snap will be battling it out with BN in 24 seats.
Along the way Snap was also alleged to be part of a covert BN operation to split voter support for PKR.
The Umno support
A reliable Umno source said the party was receiving its funds from an individual aligned to Umno.
The same source said that “in the event (Chief Minister) Taib (Mahmud) fails, BN wants to co-opt Snap.”
“There is a feeling that things are not good for BN that’s why they are making a deal with Snap.
“There also some here (in Umno) who feel it is time an Iban heads the state. It will also mean that BN is heeding the call of Sarawakians,” said the source.
By Pushparani Thilaganathan
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Investigate PKR’s real motives and greed
By Pakatan Borneo Warrior
Reply to SNAP’s Deal with BN- The Damning evidence
Sarawak Report is against the BN or is pro the BN? Why is Sarawak Report so happy to swallow the entire fabrication by a “BN supporter in KL”? Does Sarawak Report believe that if there is a plot between BN and SNAP, that the KL people will send the “explosive evidence” and “highly confidential” plan to Sarawak Report?
To me, the report is invented by greedy, self-centred PKR to kill SNAP even at the expense of an opposition victory.
Let’s look at the FACTS:
PKR is the one splitting the opposition votes with 3-cornered fights. After cornering DAP to only 15-seats and PAS 5-seats, PKR grabbed the balance 50 seats. But the PKR candidate for Pakan disappeared on nomination day. PKR now has 49 candidates. Talk is that the PKR candidate was bought. If SNAP had not fielded a candidate, then the BN would have got a walk over!! These are facts that PKR must answer.
SNAP finally contested in 26 Dayak seats. They had earlier threatened to contest in 40 seats, if PKR cannot come to an agreement with SNAP. As it happened, it was PKR that went all out to destroy opposition chances by fielding candidates in all the SNAP areas.
PKR had also fielded a candidate against the SNAP President, Edwin Dundang, at Marudi. The excuse was that PKR was afraid that the SNAP President might not turn up at the nomination and give the BN a walk over. Such a ludicrous statement was made by PKR.
Edwin has been fighting BN and Taib Mahmud even before PKR set foot in Sarawak. It therefore becomes suspicious why PKR wants to spoil the chances of fellow opposition SNAP which had joined PR last year. Are some PKR leaders agents of BN? Where did Azmin Ali get all his money to fund his nationwide party election last year?
If SNAP were an agent for BN, then they would have fielded candidates in PBB and mixed areas to split the votes to help PBB and SUPP.
SNAP contesting only in Dayak majority areas is totally consistent with their struggle to restore Dayak unity.
Whether one agrees or not with them, that is their struggle at this stage of the party. It is one of the oldest party in Sarawak, formed in 1961, even before Malaysia was formed.
SNAP members in DAP and PAS areas are openly supporting DAP and PAS. SNAP also avoided contests in Dayak seats like Bakelalan and Batang Ai where where PKR’s Baru Bian and Nicholas Bawin are accepted to be the strongest and have the best chance of beating BN. This is proof of SNAP sincerity.
Upon the collapse of negotiation between SNAP and PKR on the eve of nomination, PKR leaders like Tian Chua speculated that SNAP gets money from KL sources. This shows that PKR leaders are afraid of their own shadows. SNAP gets support from well wishers and common enemies of BN. Two days ago PKR Sarawak leader Baru Bian confirmed that SNAP has run out of money.
One might ask, where is PKR getting the money to fund its massive campaigns? Who is paying for the hordes of PKR campaigners from Peninsular Malaysia to fly to Sarawak, stay in hotels and spend their way through? Top financier of PKR is Sng Chee Wah, the top crony of Anwar in the UMNO days. Everybody in Sarawak and Sabah knows that kind of character Sng is.
In a way, we cannot blame PKR for being suspicious of other people. After all, PKR has the most number of defectors. MPs, assemblymen, ketua cabang and leaders at all levels have left PKR. Can they all be wrong? Some of those who remain in PKR are scandal ridden leaders, some charged for corruption, some fighting for projects and sand mining permits and one caught in nude. There is a whole load of heavy baggage in PKR.
The fact that PKR’s own leaders cannot be trusted is their own problem. They should not accuse others of untrustworthiness. They, after all, have no monopoly over the opposition. There are many, many people opposed to the BN and UMNO but are not aligned to PKR. SNAP is helping DAP and PAS. SNAP cannot help PKR for the simple reason that PKR wants to kill off SNAP. PKR by fielding candidates against all SNAP leaders is splitting the opposition to help the BN. SNAP by avoiding staying out of non-Dayak areas has helped the opposition.
