By Jeffrey
I respectfully disagree with PR’s position that defines national political change as being based on (1) a titanic struggle between BN vs PR (2) that those opposed to BN must “unite & join” under a single banner to give PR the additional 30+ seats in Sarawak & Sabah.
The strategy is not for PR win another 30 seats from East Malaysia but to deny BN that 30 seats. For that to happen Semenanjung PR’s leaders must recognize that foremost in Sarawkian & Sabah’s aspirations is regional political autonomy. This is their main grouse against UMNO/BN. PR therefore has nothing better to offer and bring to the table to advance this central East Malaysian aspiration if it requires East Malaysian political parties & parties (like Sabah’s SAPP & Sarawak’s SNAP) to unite under PR banner, follow its strict dictation on seat allocation that will be perceived there as serving more of PKR’s and DAP’s interest to expand their presence/control at expense of local parties. They don’t want to dislodge one neo colonialist semananjung mster (BN) for another (PR)!
The Opposition just can’t go there (East Malaysia), highlight local issues, stir regional sentiments there against Federal Control by BN and then when it comes to matters of next General election inconsistently dictate to locals there (Jeffrey kitingan or Yong Teck Ling) how to contest under PR’s banner and what to do. For that will be simply exciting aspirations that you you do not and cannot satisfy – that will only unleash a backlash!
I reiterate: the immediate step is not PR winning BN but BN losing in terms of seats to PR plus combination of local East Malaysian parties contesting under their own banners. You then all come together only after winning GE in this sense (otherwise its academic) but not before GE upon terms that East malaysians must contest under PR’s banner in an epic struggle defined narrowly as consisting only 2 players (ie BN & PR).
30 seats more for PR don’t help. Its a hung parliament! Neither can rule with a simple majority of a 2 or 3 parliamentarians more! If you have more, the other side will buy cross overs; if you have less, the other side couldn’t rule with such a small majority and will do even more drastic things to consolidate power than what was donme in 308! Either way the country will plunge to rough times. You’ve got to think big, bold, drastic and strategic, as what is needed is a paradigm shift in power equation – not a simple majority of 30! Its now or never to do so. Sorry thats the harsh reality.
Showing posts with label SNAP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SNAP. Show all posts
Sunday, May 29, 2011
Thursday, May 26, 2011
Is Anwar lying?
Anwar is lying, says SNAP
There was no written agreement with PKR or Pakatan Rakyat on seat allocations 'few months' before the April 16 Sarawak elections, says Sarawak Nasional Party.
KUCHING: Sarawak Nasional Party (SNAP) has strongly rebutted PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim’s claims that it had signed an agreement with the party, to contest only in three seats a few months before the recent Sarawak election.
SNAP Youth chief Dayrell Enterie said Anwar’s statement was “totally incorrect”.
“This statement of his (Anwar) is totally incorrect as neither SNAP nor its president (who was erroneously named Stanley Jugol in the Malaysiakini article) had entered into any written agreement whatsoever on seat allocations with PKR.
“SNAP wishes to reiterate that it is not a push-over party for any West Malaysian entity nor is SNAP a Pakatan stooge,” he said in a statement mailed to FMT.
Dayrell was responding to Anwar who had reportedly said that “there was an agreement in writing, where SNAP only agreed to contest three seats, and then they asked us if it is possible to have another three”.
“It was signed a few months before the election by (SNAP president) Stanley (Jugol),” Anwar had said.
Anwar had also said that Sarawak PKR chief Baru Bian and his “Dayak boys had strong issues against SNAP”.
“It was not just about being from a different party… (it was also about) whether or not this group of people (from SNAP) can be trusted,” Anwar said.
Inherent right
Expressing SNAP’s frustration, Dayrell said the party was fed up with the insinuations and allegations PKR has slapped it with.
“As a Sarawak-based Party, SNAP has an inherent right to decide its own direction. Being a local party, it has the legitimate obligation to care for Sarawakians.
“SNAP is fed up with the allegations by a Pakatan party that it is Umno-funded, and an agent for BN.
“We left because SNAP was not accorded any respect,” he said, adding that in view of PKR’s treatment of SNAP in the last state election, there is now a strong desire for SNAP to be unencumbered by any political collaboration.
This, however, did not mean that SNAP will not collaborate with anyone.
“SNAP subscribes to the Borneo Agenda which seeks the fulfilment of the 18-points of the 1962 Inter-Governmental Committee (IGC) Report.
“We welcome those who share SNAP’s aspirations to struggle for better deals for the people of Sarawak, especially the rural poor,” he said.
He added that it is imperative that all the election promises made by campaigners from Peninsular Malaysia be fulfilled.
“They should never assume that Sarawak can be a dumping ground for all these empty sweet talks and rhetoric. SNAP, after all, stays put while the West Malaysians have all left,” he said.
Lifted from FMT
There was no written agreement with PKR or Pakatan Rakyat on seat allocations 'few months' before the April 16 Sarawak elections, says Sarawak Nasional Party.
KUCHING: Sarawak Nasional Party (SNAP) has strongly rebutted PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim’s claims that it had signed an agreement with the party, to contest only in three seats a few months before the recent Sarawak election.
SNAP Youth chief Dayrell Enterie said Anwar’s statement was “totally incorrect”.
“This statement of his (Anwar) is totally incorrect as neither SNAP nor its president (who was erroneously named Stanley Jugol in the Malaysiakini article) had entered into any written agreement whatsoever on seat allocations with PKR.
“SNAP wishes to reiterate that it is not a push-over party for any West Malaysian entity nor is SNAP a Pakatan stooge,” he said in a statement mailed to FMT.
Dayrell was responding to Anwar who had reportedly said that “there was an agreement in writing, where SNAP only agreed to contest three seats, and then they asked us if it is possible to have another three”.
“It was signed a few months before the election by (SNAP president) Stanley (Jugol),” Anwar had said.
Anwar had also said that Sarawak PKR chief Baru Bian and his “Dayak boys had strong issues against SNAP”.
“It was not just about being from a different party… (it was also about) whether or not this group of people (from SNAP) can be trusted,” Anwar said.
Inherent right
Expressing SNAP’s frustration, Dayrell said the party was fed up with the insinuations and allegations PKR has slapped it with.
“As a Sarawak-based Party, SNAP has an inherent right to decide its own direction. Being a local party, it has the legitimate obligation to care for Sarawakians.
“SNAP is fed up with the allegations by a Pakatan party that it is Umno-funded, and an agent for BN.
“We left because SNAP was not accorded any respect,” he said, adding that in view of PKR’s treatment of SNAP in the last state election, there is now a strong desire for SNAP to be unencumbered by any political collaboration.
This, however, did not mean that SNAP will not collaborate with anyone.
“SNAP subscribes to the Borneo Agenda which seeks the fulfilment of the 18-points of the 1962 Inter-Governmental Committee (IGC) Report.
“We welcome those who share SNAP’s aspirations to struggle for better deals for the people of Sarawak, especially the rural poor,” he said.
He added that it is imperative that all the election promises made by campaigners from Peninsular Malaysia be fulfilled.
“They should never assume that Sarawak can be a dumping ground for all these empty sweet talks and rhetoric. SNAP, after all, stays put while the West Malaysians have all left,” he said.
Lifted from FMT
Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Shadow cabinet: Who is power hungry?
PKR vs DAP: More than just a spat, a crossroad for Pakatan and New Politics
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
KUCHING - The DAP and Parti Keadilan Rakyat are at loggerheads over the shadow cabinet line-up announced on Sunday. Sarawak DAP chairman Wong Ho Leng in his blog yesterday accused "someone" in the PKR Political Bureau of being "power hungry"' for objecting to being given "junior" portfolios. The DAP-PKR tussle over posts in the Sarawak shadow Cabinet escalated into a full-fledged war today - Malaysian Insider
If one reads the above with care, what does it all say?
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
Apparently still gloating on their Sarawak win, they have become vain and insensitive to their coalition partners in PKR Sarawak. Preferring to admonish their partners in public, without regard for sensitivities and close cooperation, will only lead to more misunderstanding. At the rate DAP is conducting themselves in the Pakatan Rakyat, it won’t be long before this attitude will cause the disintegration of the Opposition Coalition.
Manipulative politics not part of New Politics
It is really senseless how internal squabbles can come out so openly in the mainstream media. One really wonders if third-parties have been prodding such a blow-up. Surely, DAP has enough sense to sit down and work it out with their coalition partners? Already PAS is wondering what the hell is going on. The MSM had a field day reporting this exclusive and splashed it all over national television. BN leaders are also laughing their heads off.
DAP really needs to shake off such a mentality if it intends to stay in the coalition. The SNAP-DAP merger fiasco is hardly over, and yet DAP Sarawak has already started another one. Such bullying tactics in the past led a meek PKR into conceding most of the choice urban seats to DAP. Insisting on safe seat allocations in the urban areas at the expense of PKR, DAP went on to garner a historic win. Offering little help to PKR during the Sarawak election, who were seriously shorthanded while contesting on all fronts, had also impaired PKR’s chances to win more seats than anticipated.
Sarawak PKR chief Baru Bian has in the past given in to DAP’s demands as an equal coalition partner, but DAP still continues to take advantage of his friendly gesture. It is Wrong to think you are smart and he is naive. This is not what new politics is about. This is even worse than old politics. How is it different from manipluating and bullying? Shame on you, Wong Ho Leng and DAP.
Just as we call on Malaysians to reject the corrupt and despicablle Umno elite and BN, we must call on Malaysians to reject this sort of 'cheating' politics - of getting unfair advantage by taking undue advantange, and later on having the cheek to laugh at your opponent for being naive and falling to your 'skilled' hand. Do we admire this type of he-man, cave-man tactics? Which leads to the question of what type of culture do we want for ourselves and our children?
Do we want to be smart, sharp, alert, capable, caring and protecting of those who are less gifted? Or do we simply want to be cunning, calculative and win at all costs? Malaysians, think carefully. Don't blindly support for the sake of supporting. All leaders, regardless of party Or coalition, must Deserve our respect especially as far as such basics are concerned.
Bumi and Dayak interest
Making a mockery of Baru Bian’s suggestion to include a more equal Bumi and Dayak participation in the Shadow Cabinet, DAP's Wong Ho Leng had also gone on to belittle his counterpart in PKR. He rubbed salt into Baru by describing the portfolio alloted to him as 'junior'. Is this sheer spite or gross insensitivity? Whichever disgusting reason, Wong Ho Leng should go back to school and learn some manners before he walks out the door as a Member of our Malaysian Parliament!
The question is, why is Wong making it so personal? Is he trying to chop down Baru Bian's persona and credibility so that he can be the indisputable 'Chief Minister' of Sarawak. So much ambition with just 12 seats! It is incredible and if this is a reflection of how other DAP leaders are, especially at national level, then PKR and PAS must wake up instantly and dump DAP. They may look foolish for a while, but better they realize that they have been nurturing a viper in their bosom before they become like MCA - raped, abused and ditched by an uncaring spouse!
Wong has sunk to a personal low by questioning the Sarawak PKR chief’s powers. Why can’t he try to listen to Baru Bian's views instead of railroading the Shadow Cabinet proposal through at press conference and later on with juicy statement aimed at tarnishing his own coalition mate? If I were PKR and PAS, I would demand disciplinary action against him. Is there any difference between him and Zulkifli Noordin or Zahrain Hashim. Even Wee Choo Keong has a bit more class, and that to me, is really digging the bottom of the barrel.
Wong cannot hide the fact that Bumi and Malay interest were sidelined in DAP's Shadow Cabinet proposal. Yes, DAP federal level - please do take note of this. It is DAP's proposed Shadow Cabinet lineup and not Wong's. This is how the people in Sarawak will judge the lineup - a DAP proposal. And the people of Sarawak are more than just Chinese. Nearly 70 per cent of Sarawakians are non-Chinese, in fact.
Winnability and Winning the Only Thing
I fail to understand why Guan Eng and Kit Siang continue to close an eye and let Sarawak run wild when they should withdraw their franchise if Wong and co. really have full automation. Why let a loose cannon tar the good name of the DAP?
If winnability and the number of seats are all that matters, then every single Single one of the Sarawakian people should vote BN and dump Pakatan. If it is all a numbers game and winning is all that counts, let's stick with the BN. Why take a chance this motley group of Churchmouses calling themselves DAP, PKR and PAS!
Many Malaysians often say silly things like, Winning is not the Only thing, it is Everything! Then let's keep Taib Mahmud. Who can beat him at the numbers and winnability game? At 75, he cleans up 35 seats each time for the PBB for the past 30 years. Enough humbers for you? Seeing stars yet?
Wong can stubbornly cling onto his face, but as far as national and state politics are concerned, he is nearly finished! So instead of swaggering and thinking of how to teach these orang peninsula a lesson, he should realize he is already yesterday's news in Sarawak itself. How many Iban, Dayak, Bidayuh, Orang Ulu, Malay and Melanau in Sarawak would wish to go near him after his Crass reaction on the Shadow Cabinet lineup that marginalizes their representation?
The arrogant should always repent. Humility is the core essence of humanity. Those who are guilty may have used their cunning to take advantage and bully their colleagues. And Malaysians, DAP and Pakatan supporters may have been blinded because of the recent election success. They forgot the very promises that Pakatan made - Reform, New Politics, Civil Culture.
So do not try to grandstand in public or deflect attention from this fact. Never ever try to deal like this again. Stop the hot gas, start working by repairing ties with humility. Maybe that way, you can gain the forgiveness of your colleagues and the Sarawak people. It is actually a very Serious crime what DAP has done. It is little different from what Pakatan keeps accusing Umno of doing - bamboozling people and being hypocritical. No amount of water can wash you guys clean.
Summary and implications for DAP, PAS and PKR
A stern-faced Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim had dismissed the shadow Cabinet line-up as a mere proposal from DAP, claiming the final list had yet to be determined by other PR parties. He has also just called on the Pakatan to close ranks.
Really, it is simply incredible that the setup of a Shadow cabinet at the state level can erupt into a full scale mudslinging contest. Seriously, DAP should investigate if there 'external' forces that encouraged Wong Ho Leng into his horrible actions.
It is also unacceptable of Wong Ho Leng to go public with his grievances. In the aftermath of the Kedah DAP fiasco in 2009, wasn't the Pakatan secretariat set up for a purpose? Doesn't the DAP, or for that matter PKR and PAS, respect their own secretariat. If not, then this is another lie the DAP and Pakatan has told the nation. Please don't rush to make a public announcement. Clarify among yourselves first, then only only tell. And make sure, you tell the truth now.
Sarawak DAP must come to terms that PKR and PAS are part and parcel of the Opposition Coalition. Due respect and a smooth cooperation should be the order of the day amongst coalition partners. DAP cannot continue to make their own calls, without due consultation with the Coalition Partners.
Finally, this fiasco is a stab in the back for Sarawak PKR and its chief Baru Bian. It is very unethical and totally uncalled for and Baru should be extended an apology for such a low blow. Truly, memories of PKR's Zulkifli Noordin and PAS' Khalid Samad come back to me.
If DAP at federal level cannot get its Sarawak leaders to resolve this matter amicably, we are pretty sure that this coalition will not last.
PAS would be better off in the arms of UMNO, before this coalition collapses and it loses more Malay votes. Being an Islamic party in a Muslim-predominant country, it will always have its own core and can only be rocked by external turbulence for a limited period of time.
PKR has always lived on principles and ideals - it takes only 24 hours to collapse this party because it is just a baby party. But being a baby party - it takes just 24 hours for it to grow back again. But as long it always stays true to its ideals, it will bounce back bigger and stronger. The day it stops doing that will truly be "the day the music died".
And DAP - the lone-ranger Chinese party. Unable to get along with anyone after all these years. Because it is too boastful and too bullying. It will have to continue to compete with the MCA and another pseudo-multiracial party, Gerakan.
Is that what you guys want people to think. Then the whole bunch of you - DAP, PAS and PKR - had better get your act together because I for one am starting to think of voting for Umno!
- Malaysia Chronicle
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
KUCHING - The DAP and Parti Keadilan Rakyat are at loggerheads over the shadow cabinet line-up announced on Sunday. Sarawak DAP chairman Wong Ho Leng in his blog yesterday accused "someone" in the PKR Political Bureau of being "power hungry"' for objecting to being given "junior" portfolios. The DAP-PKR tussle over posts in the Sarawak shadow Cabinet escalated into a full-fledged war today - Malaysian Insider
If one reads the above with care, what does it all say?
It is really sad that DAP still has not shirked its chauvinistic mentality after all this years. Ignoring calls to open up the party to embrace multi racialism, today DAP is still a closed party helmed by a select few who continue to hang on to age-old politics.
Apparently still gloating on their Sarawak win, they have become vain and insensitive to their coalition partners in PKR Sarawak. Preferring to admonish their partners in public, without regard for sensitivities and close cooperation, will only lead to more misunderstanding. At the rate DAP is conducting themselves in the Pakatan Rakyat, it won’t be long before this attitude will cause the disintegration of the Opposition Coalition.
Manipulative politics not part of New Politics
It is really senseless how internal squabbles can come out so openly in the mainstream media. One really wonders if third-parties have been prodding such a blow-up. Surely, DAP has enough sense to sit down and work it out with their coalition partners? Already PAS is wondering what the hell is going on. The MSM had a field day reporting this exclusive and splashed it all over national television. BN leaders are also laughing their heads off.
DAP really needs to shake off such a mentality if it intends to stay in the coalition. The SNAP-DAP merger fiasco is hardly over, and yet DAP Sarawak has already started another one. Such bullying tactics in the past led a meek PKR into conceding most of the choice urban seats to DAP. Insisting on safe seat allocations in the urban areas at the expense of PKR, DAP went on to garner a historic win. Offering little help to PKR during the Sarawak election, who were seriously shorthanded while contesting on all fronts, had also impaired PKR’s chances to win more seats than anticipated.
Sarawak PKR chief Baru Bian has in the past given in to DAP’s demands as an equal coalition partner, but DAP still continues to take advantage of his friendly gesture. It is Wrong to think you are smart and he is naive. This is not what new politics is about. This is even worse than old politics. How is it different from manipluating and bullying? Shame on you, Wong Ho Leng and DAP.
Just as we call on Malaysians to reject the corrupt and despicablle Umno elite and BN, we must call on Malaysians to reject this sort of 'cheating' politics - of getting unfair advantage by taking undue advantange, and later on having the cheek to laugh at your opponent for being naive and falling to your 'skilled' hand. Do we admire this type of he-man, cave-man tactics? Which leads to the question of what type of culture do we want for ourselves and our children?
Do we want to be smart, sharp, alert, capable, caring and protecting of those who are less gifted? Or do we simply want to be cunning, calculative and win at all costs? Malaysians, think carefully. Don't blindly support for the sake of supporting. All leaders, regardless of party Or coalition, must Deserve our respect especially as far as such basics are concerned.
Bumi and Dayak interest
Making a mockery of Baru Bian’s suggestion to include a more equal Bumi and Dayak participation in the Shadow Cabinet, DAP's Wong Ho Leng had also gone on to belittle his counterpart in PKR. He rubbed salt into Baru by describing the portfolio alloted to him as 'junior'. Is this sheer spite or gross insensitivity? Whichever disgusting reason, Wong Ho Leng should go back to school and learn some manners before he walks out the door as a Member of our Malaysian Parliament!
The question is, why is Wong making it so personal? Is he trying to chop down Baru Bian's persona and credibility so that he can be the indisputable 'Chief Minister' of Sarawak. So much ambition with just 12 seats! It is incredible and if this is a reflection of how other DAP leaders are, especially at national level, then PKR and PAS must wake up instantly and dump DAP. They may look foolish for a while, but better they realize that they have been nurturing a viper in their bosom before they become like MCA - raped, abused and ditched by an uncaring spouse!
Wong has sunk to a personal low by questioning the Sarawak PKR chief’s powers. Why can’t he try to listen to Baru Bian's views instead of railroading the Shadow Cabinet proposal through at press conference and later on with juicy statement aimed at tarnishing his own coalition mate? If I were PKR and PAS, I would demand disciplinary action against him. Is there any difference between him and Zulkifli Noordin or Zahrain Hashim. Even Wee Choo Keong has a bit more class, and that to me, is really digging the bottom of the barrel.
Wong cannot hide the fact that Bumi and Malay interest were sidelined in DAP's Shadow Cabinet proposal. Yes, DAP federal level - please do take note of this. It is DAP's proposed Shadow Cabinet lineup and not Wong's. This is how the people in Sarawak will judge the lineup - a DAP proposal. And the people of Sarawak are more than just Chinese. Nearly 70 per cent of Sarawakians are non-Chinese, in fact.
Winnability and Winning the Only Thing
I fail to understand why Guan Eng and Kit Siang continue to close an eye and let Sarawak run wild when they should withdraw their franchise if Wong and co. really have full automation. Why let a loose cannon tar the good name of the DAP?
If winnability and the number of seats are all that matters, then every single Single one of the Sarawakian people should vote BN and dump Pakatan. If it is all a numbers game and winning is all that counts, let's stick with the BN. Why take a chance this motley group of Churchmouses calling themselves DAP, PKR and PAS!
Many Malaysians often say silly things like, Winning is not the Only thing, it is Everything! Then let's keep Taib Mahmud. Who can beat him at the numbers and winnability game? At 75, he cleans up 35 seats each time for the PBB for the past 30 years. Enough humbers for you? Seeing stars yet?
Wong can stubbornly cling onto his face, but as far as national and state politics are concerned, he is nearly finished! So instead of swaggering and thinking of how to teach these orang peninsula a lesson, he should realize he is already yesterday's news in Sarawak itself. How many Iban, Dayak, Bidayuh, Orang Ulu, Malay and Melanau in Sarawak would wish to go near him after his Crass reaction on the Shadow Cabinet lineup that marginalizes their representation?
The arrogant should always repent. Humility is the core essence of humanity. Those who are guilty may have used their cunning to take advantage and bully their colleagues. And Malaysians, DAP and Pakatan supporters may have been blinded because of the recent election success. They forgot the very promises that Pakatan made - Reform, New Politics, Civil Culture.
So do not try to grandstand in public or deflect attention from this fact. Never ever try to deal like this again. Stop the hot gas, start working by repairing ties with humility. Maybe that way, you can gain the forgiveness of your colleagues and the Sarawak people. It is actually a very Serious crime what DAP has done. It is little different from what Pakatan keeps accusing Umno of doing - bamboozling people and being hypocritical. No amount of water can wash you guys clean.
Summary and implications for DAP, PAS and PKR
A stern-faced Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim had dismissed the shadow Cabinet line-up as a mere proposal from DAP, claiming the final list had yet to be determined by other PR parties. He has also just called on the Pakatan to close ranks.
Really, it is simply incredible that the setup of a Shadow cabinet at the state level can erupt into a full scale mudslinging contest. Seriously, DAP should investigate if there 'external' forces that encouraged Wong Ho Leng into his horrible actions.
It is also unacceptable of Wong Ho Leng to go public with his grievances. In the aftermath of the Kedah DAP fiasco in 2009, wasn't the Pakatan secretariat set up for a purpose? Doesn't the DAP, or for that matter PKR and PAS, respect their own secretariat. If not, then this is another lie the DAP and Pakatan has told the nation. Please don't rush to make a public announcement. Clarify among yourselves first, then only only tell. And make sure, you tell the truth now.
Sarawak DAP must come to terms that PKR and PAS are part and parcel of the Opposition Coalition. Due respect and a smooth cooperation should be the order of the day amongst coalition partners. DAP cannot continue to make their own calls, without due consultation with the Coalition Partners.
Finally, this fiasco is a stab in the back for Sarawak PKR and its chief Baru Bian. It is very unethical and totally uncalled for and Baru should be extended an apology for such a low blow. Truly, memories of PKR's Zulkifli Noordin and PAS' Khalid Samad come back to me.
If DAP at federal level cannot get its Sarawak leaders to resolve this matter amicably, we are pretty sure that this coalition will not last.
PAS would be better off in the arms of UMNO, before this coalition collapses and it loses more Malay votes. Being an Islamic party in a Muslim-predominant country, it will always have its own core and can only be rocked by external turbulence for a limited period of time.
PKR has always lived on principles and ideals - it takes only 24 hours to collapse this party because it is just a baby party. But being a baby party - it takes just 24 hours for it to grow back again. But as long it always stays true to its ideals, it will bounce back bigger and stronger. The day it stops doing that will truly be "the day the music died".
And DAP - the lone-ranger Chinese party. Unable to get along with anyone after all these years. Because it is too boastful and too bullying. It will have to continue to compete with the MCA and another pseudo-multiracial party, Gerakan.
Is that what you guys want people to think. Then the whole bunch of you - DAP, PAS and PKR - had better get your act together because I for one am starting to think of voting for Umno!
- Malaysia Chronicle
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
PKR: Gabungan DAP-Snap tak masuk akal
PETALING JAYA: Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) hari ini menolak cadangan penggabungan antara DAP dengan Parti Kebangsaan Sarawak (Snap) dalam usaha meningkatkan lagi sokongan rakyat Sarawak khususnya masyarakat Dayak kepada Pakatan Rakyat (PR).
Sambil menyifatkan idea tersebut sebagai ‘tidak masuk akal’, Pengarah Strategi PKR Mohd Rafizi Ramli berpendapat DAP perlu mempertimbangkan semula cadangan itu berikutan kredibiliti Snap sendiri yang gagal meraih sokongan masyarakat Dayak dan Iban.
“Saya tak nampak bagaimana gabungan itu boleh memberikan satu lonjakan sokongan yang mendadak kepada PR.
“Secara logiknya kalau mahu bergabung untuk menaikkan undi Dayak kepada PR perlu ada kekuatan dalaman parti sendiri tapi Snap tidak ada apabila kalah dan hilang deposit di 25 kerusi daripada 26 kerusi yang ditandinginya.
“Malah Snap semasa pilihan raya bulan lalu mempunyai jentera yang lemah dan tidak berusaha untuk meraih sokongan rakyat ,” katanya dalam sidang media di ibu pejabat PKR di sini hari ini.
Penasihat DAP Lim Kit Siang sebelum ini pernah mencadangkan DAP dan Snap digabungkan sebagai usaha untuk mempercepatkan kesedaran politik Dayak berikutan pilihan raya Sarawak 16 April lalu sekaligus mengelakkan pertandingan pelbagai penjuru yang hanya menguntungkan Barisan Nasional (BN).
Beliau berkata, cadangan itu seolah-olah seperti PR sudah melupakan ‘pengkhianatan’ Snap di saat akhir penamaan calon pilhan raya Sarawak bulan lalu sehingga PKR akhirnya terpaksa bertanding 49 kerusi daripada perancangan awal yang hanya mahu meletakkan calon di 25 kerusi sahaja.
Snap belum jelaskan pendiriannya
Malah Rafizi berkata Snap juga sehingga sekarang belum menjelaskan pendiriannya dalam PR termasuk ada laporan parti itu menerima bantuan kewangan daripada Ketua Menteri Sarawak Tan Sri Taib Mahmud termasuk kenyataan Presidennya Edwin Dundang yang menyokong Taib terus kekal meneraju Sarawak.
“Kita tak boleh lupa dan maafkan pengkhianatan yang dibuat sehingga PKR terpaksa berlawan kerusi tiga penjuru.
“Kalau Snap mainkan peranan yang adil dalam PR, PKR tak perlu bertanding 49 kerusi tapi Snap tak mahu ambil tanggungjawab dan mereka bertanding di 25 kerusi dimana PKR sudah mempunyai jentera dan pemimpin yang mantap dikawasan tersebut,” katanya.
Katanya, setiap parti dalam PR perlu berusaha sendiri untuk mendekati dan mendapat keyakinan masyarakat pedalaman dan Dayak walaupun ia mengambil masa yang lama.
“Tidak ada jalan pintas untuk mendekati masyarakat Dayak melainkan kita sendiri bekerja dan berusaha,” katanya.
Sehubungan itu, sebagai salah seorang sekretariat PR Rafizi berkata isu ini akan dibangkitkannya dalam mesyuarat ‘post-mortem’ PR yang akan diadakan esok.
“Kita mengalu-alukan kalau DAP ada usaha nak masuk pedalaman tapi kalau nak bergabung kita mesti tengok kesepakatan dan keuntungan kepada PR secara keseluruhannya,” katanya.
By Jamilah Kamarudin
Monday, April 25, 2011
Snap: Working together easier than merging
The views of Sarawak National Party (Snap) members have to be sought before any move is made to merge the party with the DAP, its secretary-general Stanley Jugol explained today.