Finally, how about the mystery of PKR fielding an unknown candidate against MoCS (Movement for Change Sarawak) candidate at Balingian, the seat held by white hair Taib Mahmud? Once again, PKR has caused a split in the opposition vote of MoCS candidate Salleh Jafaruddin, who is a senior leader with enough stature to take on Taib.
After the Sarawak elections, we must investigate the real motives and greed of PKR.
Reply to SNAP’s Deal with BN- The Damning evidence
Sarawak Report is against the BN or is pro the BN? Why is Sarawak Report so happy to swallow the entire fabrication by a “BN supporter in KL”? Does Sarawak Report believe that if there is a plot between BN and SNAP, that the KL people will send the “explosive evidence” and “highly confidential” plan to Sarawak Report?
To me, the report is invented by greedy, self-centred PKR to kill SNAP even at the expense of an opposition victory.
Let’s look at the FACTS:
PKR is the one splitting the opposition votes with 3-cornered fights. After cornering DAP to only 15-seats and PAS 5-seats, PKR grabbed the balance 50 seats. But the PKR candidate for Pakan disappeared on nomination day. PKR now has 49 candidates. Talk is that the PKR candidate was bought. If SNAP had not fielded a candidate, then the BN would have got a walk over!! These are facts that PKR must answer.
![]() |
| Edwin Dundang |
PKR had also fielded a candidate against the SNAP President, Edwin Dundang, at Marudi. The excuse was that PKR was afraid that the SNAP President might not turn up at the nomination and give the BN a walk over. Such a ludicrous statement was made by PKR.
Edwin has been fighting BN and Taib Mahmud even before PKR set foot in Sarawak. It therefore becomes suspicious why PKR wants to spoil the chances of fellow opposition SNAP which had joined PR last year. Are some PKR leaders agents of BN? Where did Azmin Ali get all his money to fund his nationwide party election last year?
![]() |
| Azmin Ali |
SNAP contesting only in Dayak majority areas is totally consistent with their struggle to restore Dayak unity.
Whether one agrees or not with them, that is their struggle at this stage of the party. It is one of the oldest party in Sarawak, formed in 1961, even before Malaysia was formed.
SNAP members in DAP and PAS areas are openly supporting DAP and PAS. SNAP also avoided contests in Dayak seats like Bakelalan and Batang Ai where where PKR’s Baru Bian and Nicholas Bawin are accepted to be the strongest and have the best chance of beating BN. This is proof of SNAP sincerity.
Upon the collapse of negotiation between SNAP and PKR on the eve of nomination, PKR leaders like Tian Chua speculated that SNAP gets money from KL sources. This shows that PKR leaders are afraid of their own shadows. SNAP gets support from well wishers and common enemies of BN. Two days ago PKR Sarawak leader Baru Bian confirmed that SNAP has run out of money.
One might ask, where is PKR getting the money to fund its massive campaigns? Who is paying for the hordes of PKR campaigners from Peninsular Malaysia to fly to Sarawak, stay in hotels and spend their way through? Top financier of PKR is Sng Chee Wah, the top crony of Anwar in the UMNO days. Everybody in Sarawak and Sabah knows that kind of character Sng is.
In a way, we cannot blame PKR for being suspicious of other people. After all, PKR has the most number of defectors. MPs, assemblymen, ketua cabang and leaders at all levels have left PKR. Can they all be wrong? Some of those who remain in PKR are scandal ridden leaders, some charged for corruption, some fighting for projects and sand mining permits and one caught in nude. There is a whole load of heavy baggage in PKR.
The fact that PKR’s own leaders cannot be trusted is their own problem. They should not accuse others of untrustworthiness. They, after all, have no monopoly over the opposition. There are many, many people opposed to the BN and UMNO but are not aligned to PKR. SNAP is helping DAP and PAS. SNAP cannot help PKR for the simple reason that PKR wants to kill off SNAP. PKR by fielding candidates against all SNAP leaders is splitting the opposition to help the BN. SNAP by avoiding staying out of non-Dayak areas has helped the opposition.
Finally, how about the mystery of PKR fielding an unknown candidate against MoCS (Movement for Change Sarawak) candidate at Balingian, the seat held by white hair Taib Mahmud? Once again, PKR has caused a split in the opposition vote of MoCS candidate Salleh Jafaruddin, who is a senior leader with enough stature to take on Taib.
After the Sarawak elections, we must investigate the real motives and greed of PKR.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