“We have to get their views as merger means dissolution of the party,” Jugol (left) said.
“Do they really want the party to be dissolved?” he said when asked to comment on DAP adviser Lim Kit Siang's statement yesterday.
Lim had said the proposed merger between the DAP and Snap was still at a preliminary stage, that it would be in the interests of the present opposition pact and would be of no threat to any party in the grouping.
“The Sarawak DAP leadership is still exploring the idea of a merger. It (the discussion) will be discontinued if the Snap leadership is against it (the merger),” Lim told a press conference in Sibu yesterday, after a DAP post-mortem on the April 16 state election.
According to Lim, DAP's winning of 12 seats in the election not because of the Chinese support alone.
He explained that the party would have had difficulty winning constituencies such as Batu Kawah, Meradong, Kidurong, Kota Sentosa, Repok, Piasau and Dudong without the support of the bumiputera voters.
Jugol said it would be difficult for Snap to merge with the DAP because of historical reasons and the feelings of SNAP members.
“If you want to merge, both Snap and DAP have to be dissolved so we can form a new party,” he said, and asked whether the DAP members would like to see their party dissolved.
Jugol said he did not want to speculate whether Snap or DAP members wanted their parties to be dissolved as both have long histories.
'CEC has not held a meeting to discuss the merger'
Jugol said Snap's central executive committee (CEC) had not held a meeting to discuss the merger since Lim mooted the idea.
He said the CEC members would have to air their views before bringing up the matter to the party members.
Jugol said he did not think that a CEC meeting would have to be called just to discuss the merger proposal.
He said if the merger proposal did not materialise, Snap would be willing to work together with the DAP.
“Working together is easier done than merging,” he said.
Jugol said both Snap and DAP could cooperate in many ways, and that there was nothing to stop them from working together as both were in the opposition.
In the recent state election, the two parties did not clash with each other in the seats they contested.
However, Snap and PKR, both members of Pakatan Rakyat, clashed in 25 seats, which were also contested by the Barisan Nasional and Independents.
PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim had stated that any move for a DAP-Snap merger would have to be discussed by the Pakatan Rakyat council.
“We want to know the reasons for the merger as various allegations have been made against Snap during the campaigning period for the state election,” Anwar had said.
“We have to get their views as merger means dissolution of the party,” Jugol (left) said.
“Do they really want the party to be dissolved?” he said when asked to comment on DAP adviser Lim Kit Siang's statement yesterday.
Lim had said the proposed merger between the DAP and Snap was still at a preliminary stage, that it would be in the interests of the present opposition pact and would be of no threat to any party in the grouping.
“The Sarawak DAP leadership is still exploring the idea of a merger. It (the discussion) will be discontinued if the Snap leadership is against it (the merger),” Lim told a press conference in Sibu yesterday, after a DAP post-mortem on the April 16 state election.
According to Lim, DAP's winning of 12 seats in the election not because of the Chinese support alone.
He explained that the party would have had difficulty winning constituencies such as Batu Kawah, Meradong, Kidurong, Kota Sentosa, Repok, Piasau and Dudong without the support of the bumiputera voters.
Jugol said it would be difficult for Snap to merge with the DAP because of historical reasons and the feelings of SNAP members.
“If you want to merge, both Snap and DAP have to be dissolved so we can form a new party,” he said, and asked whether the DAP members would like to see their party dissolved.
Jugol said he did not want to speculate whether Snap or DAP members wanted their parties to be dissolved as both have long histories.
'CEC has not held a meeting to discuss the merger'Jugol said Snap's central executive committee (CEC) had not held a meeting to discuss the merger since Lim mooted the idea.
He said the CEC members would have to air their views before bringing up the matter to the party members.
Jugol said he did not think that a CEC meeting would have to be called just to discuss the merger proposal.
He said if the merger proposal did not materialise, Snap would be willing to work together with the DAP.
“Working together is easier done than merging,” he said.
Jugol said both Snap and DAP could cooperate in many ways, and that there was nothing to stop them from working together as both were in the opposition.
In the recent state election, the two parties did not clash with each other in the seats they contested.
However, Snap and PKR, both members of Pakatan Rakyat, clashed in 25 seats, which were also contested by the Barisan Nasional and Independents.
PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim had stated that any move for a DAP-Snap merger would have to be discussed by the Pakatan Rakyat council.
“We want to know the reasons for the merger as various allegations have been made against Snap during the campaigning period for the state election,” Anwar had said.
Ang Ngan Toh
Sunday, April 24, 2011
SNAP not keen on DAP merger
We were betrayed by PKR during the state election and stabbed in the back by DAP, says SNAP sec-gen Stanley Jugol.
KOTA KINABALU: The Sarawak National Party (SNAP), a formidable nationalist force which once ruled the state, is at a crossroads in the wake of the just-concluded April 16 state election, according to a post-mortem concluded within days.
However, while the Iban-led party – Parti Asal Bansa Kitai — may be down for now, it’s by no means out.
This is the confident, if not defiant, tone struck by SNAP secretary-general Stanley Jugol in an exclusive take in Kota Kinabalu.
Jugol was in the Sabah capital to trade notes with Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) president Yong Teck Lee and for a much-needed short vacation with his family in a favourite holiday destination for Sarawakians.
“SAPP anticipates that the PKR will do a number on it in Sabah as it did against SNAP in the recent Sarawak elections,” said Jugol. “We could only share our unfortunate experience with PKR so that they would be ready for the onslaught when it comes.”
On the post-mortem, Jugol disclosed that his party confirmed that it was done in by two other Pakatan Rakyat (PR) members, the PKR and DAP, in-fighting within the opposition alliance, money politics by the ruling Barisan Nasional and its own lack of resources.
SNAP, the post-mortem concluded, was also not “the spoiler” in multi-cornered fights since even the combined opposition votes in the 26 seats it contested was less than that collected by the BN.
“The BN didn’t even bother to really campaign much in the rural areas and yet it won,” claimed Jugol.
“The coalition employed thousands of party workers at RM30 a day for ten days, sponsored nightly feasts in the longhouses, and bought up votes in the last two days before the voting on April 16.”
Going forward, Jugol does not think that SNAP will ever merge with the DAP following the latter’s invite from party stalwart Lim Kit Siang. He disclosed that SNAP was taken aback by the invite although it is yet to reject it outright.
The Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS), led by James Masing, has also invited SNAP to close shop and join it and participate in merger talks with the Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP).
(PRS was formed after the Parti Bansa Dayak Sarawak (PBDS), a 1983 breakaway from SNAP, was deregistered. Subsequently, when SNAP was deregistered for a while, the SPDP was formed.)
“The DAP invite may actually be too much too soon,” said Jugol. “We were betrayed by PKR during the state election and stabbed in the back by DAP.”
Both PKR and DAP, he explained, backed each other during the campaigning and urged the voters to reject SNAP in favour of either themselves or the other party.
Funds dried up
DAP, he added, went along with PKR’s lies and this included the fiction that SNAP was suddenly rolling in money because it was purportedly financed by the BN and would be re-joining the ruling coalition soon.
“Both PKR and DAP did not concentrate so much on BN during the campaign but against SNAP,” alleged Jugol.
“We were in fact initially financed by the losers in the recent PKR elections but the funds from them suddenly dried up once the campaigning started and we came under attack.”
Having faced the DAP’s onslaught during the polls period, Jugol did not think that SNAP could suddenly turn around and “persuade the Dayaks to love the Chinese-based Peninsular Malaysian party”.
Besides, a DAP-SNAP merger would merely be a re-creation of the discredited SUPP model, he said.
“SUPP did not benefit the Dayaks at all and in the end even the Chinese abandoned it although the Dayaks continued to stand by it in six seats.”
“The DAP has reached its maximum potential in Sarawak, among the Chinese, and that’s why it’s now eyeing the Dayak seats,” said Jugol. “So, there’s potential for a conflict in Sarawak between DAP and PKR.”
PKR, pointed out Jugol, also wants all Dayak seats for itself since “it can’t win even a single Malay seat in Sarawak despite being a Malay party”.
Leaving aside the proposed DAP-SNAP merger as a non-option, and the possibility of teaming up with PRS and SPDP, Jugol thinks that his party could still mull over several other definite options.
These include the party staying as it is – pledged to unite all Dayak seats under its banner; transform itself into a Borneo-based party or a Borneo-based national party.
“We are not in any great hurry to decide on the way forward,” said Jugol. “We have to also listen to what our members, delegates and leaders have to say on the issue during the August party elections.”
Looking at Baru
He does not rule out the possibility that SNAP would formally invite Sarawak PKR leader Baru Bian to take over the helm of the party since the president, Edwin Dundang, has expressed a wish to step down.
Baru, an Orang Ulu, is the newly-elected state assemblyperson for Ba’Kelalan. He is expected to help attract the minority Dayak communities like the Bidayuh and Melanau besides his own people.
He expects SNAP – “we are still licking our wounds” — would stay out of the fray for the parliamentary seats if the general election was held this year.
The later the general election is held, confirmed Jugol, the greater the possibility that SNAP would focus on a few Dayak seats. These have tentatively been identified as Serian, Kapit, Mambong and Betong.
Asked for the particular interest in these seats, Jugoh said that they were held by non-Dayak based parties like SUPP in Serian and the Malay-based Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) in the three other areas.
“We are in principle against non-Dayak based parties holding Dayaks seats and weakening our collective voice,” said Jugol. “Again, this is one reason why the DAP invite to us does not hold water.”
Besides the 26 seats where it contested, SNAP member George Lagong stood and won Pelagus as an independent.
Lagong, a half-brother of tycoon Sng Chee Hwa, initially had the party’s official consent to stand against Masing in Baleh at the instigation of the latter. But when Lagong changed his mind and decided on Pelagus instead, there wasn’t sufficient time to issue him with a new official consent letter since party officials were also busy in their respective areas.
By Joe Fernandez
KOTA KINABALU: The Sarawak National Party (SNAP), a formidable nationalist force which once ruled the state, is at a crossroads in the wake of the just-concluded April 16 state election, according to a post-mortem concluded within days.
However, while the Iban-led party – Parti Asal Bansa Kitai — may be down for now, it’s by no means out.
This is the confident, if not defiant, tone struck by SNAP secretary-general Stanley Jugol in an exclusive take in Kota Kinabalu.
Jugol was in the Sabah capital to trade notes with Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) president Yong Teck Lee and for a much-needed short vacation with his family in a favourite holiday destination for Sarawakians.
“SAPP anticipates that the PKR will do a number on it in Sabah as it did against SNAP in the recent Sarawak elections,” said Jugol. “We could only share our unfortunate experience with PKR so that they would be ready for the onslaught when it comes.”
On the post-mortem, Jugol disclosed that his party confirmed that it was done in by two other Pakatan Rakyat (PR) members, the PKR and DAP, in-fighting within the opposition alliance, money politics by the ruling Barisan Nasional and its own lack of resources.
SNAP, the post-mortem concluded, was also not “the spoiler” in multi-cornered fights since even the combined opposition votes in the 26 seats it contested was less than that collected by the BN.
“The BN didn’t even bother to really campaign much in the rural areas and yet it won,” claimed Jugol.
“The coalition employed thousands of party workers at RM30 a day for ten days, sponsored nightly feasts in the longhouses, and bought up votes in the last two days before the voting on April 16.”
Going forward, Jugol does not think that SNAP will ever merge with the DAP following the latter’s invite from party stalwart Lim Kit Siang. He disclosed that SNAP was taken aback by the invite although it is yet to reject it outright.
The Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS), led by James Masing, has also invited SNAP to close shop and join it and participate in merger talks with the Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP).
(PRS was formed after the Parti Bansa Dayak Sarawak (PBDS), a 1983 breakaway from SNAP, was deregistered. Subsequently, when SNAP was deregistered for a while, the SPDP was formed.)
“The DAP invite may actually be too much too soon,” said Jugol. “We were betrayed by PKR during the state election and stabbed in the back by DAP.”
Both PKR and DAP, he explained, backed each other during the campaigning and urged the voters to reject SNAP in favour of either themselves or the other party.
Funds dried up
DAP, he added, went along with PKR’s lies and this included the fiction that SNAP was suddenly rolling in money because it was purportedly financed by the BN and would be re-joining the ruling coalition soon.
“Both PKR and DAP did not concentrate so much on BN during the campaign but against SNAP,” alleged Jugol.
“We were in fact initially financed by the losers in the recent PKR elections but the funds from them suddenly dried up once the campaigning started and we came under attack.”
Having faced the DAP’s onslaught during the polls period, Jugol did not think that SNAP could suddenly turn around and “persuade the Dayaks to love the Chinese-based Peninsular Malaysian party”.
Besides, a DAP-SNAP merger would merely be a re-creation of the discredited SUPP model, he said.
“SUPP did not benefit the Dayaks at all and in the end even the Chinese abandoned it although the Dayaks continued to stand by it in six seats.”
“The DAP has reached its maximum potential in Sarawak, among the Chinese, and that’s why it’s now eyeing the Dayak seats,” said Jugol. “So, there’s potential for a conflict in Sarawak between DAP and PKR.”
PKR, pointed out Jugol, also wants all Dayak seats for itself since “it can’t win even a single Malay seat in Sarawak despite being a Malay party”.
Leaving aside the proposed DAP-SNAP merger as a non-option, and the possibility of teaming up with PRS and SPDP, Jugol thinks that his party could still mull over several other definite options.
These include the party staying as it is – pledged to unite all Dayak seats under its banner; transform itself into a Borneo-based party or a Borneo-based national party.
“We are not in any great hurry to decide on the way forward,” said Jugol. “We have to also listen to what our members, delegates and leaders have to say on the issue during the August party elections.”
Looking at Baru
He does not rule out the possibility that SNAP would formally invite Sarawak PKR leader Baru Bian to take over the helm of the party since the president, Edwin Dundang, has expressed a wish to step down.
Baru, an Orang Ulu, is the newly-elected state assemblyperson for Ba’Kelalan. He is expected to help attract the minority Dayak communities like the Bidayuh and Melanau besides his own people.
He expects SNAP – “we are still licking our wounds” — would stay out of the fray for the parliamentary seats if the general election was held this year.
The later the general election is held, confirmed Jugol, the greater the possibility that SNAP would focus on a few Dayak seats. These have tentatively been identified as Serian, Kapit, Mambong and Betong.
Asked for the particular interest in these seats, Jugoh said that they were held by non-Dayak based parties like SUPP in Serian and the Malay-based Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) in the three other areas.
“We are in principle against non-Dayak based parties holding Dayaks seats and weakening our collective voice,” said Jugol. “Again, this is one reason why the DAP invite to us does not hold water.”
Besides the 26 seats where it contested, SNAP member George Lagong stood and won Pelagus as an independent.
Lagong, a half-brother of tycoon Sng Chee Hwa, initially had the party’s official consent to stand against Masing in Baleh at the instigation of the latter. But when Lagong changed his mind and decided on Pelagus instead, there wasn’t sufficient time to issue him with a new official consent letter since party officials were also busy in their respective areas.
By Joe Fernandez
Thursday, April 21, 2011
Snap pours cold water on merger with DAP
Sarawak National Party (Snap) secretary-general Stanley Jugol said today that it is unlikely that his party will merge with DAP.
“It is not going to happen anytime soon. We are not excited by the idea,” Jugol explained.
“We are not going to convene our central executive committee (CEC) meeting to discuss the suggestion from Lim (Kit Siang),” he said, adding that the CEC had just held its meeting on Monday.
He however said the CEC would have discussed the proposal had it been submitted to the party headquarters or had DAP supremo Lim called party president Edwin Dundang on the merger idea.
Jugol said he was surprised by the proposal as DAP was campaigning against Snap candidates in the state election.
Lim had mooted a merger between DAP and Snap to accelerate the Dayak political awakening following the April 16 Sarawak state election.
He said it would also avoid any multi-cornered contests, which could only benefit the ruling BN coalition.
According to Jugol, instead of a merger with DAP, Snap might expand its influence nationwide.
“We are going to amend our constitution at our next triennial delegates conference by the end of this year,” he said. The amendment would allow the party to play a political role beyond Sarawak.
PKR taken aback
Meanwhile, Sarawak PKR is taken aback by the DAP-Snap merger proposal.
"Since we are Pakatan Rakyat partners, we would appreciate a clarification of this proposal from Lim and the DAP," state party chief Baru Bian said in a strongly-worded statement issued to the press today.
He said Snap, despite its previous rhetoric of being a Pakatan Rakyat coalition partner, has explicitly opposed the opposition coalition by fielding candidates in 26 seats which saw multi-cornered fights with the PKR.
"Snap has also consistently been negatively critical of PKR for reasons best known only to them," he said, adding that if anything else, Sarawak PKR is deeply disappointed and saddened by Snap's approach within the Pakatan.
Baru (right) said as proven by its disastrous electoral performance, Snap has no electoral machinery, little political capital and even less social clout on the ground.
He added the total votes garnered by all of Snap's candidates combined were less than those that went to independent candidates.
Baru puzzled by Lim's suggestion
"Snap came in last in almost all multi-cornered fights.
"Put differently, Snap's inexplicable political strategy of undermining Sarawak PKR even as they attempted to dislodge the BN on their own did not succeed," Baru said, adding that Snap's outlook only served to confuse the electorate, weaken the Pakatan, ultimately delivering electoral success to the BN.
He added PKR, therefore, is deeply puzzled by Lim's purpose in suggesting a 'merger' of the DAP with a party like Snap.
He warned that such a merger proposal - although the right of any political party in a free society - would have an influence on the existing relationship of Sarawak's Pakatan coalition members.
"It is thus Sarawak PKR's considered opinion that such proposals should be thoroughly discussed behind closed doors.
"This would ensure that all component parties of the Pakatan fully understand and endorse the objectives of such a possible merger, which ultimately must strengthen the coalition.
Proposal may sow confusion
He said without a thorough discussion, Sarawak PKR's fear is that the proposal only opens the door for multiple interpretations.
"This sows confusion in the hearts and minds of both PKR and DAP members who stood shoulder-to-shoulder against the BN (and also Snap) during the recent state elections.
"Additionally, Sarawak PKR is of the view that any such mergers by coalition partners must enhance diversity and reflect the multi-ethnic realities of politics in Malaysia instead of deepening any existing ethnic cleavage which would only serve the sectarian politics of the BN," he said.
Baru said Sarawak PKR is of the opinion that the best way forward is for Snap to dissolve itself and its members join whatever parties they wish to in their fight against oppression and for justice and development in Sarawak.
"In this way, we believe that Snap cannot ever be made use of as a vehicle to further undermine the stable coherence of Pakatan Rakyat in the years to come," he said.
By Ang Ngan Toh
“It is not going to happen anytime soon. We are not excited by the idea,” Jugol explained.
“We are not going to convene our central executive committee (CEC) meeting to discuss the suggestion from Lim (Kit Siang),” he said, adding that the CEC had just held its meeting on Monday.
He however said the CEC would have discussed the proposal had it been submitted to the party headquarters or had DAP supremo Lim called party president Edwin Dundang on the merger idea.
Jugol said he was surprised by the proposal as DAP was campaigning against Snap candidates in the state election.
Lim had mooted a merger between DAP and Snap to accelerate the Dayak political awakening following the April 16 Sarawak state election.
He said it would also avoid any multi-cornered contests, which could only benefit the ruling BN coalition.
According to Jugol, instead of a merger with DAP, Snap might expand its influence nationwide.
“We are going to amend our constitution at our next triennial delegates conference by the end of this year,” he said. The amendment would allow the party to play a political role beyond Sarawak.
PKR taken aback
Meanwhile, Sarawak PKR is taken aback by the DAP-Snap merger proposal.
"Since we are Pakatan Rakyat partners, we would appreciate a clarification of this proposal from Lim and the DAP," state party chief Baru Bian said in a strongly-worded statement issued to the press today.
He said Snap, despite its previous rhetoric of being a Pakatan Rakyat coalition partner, has explicitly opposed the opposition coalition by fielding candidates in 26 seats which saw multi-cornered fights with the PKR.
"Snap has also consistently been negatively critical of PKR for reasons best known only to them," he said, adding that if anything else, Sarawak PKR is deeply disappointed and saddened by Snap's approach within the Pakatan.
Baru (right) said as proven by its disastrous electoral performance, Snap has no electoral machinery, little political capital and even less social clout on the ground.
He added the total votes garnered by all of Snap's candidates combined were less than those that went to independent candidates.
Baru puzzled by Lim's suggestion
"Snap came in last in almost all multi-cornered fights.
"Put differently, Snap's inexplicable political strategy of undermining Sarawak PKR even as they attempted to dislodge the BN on their own did not succeed," Baru said, adding that Snap's outlook only served to confuse the electorate, weaken the Pakatan, ultimately delivering electoral success to the BN.
He added PKR, therefore, is deeply puzzled by Lim's purpose in suggesting a 'merger' of the DAP with a party like Snap.
He warned that such a merger proposal - although the right of any political party in a free society - would have an influence on the existing relationship of Sarawak's Pakatan coalition members.
"It is thus Sarawak PKR's considered opinion that such proposals should be thoroughly discussed behind closed doors.
"This would ensure that all component parties of the Pakatan fully understand and endorse the objectives of such a possible merger, which ultimately must strengthen the coalition.
Proposal may sow confusion
He said without a thorough discussion, Sarawak PKR's fear is that the proposal only opens the door for multiple interpretations.
"This sows confusion in the hearts and minds of both PKR and DAP members who stood shoulder-to-shoulder against the BN (and also Snap) during the recent state elections.
"Additionally, Sarawak PKR is of the view that any such mergers by coalition partners must enhance diversity and reflect the multi-ethnic realities of politics in Malaysia instead of deepening any existing ethnic cleavage which would only serve the sectarian politics of the BN," he said.
Baru said Sarawak PKR is of the opinion that the best way forward is for Snap to dissolve itself and its members join whatever parties they wish to in their fight against oppression and for justice and development in Sarawak.
"In this way, we believe that Snap cannot ever be made use of as a vehicle to further undermine the stable coherence of Pakatan Rakyat in the years to come," he said.
By Ang Ngan Toh
Kit Siang’s merger idea irks Bian
KUCHING: PKR Sarawak appears upset by DAP leader Lim Kit Siang’s proposal that his party merge with SNAP and wants him to explain.
In a statement critical of SNAP’s political performance and its attitude towards Pakatan Rakyat, Sarawak PKR chairman Baru Bian said such a proposal should have been discussed among the opposition partners before being publicised.
“Since we are Pakatan Rakyat partners, we would appreciate a clarification of this proposal from Lim,” he said.
Bian recalled that SNAP explicitly opposed Pakatan in the recent state election by fielding candidates in 26 seats.
“SNAP has also consistently been negatively critical of PKR for reasons best known only to them,” he said.
“Sarawak PKR is deeply disappointed and saddened by SNAP’s approach within PR since we have always regarded SNAP as our partner.
“As proven by its disastrous electoral performance, SNAP has no electoral machinery, little political capital and even less social clout on the ground.
“The total votes garnered by all of SNAP’s candidates combined were less than those garnered by independent candidates.”
Bian, who is now the state assemblyman for Ba’Kelalan, described SNAP’s political strategy as “inexplicable”, saying it served only to “confuse the electorate, weaken PR and ultimately deliver electoral success to the BN”.
“We are therefore deeply puzzled by Lim’s purpose in suggesting a merger between the DAP and a party like SNAP,” he said.
Dissolve SNAP
He said such proposals should be thoroughly discussed behind closed doors.
“This would ensure that all component parties of PR understand and endorse the objectives of such a possible merger, which ultimately must strengthen the coalition.
“Additionally, Sarawak PKR is of the view that any such mergers by coalition partners must enhance diversity and reflect the multi-ethnic realities of politics in Malaysia instead of deepening any existing ethnic cleavages which would only serve the sectarian politics of the BN.
“Finally, Sarawak PKR is of the opinion that the best way forward is for SNAP to dissolve itself and SNAP members to join whatever parties they wish to in their fight against oppression and for justice and development in Sarawak.
“In this way, we believe that SNAP cannot ever be made use of as a vehicle to further undermine the stable coherence of Pakatan Rakyat in the years to come.”
On Tuesday, Lim, who is DAP’s parliamentary leader, proposed that DAP and SNAP merge in time for the next general election in order to better serve the Iban-Dayak community.
He said that such a merger would accelerate the Iban-Dayak political awakening following the recently concluded Sarawak general election.
SNAP immediately responded by saying that it was surprised by the proposal and needed to discuss it among its leaders.
By Joseph Tawie
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
Fresh from defeat, Snap mulls going national
Ang Ngan Toh
The Sarawak National Party (Snap), which fared badly in the just-concluded state election, is considering amending its constitution to enable it to play a political role at either the regional or national level.
“We are examining various options open to us in terms of coalition building, one that would ensure stability of direction and purpose.
“This may include the possibility of electoral pacts with parties or organisations outside of Sarawak,” he said after the party's central executive committee meeting (CEC) yesterday.
“With such reforms being taken within the party, we are sure that Snap will emerge stronger and more responsive as a political organisation,” he added.
It is not clear whether Dundang was referring to DAP supremo Lim Kit Siang, who yesterday proposed a Dap-Snap merger.
Meanwhile, Dundang said the Snap leadership accepted the verdict handed down by the voters in the polls.
“Owing to various factors, Snap did not perform well as it had expected. In fact, the party is at a low ebb,” he added.
He said an initial result of a post-mortem conducted immediately after the election showed certain structural weakness in the party for the poor response from the voters.
Dundang said the full result of the post-mortem would be known in a few weeks' time.
Snap fought polls 'virtually alone'
Another reason for the pathetic showing, he said, was the party's troubled relationship with Pakatan Rakyat, particularly PKR.
He blamed PKR for targeting Snap more than BN during the 10-day election campaign.
“Given the ferocity of attack on Snap by PKR, it was hardly surprising that Snap had to fight the election virtually alone,” he added.
“This was clearly not a satisfactory situation for Snap since we had considered ourselves part and parcel of Pakatan Rakyat,” he said, adding that the shabby treatment by PKR was uncalled for.
Dundang however said he would not be stepping down as party president to take responsibility for Snap's failure in the election.
“I am not a cabinet minister unlike Dr George Chan, the deputy chief minister, who took the full blame for SUPP's poor showing in the election,” he said.
He said his term as party president expired at the party's triennial delegates conference scheduled for August this year.
Snap claims Pelagus rep as its own
Meanwhile, Dundang claimed that an independent candidate, George Lagong, who won in Pelagus in last Saturday's polls is the party's state assemblyperson.
He said Lagong was supposed to contest in Baleh on a Snap ticket, but made a last-minute switch to Pelagus when incumbent Larry Sng was not re-nominated to contest on a BN's ticket.
“Lagong was unable to get a letter of authority from the party in time due to the last-minute switch so he stood as an Independent.
“This was done with the full knowledge and blessing of the party,” he said, adding that Lagong could not be present at the CEC meeting yesterday as he had prior commitment elsewhere.
Dundang said Lagong had stated that “he is and will remain steadfastly as a Snap member”.
“Being the sole Snap representative in the State Legislative Assembly, he will be given, in due course, an important and significant role in the party's central executive committee,” Dundang said.
He said Lagong had accepted as a member of CEC with immediate effect.
Dundang said Snap, therefore, was not totally wiped out in the election as widely reported by the media.
Twenty-five of 26 Snap candidates lost their election deposits when they failed to secure one-eighth of the total vote cast in the constituencies they contested.
The sole Snap candidate, who did not lose his deposit, was Tedong Gunda, who faced Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP) president William Mawan Ikom, in Pakan.
Lagong, however, is non-committal
Lagong, who is Larry Sng's uncle, defeated Stanley Nyitar @ Unja Malang of Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS) and Edward Sumbang Asun of PKR.
Lagong, when contacted, was non-committal about his ties with Snap.
“It was a mere speculation that I was a Snap candidate. I won as an Independent, and not on a Snap ticket,” he said.
He conceded that he was supposed to contest on a Snap ticket in Baleh, but made a last-minute switch to Pelagus.
Lagong said any political decision he made would be based on what is good for the people of Pelagus.
He nevertheless said he needed a political vehicle to pursue his political career.
“I do not rule out the possibility of joining PRS or any other parties,” he explained, when asked for his reaction to the invitation by PRS president James Masing to join PRS, a component of BN.
The Sarawak National Party (Snap), which fared badly in the just-concluded state election, is considering amending its constitution to enable it to play a political role at either the regional or national level.
“We are examining various options open to us in terms of coalition building, one that would ensure stability of direction and purpose.
“This may include the possibility of electoral pacts with parties or organisations outside of Sarawak,” he said after the party's central executive committee meeting (CEC) yesterday.
“With such reforms being taken within the party, we are sure that Snap will emerge stronger and more responsive as a political organisation,” he added.
It is not clear whether Dundang was referring to DAP supremo Lim Kit Siang, who yesterday proposed a Dap-Snap merger.
Meanwhile, Dundang said the Snap leadership accepted the verdict handed down by the voters in the polls.
“Owing to various factors, Snap did not perform well as it had expected. In fact, the party is at a low ebb,” he added.
He said an initial result of a post-mortem conducted immediately after the election showed certain structural weakness in the party for the poor response from the voters.
Dundang said the full result of the post-mortem would be known in a few weeks' time.
Snap fought polls 'virtually alone'
Another reason for the pathetic showing, he said, was the party's troubled relationship with Pakatan Rakyat, particularly PKR.
He blamed PKR for targeting Snap more than BN during the 10-day election campaign.
“Given the ferocity of attack on Snap by PKR, it was hardly surprising that Snap had to fight the election virtually alone,” he added.
“This was clearly not a satisfactory situation for Snap since we had considered ourselves part and parcel of Pakatan Rakyat,” he said, adding that the shabby treatment by PKR was uncalled for.
Dundang however said he would not be stepping down as party president to take responsibility for Snap's failure in the election.
“I am not a cabinet minister unlike Dr George Chan, the deputy chief minister, who took the full blame for SUPP's poor showing in the election,” he said.
He said his term as party president expired at the party's triennial delegates conference scheduled for August this year.
Snap claims Pelagus rep as its own
Meanwhile, Dundang claimed that an independent candidate, George Lagong, who won in Pelagus in last Saturday's polls is the party's state assemblyperson.
He said Lagong was supposed to contest in Baleh on a Snap ticket, but made a last-minute switch to Pelagus when incumbent Larry Sng was not re-nominated to contest on a BN's ticket.
“Lagong was unable to get a letter of authority from the party in time due to the last-minute switch so he stood as an Independent.
“This was done with the full knowledge and blessing of the party,” he said, adding that Lagong could not be present at the CEC meeting yesterday as he had prior commitment elsewhere.
Dundang said Lagong had stated that “he is and will remain steadfastly as a Snap member”.
“Being the sole Snap representative in the State Legislative Assembly, he will be given, in due course, an important and significant role in the party's central executive committee,” Dundang said.
He said Lagong had accepted as a member of CEC with immediate effect.
Dundang said Snap, therefore, was not totally wiped out in the election as widely reported by the media.
Twenty-five of 26 Snap candidates lost their election deposits when they failed to secure one-eighth of the total vote cast in the constituencies they contested.
The sole Snap candidate, who did not lose his deposit, was Tedong Gunda, who faced Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP) president William Mawan Ikom, in Pakan.
Lagong, however, is non-committal
Lagong, who is Larry Sng's uncle, defeated Stanley Nyitar @ Unja Malang of Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS) and Edward Sumbang Asun of PKR.
Lagong, when contacted, was non-committal about his ties with Snap.
“It was a mere speculation that I was a Snap candidate. I won as an Independent, and not on a Snap ticket,” he said.
He conceded that he was supposed to contest on a Snap ticket in Baleh, but made a last-minute switch to Pelagus.
Lagong said any political decision he made would be based on what is good for the people of Pelagus.
He nevertheless said he needed a political vehicle to pursue his political career.
“I do not rule out the possibility of joining PRS or any other parties,” he explained, when asked for his reaction to the invitation by PRS president James Masing to join PRS, a component of BN.
Thursday, April 14, 2011
SNAP Supports Baru Bian as CM
SNAP today announces that it is willing to join a cabinet headed by Baru Bian as Chief Minister. The notion that Baru Bian is to be the Chief Minister has been agreed upon by Pakatan Rakyat Sarawak. This is because SNAP is a member of Pakatan Rakyat Sarawak.
PKR is spoiling the chances of Pakatan by contesting in too many seats and causing a split in the opposition votes. SNAP only fielded candidates in 26 areas. But PKR fielded 49 candidates which reduce the chances of Pakatan Rakyat Sarawak to win in the majority of the seats they contest.
In the event that PKR wins very few seats, and SNAP captures more seats within the opposition front, SNAP will offer DAP, PAS and PKR to jointly govern Sarawak.
It is hereby assured that SNAP strongly subscribes to the struggle of Pakatan Rakyat Sarawak.
By: EDMUND STANLEY JUGOL
PKR is spoiling the chances of Pakatan by contesting in too many seats and causing a split in the opposition votes. SNAP only fielded candidates in 26 areas. But PKR fielded 49 candidates which reduce the chances of Pakatan Rakyat Sarawak to win in the majority of the seats they contest.
In the event that PKR wins very few seats, and SNAP captures more seats within the opposition front, SNAP will offer DAP, PAS and PKR to jointly govern Sarawak.
It is hereby assured that SNAP strongly subscribes to the struggle of Pakatan Rakyat Sarawak.
By: EDMUND STANLEY JUGOL
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
SNAP is still Pakatan-friendly
Snap's priority is re-acquainting itself to the people, says party advisor Daniel Tajem.
KUCHING: Former diplomat and ex-deputy chief minister Daniel Tajem is quietly confident that Sarawak Nasional Party’s (Snap) primary objective will be achieved in the 10th Sarawak state election this Saturday even if it fails to make an impression on the election front.
Going into the election as underdogs, Snap, Tajem said, would have re-introduced itself to the grassroots voters.
Snap has had to suffer humiliation in the hands of its more manipulative brothers in the Pakatan Rakyat coalition in recent weeks.
Having said this, Snap’s advisor Tajem reiterated the party’s position as being Pakatan-friendly.
“I go back to the basic objective. Snap’s revival started only three months ago. At that time there were no plans or talk of taking part in the election.
“The aim was to reacquaint people to Snap. Then the election was called. It interfered with our plans and ended up with Snap being forced into participating,” he told FMT recently.
Tajem, who is considered an icon among the Dayaks, has distanced himself from the conflicts within Snap and the party’s collision with PKR.
Peninsular-based PKR, many here opined, has bulldozed its way into contesting in 48 seats. This has only ‘buried’ Snap’s aspiration of making a significant impact in the state polls on April 16.
“Snap is made up of many Dayaks. Our aim is to reach the many more out there. We believe Snap should be representing Dayak majority areas. Snap is a local party,” said Tajem.
“But there are two wings in Pakatan. One wing is trying to dominate the politics here and has made Snap a victim,” he added.
Beware of vote-buying
Although he declined to speculate on the election, Tajem did however say that “all the thinking Dayaks are not in Sarawak”.
“The 20 percent rural Dayaks who are educated are not in Sarawak anymore. They can’t get jobs here, so they are now working in peninsular, Singapore, the Middle East and even in as far as Norway and Mexico.
“They are not here. What you have left is the old Dayak who will be happy with the pittance thrown to them (by the BN),” he said on a bitter note.
In the 2006 polls, Tajem was a candidate in Bukit Begunan and was poised to win until hours before the election when BN stepped in with its “fear, bribe and threaten” campaign.
Tajem was up against BN candidate Mong Dagang. Dagang eventually won the seat by 1,007 votes.
“Its the rural voters’ characteristic….in the end, those who are leftovers in the longhouses will vote for them (BN) for the (RM)25 pittance.
“It’s the characteristic … it’s how they are,” he said, declining to to delve further.
Snap is contesting in 27 seats in the election. Intelligence sources say the party “could win two seats”.
In the run-up to the nominations, Snap was in a bitter tussle over overlapping seats with PKR which refused to budge on its decision to contest 48 seats. As a result of the disagreement, PKR and Snap will be battling it out with BN in 24 seats.
Along the way Snap was also alleged to be part of a covert BN operation to split voter support for PKR.
The Umno support
A reliable Umno source said the party was receiving its funds from an individual aligned to Umno.
The same source said that “in the event (Chief Minister) Taib (Mahmud) fails, BN wants to co-opt Snap.”
“There is a feeling that things are not good for BN that’s why they are making a deal with Snap.
“There also some here (in Umno) who feel it is time an Iban heads the state. It will also mean that BN is heeding the call of Sarawakians,” said the source.
By Pushparani Thilaganathan
KUCHING: Former diplomat and ex-deputy chief minister Daniel Tajem is quietly confident that Sarawak Nasional Party’s (Snap) primary objective will be achieved in the 10th Sarawak state election this Saturday even if it fails to make an impression on the election front.
Going into the election as underdogs, Snap, Tajem said, would have re-introduced itself to the grassroots voters.
Snap has had to suffer humiliation in the hands of its more manipulative brothers in the Pakatan Rakyat coalition in recent weeks.
Having said this, Snap’s advisor Tajem reiterated the party’s position as being Pakatan-friendly.
“I go back to the basic objective. Snap’s revival started only three months ago. At that time there were no plans or talk of taking part in the election.
“The aim was to reacquaint people to Snap. Then the election was called. It interfered with our plans and ended up with Snap being forced into participating,” he told FMT recently.
Tajem, who is considered an icon among the Dayaks, has distanced himself from the conflicts within Snap and the party’s collision with PKR.
Peninsular-based PKR, many here opined, has bulldozed its way into contesting in 48 seats. This has only ‘buried’ Snap’s aspiration of making a significant impact in the state polls on April 16.
“Snap is made up of many Dayaks. Our aim is to reach the many more out there. We believe Snap should be representing Dayak majority areas. Snap is a local party,” said Tajem.
“But there are two wings in Pakatan. One wing is trying to dominate the politics here and has made Snap a victim,” he added.
Beware of vote-buying
Although he declined to speculate on the election, Tajem did however say that “all the thinking Dayaks are not in Sarawak”.
“The 20 percent rural Dayaks who are educated are not in Sarawak anymore. They can’t get jobs here, so they are now working in peninsular, Singapore, the Middle East and even in as far as Norway and Mexico.
“They are not here. What you have left is the old Dayak who will be happy with the pittance thrown to them (by the BN),” he said on a bitter note.
In the 2006 polls, Tajem was a candidate in Bukit Begunan and was poised to win until hours before the election when BN stepped in with its “fear, bribe and threaten” campaign.
Tajem was up against BN candidate Mong Dagang. Dagang eventually won the seat by 1,007 votes.
“Its the rural voters’ characteristic….in the end, those who are leftovers in the longhouses will vote for them (BN) for the (RM)25 pittance.
“It’s the characteristic … it’s how they are,” he said, declining to to delve further.
Snap is contesting in 27 seats in the election. Intelligence sources say the party “could win two seats”.
In the run-up to the nominations, Snap was in a bitter tussle over overlapping seats with PKR which refused to budge on its decision to contest 48 seats. As a result of the disagreement, PKR and Snap will be battling it out with BN in 24 seats.
Along the way Snap was also alleged to be part of a covert BN operation to split voter support for PKR.
The Umno support
A reliable Umno source said the party was receiving its funds from an individual aligned to Umno.
The same source said that “in the event (Chief Minister) Taib (Mahmud) fails, BN wants to co-opt Snap.”
“There is a feeling that things are not good for BN that’s why they are making a deal with Snap.
“There also some here (in Umno) who feel it is time an Iban heads the state. It will also mean that BN is heeding the call of Sarawakians,” said the source.
By Pushparani Thilaganathan
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Investigate PKR’s real motives and greed
By Pakatan Borneo Warrior
Reply to SNAP’s Deal with BN- The Damning evidence
Sarawak Report is against the BN or is pro the BN? Why is Sarawak Report so happy to swallow the entire fabrication by a “BN supporter in KL”? Does Sarawak Report believe that if there is a plot between BN and SNAP, that the KL people will send the “explosive evidence” and “highly confidential” plan to Sarawak Report?
To me, the report is invented by greedy, self-centred PKR to kill SNAP even at the expense of an opposition victory.
Let’s look at the FACTS:
PKR is the one splitting the opposition votes with 3-cornered fights. After cornering DAP to only 15-seats and PAS 5-seats, PKR grabbed the balance 50 seats. But the PKR candidate for Pakan disappeared on nomination day. PKR now has 49 candidates. Talk is that the PKR candidate was bought. If SNAP had not fielded a candidate, then the BN would have got a walk over!! These are facts that PKR must answer.
SNAP finally contested in 26 Dayak seats. They had earlier threatened to contest in 40 seats, if PKR cannot come to an agreement with SNAP. As it happened, it was PKR that went all out to destroy opposition chances by fielding candidates in all the SNAP areas.
PKR had also fielded a candidate against the SNAP President, Edwin Dundang, at Marudi. The excuse was that PKR was afraid that the SNAP President might not turn up at the nomination and give the BN a walk over. Such a ludicrous statement was made by PKR.
Edwin has been fighting BN and Taib Mahmud even before PKR set foot in Sarawak. It therefore becomes suspicious why PKR wants to spoil the chances of fellow opposition SNAP which had joined PR last year. Are some PKR leaders agents of BN? Where did Azmin Ali get all his money to fund his nationwide party election last year?
If SNAP were an agent for BN, then they would have fielded candidates in PBB and mixed areas to split the votes to help PBB and SUPP.
SNAP contesting only in Dayak majority areas is totally consistent with their struggle to restore Dayak unity.
Whether one agrees or not with them, that is their struggle at this stage of the party. It is one of the oldest party in Sarawak, formed in 1961, even before Malaysia was formed.
SNAP members in DAP and PAS areas are openly supporting DAP and PAS. SNAP also avoided contests in Dayak seats like Bakelalan and Batang Ai where where PKR’s Baru Bian and Nicholas Bawin are accepted to be the strongest and have the best chance of beating BN. This is proof of SNAP sincerity.
Upon the collapse of negotiation between SNAP and PKR on the eve of nomination, PKR leaders like Tian Chua speculated that SNAP gets money from KL sources. This shows that PKR leaders are afraid of their own shadows. SNAP gets support from well wishers and common enemies of BN. Two days ago PKR Sarawak leader Baru Bian confirmed that SNAP has run out of money.
One might ask, where is PKR getting the money to fund its massive campaigns? Who is paying for the hordes of PKR campaigners from Peninsular Malaysia to fly to Sarawak, stay in hotels and spend their way through? Top financier of PKR is Sng Chee Wah, the top crony of Anwar in the UMNO days. Everybody in Sarawak and Sabah knows that kind of character Sng is.
In a way, we cannot blame PKR for being suspicious of other people. After all, PKR has the most number of defectors. MPs, assemblymen, ketua cabang and leaders at all levels have left PKR. Can they all be wrong? Some of those who remain in PKR are scandal ridden leaders, some charged for corruption, some fighting for projects and sand mining permits and one caught in nude. There is a whole load of heavy baggage in PKR.
The fact that PKR’s own leaders cannot be trusted is their own problem. They should not accuse others of untrustworthiness. They, after all, have no monopoly over the opposition. There are many, many people opposed to the BN and UMNO but are not aligned to PKR. SNAP is helping DAP and PAS. SNAP cannot help PKR for the simple reason that PKR wants to kill off SNAP. PKR by fielding candidates against all SNAP leaders is splitting the opposition to help the BN. SNAP by avoiding staying out of non-Dayak areas has helped the opposition.
Finally, how about the mystery of PKR fielding an unknown candidate against MoCS (Movement for Change Sarawak) candidate at Balingian, the seat held by white hair Taib Mahmud? Once again, PKR has caused a split in the opposition vote of MoCS candidate Salleh Jafaruddin, who is a senior leader with enough stature to take on Taib.
After the Sarawak elections, we must investigate the real motives and greed of PKR.
Reply to SNAP’s Deal with BN- The Damning evidence
Sarawak Report is against the BN or is pro the BN? Why is Sarawak Report so happy to swallow the entire fabrication by a “BN supporter in KL”? Does Sarawak Report believe that if there is a plot between BN and SNAP, that the KL people will send the “explosive evidence” and “highly confidential” plan to Sarawak Report?
To me, the report is invented by greedy, self-centred PKR to kill SNAP even at the expense of an opposition victory.
Let’s look at the FACTS:
PKR is the one splitting the opposition votes with 3-cornered fights. After cornering DAP to only 15-seats and PAS 5-seats, PKR grabbed the balance 50 seats. But the PKR candidate for Pakan disappeared on nomination day. PKR now has 49 candidates. Talk is that the PKR candidate was bought. If SNAP had not fielded a candidate, then the BN would have got a walk over!! These are facts that PKR must answer.
![]() |
| Edwin Dundang |
PKR had also fielded a candidate against the SNAP President, Edwin Dundang, at Marudi. The excuse was that PKR was afraid that the SNAP President might not turn up at the nomination and give the BN a walk over. Such a ludicrous statement was made by PKR.
Edwin has been fighting BN and Taib Mahmud even before PKR set foot in Sarawak. It therefore becomes suspicious why PKR wants to spoil the chances of fellow opposition SNAP which had joined PR last year. Are some PKR leaders agents of BN? Where did Azmin Ali get all his money to fund his nationwide party election last year?
![]() |
| Azmin Ali |
SNAP contesting only in Dayak majority areas is totally consistent with their struggle to restore Dayak unity.
Whether one agrees or not with them, that is their struggle at this stage of the party. It is one of the oldest party in Sarawak, formed in 1961, even before Malaysia was formed.
SNAP members in DAP and PAS areas are openly supporting DAP and PAS. SNAP also avoided contests in Dayak seats like Bakelalan and Batang Ai where where PKR’s Baru Bian and Nicholas Bawin are accepted to be the strongest and have the best chance of beating BN. This is proof of SNAP sincerity.
Upon the collapse of negotiation between SNAP and PKR on the eve of nomination, PKR leaders like Tian Chua speculated that SNAP gets money from KL sources. This shows that PKR leaders are afraid of their own shadows. SNAP gets support from well wishers and common enemies of BN. Two days ago PKR Sarawak leader Baru Bian confirmed that SNAP has run out of money.
One might ask, where is PKR getting the money to fund its massive campaigns? Who is paying for the hordes of PKR campaigners from Peninsular Malaysia to fly to Sarawak, stay in hotels and spend their way through? Top financier of PKR is Sng Chee Wah, the top crony of Anwar in the UMNO days. Everybody in Sarawak and Sabah knows that kind of character Sng is.
In a way, we cannot blame PKR for being suspicious of other people. After all, PKR has the most number of defectors. MPs, assemblymen, ketua cabang and leaders at all levels have left PKR. Can they all be wrong? Some of those who remain in PKR are scandal ridden leaders, some charged for corruption, some fighting for projects and sand mining permits and one caught in nude. There is a whole load of heavy baggage in PKR.
The fact that PKR’s own leaders cannot be trusted is their own problem. They should not accuse others of untrustworthiness. They, after all, have no monopoly over the opposition. There are many, many people opposed to the BN and UMNO but are not aligned to PKR. SNAP is helping DAP and PAS. SNAP cannot help PKR for the simple reason that PKR wants to kill off SNAP. PKR by fielding candidates against all SNAP leaders is splitting the opposition to help the BN. SNAP by avoiding staying out of non-Dayak areas has helped the opposition.
Finally, how about the mystery of PKR fielding an unknown candidate against MoCS (Movement for Change Sarawak) candidate at Balingian, the seat held by white hair Taib Mahmud? Once again, PKR has caused a split in the opposition vote of MoCS candidate Salleh Jafaruddin, who is a senior leader with enough stature to take on Taib.
After the Sarawak elections, we must investigate the real motives and greed of PKR.
Monday, April 11, 2011
Snap snaps back at PKR
Joseph Tawie

KUCHING: Snap has called for an end to bickering among opposition parties and urged them to work instead towards ousting the Barisan Nasional government of Sarawak.
The call came in a press statement that was, in the main, a sneering response to recent statements by PKR leaders worried about the splitting of votes for the opposition.
“Snap does not wish to prolong the bickering among opposition parties but wish to focus against the main adversary, Barisan Nasional,” said the statement, released today and signed by Snap secretary-general Stanley Jugol.
“However, Snap feels compelled to reply to the various unfair allegations made by Baru Bian, head of PKR Sarawak, and Anwar Ibrahim, the Ketua Umum of PKR.”
Jugol said Bian was being “impertinent” in his call for the withdrawal of Snap candidates from the April 16 state election and described Anwar’s anxiety over the possibility of split opposition votes as a “compliment” to a party “to which he offered only three seats to contest”.
Local sensitivities
Bian, noting the paucity of Snap banners, posters and other campaign materials, recently urged the party’s candidates to withdraw from the election and support PKR.
“Just because Snap does not conduct its election campaign in the manner that other parties do, it does not mean that Snap is not gaining support among the voters where it is contesting,” Jugol said.
“Snap also does not believe in ostentatious spending on election peripherals such as flags, buntings and billboards in the areas we contest, which are mostly economically deprived.
“Snap also refrains from bringing in outsiders, some from the peninsula, who do not understand local sensitivities by uttering brash words in ceramahs and vote canvassing to the chagrin of the peaceful dwellers of rural Sarawak.
“Since the areas we are contesting are spread out in the hinterland with poor communications, we have dispensed with centralised ceramahs and have focused on personal visits by our candidates to the thousands of longhouses, which are miles apart.
“That was why we saw it fit to begin our election campaign with an early announcement of our candidates.
Devoid of helicopters and mainstream television, we have managed to touch the hearts of the thousands marginalised by mainstream politicians.”
He predicted that the voting would show that Sarawak’s rural natives had “their own perception of how politics should be practiced”.
He also said it was “surprising” that Anwar was now worried that Snap would split the opposition votes.
“It is indeed a compliment to Snap, a party to which he offered only three seats to contest, that apparently its support is widespread and far-reaching enough to be a party that definitely should contest in a lot more than three seats,” he said.
Referring to allegations that Snap was being sponsored by BN, he said: “Baru himself has admitted that Snap’s campaign is frugal and therefore unbecoming of a richly sponsored party.
“In the constituency of Pakan, Snap is having a straight fight with BN and giving BN a good fight instead of giving in, as anyone would expect from an alleged vassal party.”
He ended the statement with a call on all opposition parties to “concentrate on pushing for regime change.”
Stanley Jugol says the opposition should stop bickering and concentrate on kicking BN out.
KUCHING: Snap has called for an end to bickering among opposition parties and urged them to work instead towards ousting the Barisan Nasional government of Sarawak.
The call came in a press statement that was, in the main, a sneering response to recent statements by PKR leaders worried about the splitting of votes for the opposition.
“Snap does not wish to prolong the bickering among opposition parties but wish to focus against the main adversary, Barisan Nasional,” said the statement, released today and signed by Snap secretary-general Stanley Jugol.
“However, Snap feels compelled to reply to the various unfair allegations made by Baru Bian, head of PKR Sarawak, and Anwar Ibrahim, the Ketua Umum of PKR.”
Jugol said Bian was being “impertinent” in his call for the withdrawal of Snap candidates from the April 16 state election and described Anwar’s anxiety over the possibility of split opposition votes as a “compliment” to a party “to which he offered only three seats to contest”.
Local sensitivities
Bian, noting the paucity of Snap banners, posters and other campaign materials, recently urged the party’s candidates to withdraw from the election and support PKR.
“Just because Snap does not conduct its election campaign in the manner that other parties do, it does not mean that Snap is not gaining support among the voters where it is contesting,” Jugol said.
“Snap also does not believe in ostentatious spending on election peripherals such as flags, buntings and billboards in the areas we contest, which are mostly economically deprived.
“Snap also refrains from bringing in outsiders, some from the peninsula, who do not understand local sensitivities by uttering brash words in ceramahs and vote canvassing to the chagrin of the peaceful dwellers of rural Sarawak.
“Since the areas we are contesting are spread out in the hinterland with poor communications, we have dispensed with centralised ceramahs and have focused on personal visits by our candidates to the thousands of longhouses, which are miles apart.
“That was why we saw it fit to begin our election campaign with an early announcement of our candidates.
Devoid of helicopters and mainstream television, we have managed to touch the hearts of the thousands marginalised by mainstream politicians.”
He predicted that the voting would show that Sarawak’s rural natives had “their own perception of how politics should be practiced”.
He also said it was “surprising” that Anwar was now worried that Snap would split the opposition votes.
“It is indeed a compliment to Snap, a party to which he offered only three seats to contest, that apparently its support is widespread and far-reaching enough to be a party that definitely should contest in a lot more than three seats,” he said.
Referring to allegations that Snap was being sponsored by BN, he said: “Baru himself has admitted that Snap’s campaign is frugal and therefore unbecoming of a richly sponsored party.
“In the constituency of Pakan, Snap is having a straight fight with BN and giving BN a good fight instead of giving in, as anyone would expect from an alleged vassal party.”
He ended the statement with a call on all opposition parties to “concentrate on pushing for regime change.”
Sunday, April 10, 2011
Snap is a concern, admits Anwar
Syed Jaymal Zahiid

KUCHING: Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim conceded that the three-cornered fights between them and Sarawak National Party (Snap) will affect their chances.
Anwar’s PKR is pitted in a tripled-cornered contest against Snap in 26 Dayak-majority seats and said although the latter’s presence is minimal in these constituencies, they can still split the votes and dent PKR’s ambitions.
The scenario is only likely to benefit Barisan Nasional, said the former deputy prime minister.
“The vibrancy of PKR’s campaign is visible and better but although their (Snap) presence is not there, our concern is that Snap will split the votes,” he told a press conference here.
Snap was once meant to be an electoral ally to PKR but a split was imminent when seat-allocation talks collapsed as both refused to climb down from asking more seats and attempt to wield more influence among the Dayak voters.
Anwar, who arrived here today to kickstart his campaign trail in the state capital officially, said his visits to other parts of Sarawak, including the interiors, have shown that the Dayak votes were leaning either towards Pakatan Rakyat or BN, and not Snap.
Harassment and intimidation
Pakatan leaders have accused Snap of sabotage attempt and of having the backing of the ruling coalition and Anwar reiterated this today and urged caution.

Apart from Snap’s presence (photo), the opposition bloc claimed their campaigning trail have also been bogged by harassment and intimidation by their political foes.
Pakatan is aiming to break BN’s dominance in Sarawak by increasing their current seven seats to at least 15.
The target is enough to send a strong protest signal against the nation’s longest-serving Chief Minister Taib Mahmud and perhaps to force him to resign.
Ethnicity again as campaign fodder
Campaigning has hit the fifth day and battles heightened with propaganda, from the personal and racial to the ideological, reigning.
Among them are reports of battles played along religious and racial lines where news of PKR Sarawak chief Baru Bian’s candidacy as the state chief minister was used to scare local Malays.
Accusations were rife that Malays and Islam will be threatened should a Christian Orang Ulu like Baru be in charge.
Anwar said this was a scare tactic typically used by BN and cited Penang as an example where the leadership of DAP Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng has been accused as being anti-Malay and anti-Islam.
“The Malays and Melanaus under the Melanau leadership are plagued by poverty,” said Anwar, referring to Taib who is a Muslim-Melanau which forms Sarawak’s second largest electorate.
Three-cornered fights as a result of Snap contesting will only split votes to favour the BN.
KUCHING: Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim conceded that the three-cornered fights between them and Sarawak National Party (Snap) will affect their chances.
Anwar’s PKR is pitted in a tripled-cornered contest against Snap in 26 Dayak-majority seats and said although the latter’s presence is minimal in these constituencies, they can still split the votes and dent PKR’s ambitions.
The scenario is only likely to benefit Barisan Nasional, said the former deputy prime minister.
“The vibrancy of PKR’s campaign is visible and better but although their (Snap) presence is not there, our concern is that Snap will split the votes,” he told a press conference here.
Snap was once meant to be an electoral ally to PKR but a split was imminent when seat-allocation talks collapsed as both refused to climb down from asking more seats and attempt to wield more influence among the Dayak voters.
Anwar, who arrived here today to kickstart his campaign trail in the state capital officially, said his visits to other parts of Sarawak, including the interiors, have shown that the Dayak votes were leaning either towards Pakatan Rakyat or BN, and not Snap.
Harassment and intimidation
Pakatan leaders have accused Snap of sabotage attempt and of having the backing of the ruling coalition and Anwar reiterated this today and urged caution.
Apart from Snap’s presence (photo), the opposition bloc claimed their campaigning trail have also been bogged by harassment and intimidation by their political foes.
Pakatan is aiming to break BN’s dominance in Sarawak by increasing their current seven seats to at least 15.
The target is enough to send a strong protest signal against the nation’s longest-serving Chief Minister Taib Mahmud and perhaps to force him to resign.
Ethnicity again as campaign fodder
Campaigning has hit the fifth day and battles heightened with propaganda, from the personal and racial to the ideological, reigning.
Among them are reports of battles played along religious and racial lines where news of PKR Sarawak chief Baru Bian’s candidacy as the state chief minister was used to scare local Malays.
Accusations were rife that Malays and Islam will be threatened should a Christian Orang Ulu like Baru be in charge.
Anwar said this was a scare tactic typically used by BN and cited Penang as an example where the leadership of DAP Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng has been accused as being anti-Malay and anti-Islam.
“The Malays and Melanaus under the Melanau leadership are plagued by poverty,” said Anwar, referring to Taib who is a Muslim-Melanau which forms Sarawak’s second largest electorate.
Saturday, April 9, 2011
Lessons from PKR-Snap pact failure
Terence Netto
There wasn't a lot of hand-wringing and mutual recrimination following the final breakdown last weekend in seat-sharing talks between PKR and Snap.
'Easy come, easy go' would have been the epitaph on the expiry of collaboration between both parties; to be sure, both had enjoyed only a tenuous relationship at best.
Observers of a phone conversation PKR leader Anwar Ibrahim had with Snap secretary-general Stanley Jugol in April last year while he, DAP's Lim Kit Siang and PAS' Nasharuddin Mat Isa were in Sibu to cobble a coalition among opposition parties in preparation for a parliamentary by-election the following month, would have been naive to have expected that the ease with which Jugol, importuned by Anwar, had agreed to join the pact augured well for future ties.
Latterly, Snap's revival as a party to be reckoned with in Sarawak politics looked too good to be true despite its not unreasonable claims that as the oldest multiracial party in the state, it held an advantage over PKR in the contest for the allegiance of Sarawak's ethnically diverse electorate.
Still, from being cash strapped until late last year to being able to field candidates in 26 seats for the state polls on April 16 is a recrudescence that is startling at best and suspect at worst.
There is little doubt that among the financiers who have come to Snap's aid are people with less than benevolent intent towards the Pakatan coalition.
But Snap could counter this speculation by questioning PKR's cavorting with financier Sng Chee Hua, than whom there are few more notorious swashbucklers in Borneo politics.
There wasn't a lot of hand-wringing and mutual recrimination following the final breakdown last weekend in seat-sharing talks between PKR and Snap.
'Easy come, easy go' would have been the epitaph on the expiry of collaboration between both parties; to be sure, both had enjoyed only a tenuous relationship at best.
Observers of a phone conversation PKR leader Anwar Ibrahim had with Snap secretary-general Stanley Jugol in April last year while he, DAP's Lim Kit Siang and PAS' Nasharuddin Mat Isa were in Sibu to cobble a coalition among opposition parties in preparation for a parliamentary by-election the following month, would have been naive to have expected that the ease with which Jugol, importuned by Anwar, had agreed to join the pact augured well for future ties.
Latterly, Snap's revival as a party to be reckoned with in Sarawak politics looked too good to be true despite its not unreasonable claims that as the oldest multiracial party in the state, it held an advantage over PKR in the contest for the allegiance of Sarawak's ethnically diverse electorate.
Still, from being cash strapped until late last year to being able to field candidates in 26 seats for the state polls on April 16 is a recrudescence that is startling at best and suspect at worst.
There is little doubt that among the financiers who have come to Snap's aid are people with less than benevolent intent towards the Pakatan coalition.
But Snap could counter this speculation by questioning PKR's cavorting with financier Sng Chee Hua, than whom there are few more notorious swashbucklers in Borneo politics.
Needless to say, the pot cannot be calling the kettle black.
A bedraggled, unreliable lot
Still, PKR feared that if they had come to a seat-sharing agreement with Snap, it could not be sure that some candidates from the Snap list would just not turn up on Nomination Day, thus conceding seats to BN before campaigning began in earnest.
This was a possibility seasoned observers of Borneo politics could not dismiss.
The spectacle of seats going uncontested to BN on nomination day is one that the ruling coalition would have used to maximum effect to drive home the point to the folk in the longhouses that the opposition are a bedraggled, unreliable lot.
In the event, on nomination day last Wednesday, only two Snap candidates did not turn up to file their papers and a third was disqualified.
Of the two Snap candidates who did not show up in seats allocated to them, one was George Lagong, who was supposed to file his candidature in Baleh where the incumbent is BN's James Masing (centre), president of Parti Rakyat Sarawak.
It is now quite clear that Lagong, who is a step-brother of Sng Chee Hua, was merely a proxy for Sng in the fight against Masing in Baleh, masquerading under the Snap banner.
The Masing-led PRS had last February sought and obtained BN chairperson Najib Razak's assurance that Sng's son, Larry, the two-term PRS assemblyperson for Pelagus, sacked some time ago before for leading an abortive revolt against Masing, would not be fielded as the BN candidate in the Iban-majority seat.
Chief Minister and Sarawak BN chairperson Taib Mahmud is fond of Larry and had entertained the hope that he could foist his candidature over Masing's objections.
When it became clear that Larry would not be fielded by BN in Pelagus, Lagong detoured from Baleh to Pelagus to stand as an Independent.
Byzantine facets of Sarawakian politics
Likewise, Independent candidate for Layar, Tedwin Ngumbang Datu, is a proxy for Masing in the fight to see PBB's Alfred Jabu defeated in his bastion.
The defeat of Jabu in Layar would aid Masing's chances of emerging as the top Dayak in the post-Taib political scenario in Sarawak.
Tedwin, who was a PRS stalwart until early last year, had been trying for months to be the sole opposition candidate against Jabu but stories of his having been a principal player in the shenanigans that saw Parti Bansa Dayak Sarawak deregistered in 2004, rendered him suspect in both PKR's and Snap's eyes.
From these byzantine facets of Sarawakian politics, it can be deduced that both the BN and opposition coalitions are porous enough to allow for the subsuming of personal agendas within their overall strategy.
Suffice it does not suit PKR and Snap to adopt an astringent attitude about motive and funding when and if negotiations over seat-sharing resume in advance of parliamentary elections that are predicted for as early as June or as late as November or even next February.
Better to prioritise the putting up of a united front against the BN which would require the shedding of carping inquiries into each party's worthiness, for where these matters are concerned there are very few politicians who are untainted by shenanigans in Sarawak's politics.
A bedraggled, unreliable lot
Still, PKR feared that if they had come to a seat-sharing agreement with Snap, it could not be sure that some candidates from the Snap list would just not turn up on Nomination Day, thus conceding seats to BN before campaigning began in earnest.
This was a possibility seasoned observers of Borneo politics could not dismiss.
The spectacle of seats going uncontested to BN on nomination day is one that the ruling coalition would have used to maximum effect to drive home the point to the folk in the longhouses that the opposition are a bedraggled, unreliable lot.
In the event, on nomination day last Wednesday, only two Snap candidates did not turn up to file their papers and a third was disqualified.
It is now quite clear that Lagong, who is a step-brother of Sng Chee Hua, was merely a proxy for Sng in the fight against Masing in Baleh, masquerading under the Snap banner.
The Masing-led PRS had last February sought and obtained BN chairperson Najib Razak's assurance that Sng's son, Larry, the two-term PRS assemblyperson for Pelagus, sacked some time ago before for leading an abortive revolt against Masing, would not be fielded as the BN candidate in the Iban-majority seat.
Chief Minister and Sarawak BN chairperson Taib Mahmud is fond of Larry and had entertained the hope that he could foist his candidature over Masing's objections.
When it became clear that Larry would not be fielded by BN in Pelagus, Lagong detoured from Baleh to Pelagus to stand as an Independent.
Byzantine facets of Sarawakian politics
Likewise, Independent candidate for Layar, Tedwin Ngumbang Datu, is a proxy for Masing in the fight to see PBB's Alfred Jabu defeated in his bastion.
The defeat of Jabu in Layar would aid Masing's chances of emerging as the top Dayak in the post-Taib political scenario in Sarawak.
Tedwin, who was a PRS stalwart until early last year, had been trying for months to be the sole opposition candidate against Jabu but stories of his having been a principal player in the shenanigans that saw Parti Bansa Dayak Sarawak deregistered in 2004, rendered him suspect in both PKR's and Snap's eyes.
From these byzantine facets of Sarawakian politics, it can be deduced that both the BN and opposition coalitions are porous enough to allow for the subsuming of personal agendas within their overall strategy.
Suffice it does not suit PKR and Snap to adopt an astringent attitude about motive and funding when and if negotiations over seat-sharing resume in advance of parliamentary elections that are predicted for as early as June or as late as November or even next February.
Better to prioritise the putting up of a united front against the BN which would require the shedding of carping inquiries into each party's worthiness, for where these matters are concerned there are very few politicians who are untainted by shenanigans in Sarawak's politics.
TERENCE NETTO has been a journalist for close on four decades. He likes the occupation because it puts him in contact with the eminent without being under the necessity to admire them. It is the ideal occupation for a temperament that finds power fascinating and its exercise abhorrent.
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
Rude Wake-Up Call For PKR

Joe Fernadez
THE propaganda barrage is intense. The story is that the Sarawak National Party (Snap) is a fifth column within the opposition alliance and or otherwise funded by the ruling Barisan Nasional to split votes and give the latter victory by default.
The fact that such self-serving talk emanates openly from PKR does not seem to augur too well for the fledging opposition alliance in Sarawak. PKR is clearly the spoiler in the pack.
It’s true that the BN in Sarawak has been known to fund at least one mosquito party which appears from nowhere, on the eve of state elections, to make a bid for every seat.
The most infamous example was Parti Negara Rakyat Sarawak (Negara) in the early 1990s which was funded by Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB)-linked moneybags. The party lost every seat but in the process managed to draw away enough votes from the opposition especially in the marginal and mixed seats.
If Snap is indeed being funded by BN as PKR strenuously claims, notwithstanding various devious attempts in the past by Sarawak Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud to finish it off once and for all, this is something that’s best seen to be believed.
PKR seems patently oblivious to the inconvenient fact that Daniel Tajem, Taib’s arch political enemy and nemesis, is Snap adviser. Hence, BN funding for Snap is an unlikely scenario given the history of mutual animosity between the two men.
Taib has been known to openly ridicule Tajem even in the Iban longhouses. Here, the Melanau Dayak Taib puts on his Dayak mask while downplaying his faith in the process.
There is also the fact that Snap is not going for every seat unlike Negara. A BN-funded Snap would surely go for all 71 state seats. Also, the talk is that former PKR vice-president Jeffrey Kitingan may be Snap’s director of operations for the elections. Again, this rules out the ‘BN-funded Snap’ theory.
It’s not known how the opposition alliance will come together, if at all, before the April 6 nomination date. For one, there’s still no let-up in the PKR campaign against Snap as the former desperately attempts to discredit the latter in the eyes of the voters to claim the lion’s share of the seats. However, even their unlikely coming together will not assure the opposition alliance victory at the polls.
‘Melayu Party From Malaya’
If at all the Ibans turn away from BN, and quite a number of them will do so in any case this time, they are more than likely to swear by the home-grown Snap rather than PKR. The latter is seen disparagingly by the parochial longhouse dwellers as a ‘Melayu party from Malaya.’
The Ibans know which side their political bread is buttered vis-a-vis Peninsular Malaysia. They may have more than a beef with the Taib regime but they will be damned if they are going to allow any orang luar (outsiders) to capitalise on the situation in the process.
The lessons of Sabah from 1994, and the current predicament of the Dusun, are only too well etched in their minds. Nine out of the 12 state cabinet positions in Sabah, including that of chief minister, are today held by Peninsular Malaysian parties. That’s more than enough to scare off the locals from a Kuala Lumpur-controlled Sarawak PKR for good.
No doubt, in the post April 16-period, PKR will have to seriously re-think its presence in Sabah and Sarawak or kiss Putrajaya goodbye forever.
PKR must incorporate itself locally in Sabah and Sarawak, and remain independent of Kuala Lumpur, if it is to be accepted by the tribal-minded Iban and Dusun in particular.
The latter continue to flee PKR in the wake of Jeffrey first declining to go for any posts during the recent party polls–except that of Pensiangan Division Chief –and later announcing his bombshell departure around New Year’s Day.
Attempts are still being made by the party to woo Jeffrey back after it initially made various attempts to demonise him but to no avail. PKR Kota Kinabalu division chief Christina Liew remains starry-eyed and is hoping against hope that her ‘hero’ Jeffrey will return before too long to the fold. She dreams on in the manner that de facto party chief Anwar Ibrahim dreams on in Sabah and Sarawak.
Too ambitious for its own good
PKR, under Anwar, has so far been clearly too ambitious for its own good in Sabah and Sarawak. Much of this ambition is based on the outdated model of proxy politics put in place by the ruling elite since Malaysia.
Wither the agenda for change and reform!
PKR sees itself as the legitimate alternative to the PBB in Sarawak and Umno in Sabah. Both the ruling
parties in Malaysian Borneo are cast in the ketuanan Melayu (Malay dominance and supremacy) mould favoured by the ruling elite in Putrajaya.
PKR comes 30 years too late to join the gravy train in Malaysian Borneo. PBB and Sabah Umno are discredited political models waiting to tumble down like a house of cards. Already, Sabah BN has come under severe strain as its oft-cited power-sharing model and consensus-and-compromise approach to decision-making–the BN spirit–comes apart at the hands of local warlords.
The inevitable destruction of the Pesaka component of PBB will finally free Dayak politics from Putrajaya. This will bring an end to proxy politics in Sarawak once and for all. Sarawak, as yet, may for once finally show the way for Sabah.
PKR, under the circumstances, should be willing to eat humble pie and play second fiddle in Sarawak to the local parties like Snap and the others. But this happy state of affairs is unlikely to materialise as long as the party and Anwar dream on oblivious to the emerging harsh realities on the ground.
Almost no one, at this juncture, wants to hazard a guess at the eventual fate of the opposition alliance come April 16 in Sarawak.
One brave analyst in Kuching, a veteran of many polls, thinks that Snap can do no better than nine seats, PKR three seats, DAP 13 seats and PAS one seat. That gives a grand total of 26 seats to deny the BN its coveted two-third majority in the state assembly.
Snap’s seats are likely to come from Pesaka and PBB except perhaps for one each from Parti Rakyat Sarawak (PRS) and Sarawak Progressive Democratic Party (SPDP).
DAP’s 13 seats will be taken away from the Sarawak United People’s Party (Supp) and drawn from the Chinese, marginal/mixed seats. Already, DAP secretary-general Lim Guan Eng has announced that the party will go for 15 seats in Sarawak including five in the south and the rest in the central and northern regions.
PKR is expected to get a seat each from marginal/mixed Malay, Bidayuh and Orang Ulu communities. The party, it is reported, wants to go for between 37 and 39 seats at the very minimum, conceding five to PAS, 15 to 17 to Snap and 15 to DAP.
PKR has reportedly three competing lists i.e. one drawn up by state chief Baru Bian, another by Anwar and the third with 10 names selected by businessman Sng Chee Hua and to be funded by him. Sng is not wiling to fund the other PKR candidates. This has made the Sarawak chapter wonder why they should accept his proposal without getting anything in return.
PAS’ sole win in the forthcoming state election can only be in the marginal/mixed area with a significant number of Malay voters. There are 12 marginal and five mixed seats in Sarawak.
Neighbours keep close watch on Sarawak polls
Luke Rintod

KOTA KINABALU: As the Sarawak state election gets underway, Sabahans, unlike before, are following closely what is going on across the border.
Many Sabahans see the Sarawak state polls this time as a barometer of sorts which will have an impact on Sabah. The fate of Sarawak Chief Minister Taib Mahmud is also a focal point of interest.
Local opposition party Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) supreme council member Peter Marajin said the Sarawak election is interesting as it will have a bearing on Sabah’s own state election.
“We shall see how peninsula-based parties particularly PKR treat local-based parties and the Borneo territories. We will see from this election how far the mindset of our Borneon people has changed towards the all-conquering and condescending peninsular Malaysians,” he told FMT.
Marajin said the election will show if PKR or Umno’s dominance is accepted by the people or if the government-controlled media have effectively indoctrinated and brainwashed the people.
“We may also learn from here whether corruption and cheating in the election are so rampant that people are powerless to ward off this evil.
“How far we have grown in our political maturity to be able to discern good governance which respects our rights as citizens…?” he asked.
Political observer Dr Anthony Tibok agreed that interest in the Sarawak election among Sabahans is evident, but there is a lack of in-depth news on the matter.
“I am among those who are interested to know how PKR behaved in the negotiation for seats,” he said of the failed PKR-SNAP negotiation.
A local political analyst, who only wanted to be known as Jimmy, also agreed that the Sarawak state election will have a bearing on the mindset of Sabahans when they face their own election, which may be called together with the 13th general election.
“It is interesting to see how Sarawakians see and perceive Taib’s way of governing the large state after more than 30 years in power. There are so many allegations about Taib’s personal life including his assets which are said to be in the billions, not counting his children’s assets.
“We will also like to see how state-based opposition parties like SNAP and the Peninsula-based parties PKR and DAP fare in this election.
“Sabah-based opposition parties like SAPP, too, I believe, will take the cue from what is hapenning in Sarawak,” he said.
Unlike in the past, Sabahans are watching the Sarawak polls with keen interest, as the outcome may have bearing on their own state polls.
KOTA KINABALU: As the Sarawak state election gets underway, Sabahans, unlike before, are following closely what is going on across the border.
Many Sabahans see the Sarawak state polls this time as a barometer of sorts which will have an impact on Sabah. The fate of Sarawak Chief Minister Taib Mahmud is also a focal point of interest.
Local opposition party Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) supreme council member Peter Marajin said the Sarawak election is interesting as it will have a bearing on Sabah’s own state election.
“We shall see how peninsula-based parties particularly PKR treat local-based parties and the Borneo territories. We will see from this election how far the mindset of our Borneon people has changed towards the all-conquering and condescending peninsular Malaysians,” he told FMT.
Marajin said the election will show if PKR or Umno’s dominance is accepted by the people or if the government-controlled media have effectively indoctrinated and brainwashed the people.
“We may also learn from here whether corruption and cheating in the election are so rampant that people are powerless to ward off this evil.
“How far we have grown in our political maturity to be able to discern good governance which respects our rights as citizens…?” he asked.
Political observer Dr Anthony Tibok agreed that interest in the Sarawak election among Sabahans is evident, but there is a lack of in-depth news on the matter.
“I am among those who are interested to know how PKR behaved in the negotiation for seats,” he said of the failed PKR-SNAP negotiation.
A local political analyst, who only wanted to be known as Jimmy, also agreed that the Sarawak state election will have a bearing on the mindset of Sabahans when they face their own election, which may be called together with the 13th general election.
“It is interesting to see how Sarawakians see and perceive Taib’s way of governing the large state after more than 30 years in power. There are so many allegations about Taib’s personal life including his assets which are said to be in the billions, not counting his children’s assets.
“We will also like to see how state-based opposition parties like SNAP and the Peninsula-based parties PKR and DAP fare in this election.
“Sabah-based opposition parties like SAPP, too, I believe, will take the cue from what is hapenning in Sarawak,” he said.
Saturday, April 2, 2011
Jeffrey to help Snap regain its glory
Luke Rintod

KOTA KINABALU: Former PKR vice-president Dr Jeffrey Kitingan and his supporters are set to throw their support behind Sarawak National Party (Snap) candidates rather than PKR in the Sarawak state election.
They are understood to have held discussions with Snap leaders in Kuching and Miri to build some form of co-operation and a businessman from Kuala Lumpur, a former PKR associate, is said to be helping in the process.
FMT learnt that Jeffrey’s group though still party-less, would “officially” help Snap and Jeffrey himself would spend most of his time campaigning in areas surrounding Kuching.
His henchmen from United Borneo Front (UBF) and those who are still party-less, after exiting PKR, would depart for Miri, Bintulu and Kuching from April 5 on the eve of nomination day to help Snap’s quest to win Dayak seats.
The group was tightlipped on their programmes and had so far restrained anybody from the group from openly supporting Snap.
It is no secret though that Jeffrey is attempting to form a United Borneo Alliance, linking Snap with a Sabah party, which is currently still non-existent.
According to insiders, Jeffrey also played a role in influencing Snap not to put up candidates in areas PKR is putting known credible Dayak candidates such as Baru Bian, Nicholas Bawin Anggat, Mengga Mikui and a few others as a goodwill gesture to Pakatan Rakyat, the opposition umbrella.
“We would be following our Dayak brothers to campaign in long-houses, and give our opinion why a state-based party like Snap is important for the short and long terms to be supported by the locals,” said a former Sabah PKR leader who is an ally of Jeffrey.
Nomination for the Sarawak polls has been fixed for April 6 while polling is on April 16.
Unlikely settlement
A resurgent SNAP has been embroiled in overlapping claims with Peninsular-based PKR on the Dayak seats. There are about 30 Dayaks seats in the 71-seat state assembly.
Snap, basically a Dayak-based party, though multi-racial in concept, is not giving up its “right” in those seats, which are also being eyed by PKR.
Within the national and state PKR innermost circle, it is their belief that PKR would win in many Dayak seats, if it is a one-to-one fight with Barisan Nasional.
This explains the intense lobbying by PKR for the Dayak-majority seats, and in the process angering many who would like to see the once-glorious Snap making a comeback.
PKR however failed to acknowledge this Dayak nationalism and instead pushed the Sarawak party to contest in just three initially but later four Dayak seats, which to many Sarawakians, is a gross insult to the local party.
“We would contest in about 30 seats if we have a deal. But first PKR must solve their problem of overlapping lists,” said Snap leader Paul Kadang on Thursday.
Snap, he said, would not buckle down to PKR’s desire to contest in 52 seats.
As negotiations go on, it appears pressure from respective supporters of both parties would make it difficult for Snap and PKR to reach an amicable solution.
Sabah's political maverick Dr Jeffrey Kitingan and his supporters will be backing Snap instead of PKR in the Sarawak state polls.
KOTA KINABALU: Former PKR vice-president Dr Jeffrey Kitingan and his supporters are set to throw their support behind Sarawak National Party (Snap) candidates rather than PKR in the Sarawak state election.
They are understood to have held discussions with Snap leaders in Kuching and Miri to build some form of co-operation and a businessman from Kuala Lumpur, a former PKR associate, is said to be helping in the process.
FMT learnt that Jeffrey’s group though still party-less, would “officially” help Snap and Jeffrey himself would spend most of his time campaigning in areas surrounding Kuching.
His henchmen from United Borneo Front (UBF) and those who are still party-less, after exiting PKR, would depart for Miri, Bintulu and Kuching from April 5 on the eve of nomination day to help Snap’s quest to win Dayak seats.
The group was tightlipped on their programmes and had so far restrained anybody from the group from openly supporting Snap.
It is no secret though that Jeffrey is attempting to form a United Borneo Alliance, linking Snap with a Sabah party, which is currently still non-existent.
According to insiders, Jeffrey also played a role in influencing Snap not to put up candidates in areas PKR is putting known credible Dayak candidates such as Baru Bian, Nicholas Bawin Anggat, Mengga Mikui and a few others as a goodwill gesture to Pakatan Rakyat, the opposition umbrella.
“We would be following our Dayak brothers to campaign in long-houses, and give our opinion why a state-based party like Snap is important for the short and long terms to be supported by the locals,” said a former Sabah PKR leader who is an ally of Jeffrey.
Nomination for the Sarawak polls has been fixed for April 6 while polling is on April 16.
Unlikely settlement
A resurgent SNAP has been embroiled in overlapping claims with Peninsular-based PKR on the Dayak seats. There are about 30 Dayaks seats in the 71-seat state assembly.
Snap, basically a Dayak-based party, though multi-racial in concept, is not giving up its “right” in those seats, which are also being eyed by PKR.
Within the national and state PKR innermost circle, it is their belief that PKR would win in many Dayak seats, if it is a one-to-one fight with Barisan Nasional.
This explains the intense lobbying by PKR for the Dayak-majority seats, and in the process angering many who would like to see the once-glorious Snap making a comeback.
PKR however failed to acknowledge this Dayak nationalism and instead pushed the Sarawak party to contest in just three initially but later four Dayak seats, which to many Sarawakians, is a gross insult to the local party.
“We would contest in about 30 seats if we have a deal. But first PKR must solve their problem of overlapping lists,” said Snap leader Paul Kadang on Thursday.
Snap, he said, would not buckle down to PKR’s desire to contest in 52 seats.
As negotiations go on, it appears pressure from respective supporters of both parties would make it difficult for Snap and PKR to reach an amicable solution.
Thursday, March 31, 2011
PKR-Snap haggling over seats continues
Stephen Tiong
Although the PKR, DAP and PAS have finally managed to agree on the sharing of seats for the Sarawak state elections, negotiations between PKR and Snap are still ongoing.
"The talks between PKR and Snap are still on. We hope to reach a decision by April 4," Baru (right) said. "This matter will be resolved in the spirit of Pakatan Rakyat, just as we from PKR, DAP and PAS have agreed on the seat allocations."
Baru said Snap was adamant about the seats it wanted to contest, "but we hope that they will be flexible and get back to us before April 4".
He remains optimistic about solving the seat allocation problem with Snap, "unless it is not possible anymore to discuss with them", adding that PKR did not have any 'Plan B' in the event Snap was not agreeable to a compromise solution.
"I also do not want PKR to be portrayed as a party that does not want to resolve its problem with Snap. The ball is now in Snap's court. It is up to them to take it."
Although the PKR, DAP and PAS have finally managed to agree on the sharing of seats for the Sarawak state elections, negotiations between PKR and Snap are still ongoing.
According to PKR state chief Baru Bian, Snap has agreed to concede six out of the 27 Dayak-majority seats to PKR and talks over the remaining 21 seats remain unresolved.
All four parties were suppose to name their respective seats last night during a press conference. Snap leaders were missing from the event.
Baru said Snap was adamant about the seats it wanted to contest, "but we hope that they will be flexible and get back to us before April 4".
He remains optimistic about solving the seat allocation problem with Snap, "unless it is not possible anymore to discuss with them", adding that PKR did not have any 'Plan B' in the event Snap was not agreeable to a compromise solution.
"I also do not want PKR to be portrayed as a party that does not want to resolve its problem with Snap. The ball is now in Snap's court. It is up to them to take it."
Seat swap on give-and-take basis
State DAP chief DAP Wong Ho Leng said his party switched the Batu Lintang seat for PKR's Pandungan on a "give and take basis".
The party would name its candidates in the southern region of Sarawak on Saturday and those for the northern region seats on Sunday.
The other seats DAP will contest are Pending, Kota Sentosa, Batu Kawah, Simanggang, Meradong, Repok, Bukit Assek, Pelawan, Dudong, Bawang Assan, Kidurong, Pujut, Piasau and Bukit Kota.
Wong (left) said PKR, DAP and PAS were able to agree on seat allocations because they gave priority to the party that was best able to win the seats for Pakatan.
"Incumbency was never an issue in our negotiations over the seats," he added.
Sarawak PAS commissioner Adam Ahid said his party will do battle in the Tanjung Datu, Muara Tuang, Sadong Jaya, Sebuyau and Beting Maro seats.
"We are very happy to be allocated these five seats," Adam said, adding that all the party's candidates are professionals with high moral values.
PAS contested in three seats in the 2006 state election and narrowly lost Saribas.
State DAP chief DAP Wong Ho Leng said his party switched the Batu Lintang seat for PKR's Pandungan on a "give and take basis".
The party would name its candidates in the southern region of Sarawak on Saturday and those for the northern region seats on Sunday.
Wong (left) said PKR, DAP and PAS were able to agree on seat allocations because they gave priority to the party that was best able to win the seats for Pakatan.
"Incumbency was never an issue in our negotiations over the seats," he added.
Sarawak PAS commissioner Adam Ahid said his party will do battle in the Tanjung Datu, Muara Tuang, Sadong Jaya, Sebuyau and Beting Maro seats.
"We are very happy to be allocated these five seats," Adam said, adding that all the party's candidates are professionals with high moral values.
PAS contested in three seats in the 2006 state election and narrowly lost Saribas.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











